Too fat for a pony?!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well I'm 8 and a half stone and I love riding a 18.2hh horse.

Do you think he'll carry me okay? I'll try and post pics to check... :D

(sorry nothing useful to add, as usual, you know me, I'll shut up now.)


Oooh Mints Stumps is lush!!
 
DSC_8774.jpg


My friend riding my Highland mare. Friend is 5ft 8 and 12/13 stone in weight. Poppy is just 13 hands. Don't you just love Highlands?
 
IMO a well made Highland or Icelandic could undoubtedly carry more weight comfortably than Mrs P - all 16.2 of her. OK, she has plenty of bone, but she's too long backed & weak in the loin to be a true weight carrier and I think that can be said for a lot of bigger horses. How many of the taller breeds were actually bred to carry heavy loads? Most of them were bred to pull things, and the dynamics involved are completely different. Having a low centre of gravity is a very good idea if you're carrying something relatively heavy, the 'action at a distance' forces are much easier to manage.

ps I plan to succumb to middle aged spread and kidnap Fakur one day ;)
 
For an old woman you are very good at using a computer. I know most old women I know wouldnt even know how to switch one on, let alone multi quote! :D :D

Oh wait I am making a generalisation.... ;)

You are indeed. I also happen to find the ageism implicit in the statement "for an old woman you are ..." to be condescending, if not somewhat insulting.

I - and many others, of course - was using mainframes thirty and forty years ago, and using elegant programming language, too. Computers did not enter the living rooms of the inhabitants of the Western world fully fledged from a magic egg, you know. We 'old women' and 'old men' were the ones instrumental in inventing the bloomin' things!

Have you ever heard of the DEC PDP 11? That special buddy of mine which operated the second EMI body scanner to enter clinical use in the late 1970s had a 16-bit limit on logical addresses and we had rack after rack of tape reels for storing what by present standards is minimal data ... so the progression has been a gradual and fairly painless one for many of us oldies. I went back to Linux as an OS a good few years ago when I got tired of the prescriptive and restrictive limitations of Windows.

Having a low centre of gravity is a very good idea if you're carrying something relatively heavy, the 'action at a distance' forces are much easier to manage.

Thank you for a much clearer and more concise explanation than I could have attempted!

A smaller, shorter legged horse will inevitably have a lower centre of gravity than that of a taller horse, regardless of the weight of the rider - and that can clearly only be a good thing in a weight-carrying animal. A rider's body length and weight remains the same whether they be on a short horse or a tall one, and will have less destabilising influence on a lower CG than on one which is higher.
 
At the age of almost 70, having arthritis and being barely 5ft tall, I do of course need - and have - a mounting block for my 15.1hh mare. As I usually ride 10 -15 miles a day and often more, over rough countryside with gated roads and cattle-grids to negotiate, I would love you to explain to me just how I can carry this mounting block round the countryside with me. it seems much more sensible to me to eventually replace my mare with something at least 2 hands shorter, and who I will be able to mount without having to clamber up gates and walls and trees like an arthritic monkey.

I don't know if it would help you but I have a thing that fits into the stirrup but folds up pocket sized for when I'm out riding. Its basically 2 weighted flattish bars with webbing straps that hold them together, not a brilliant description, sorry. You slid it sideways into the stirrup and as the weighted bars are wider than the stirrup it doesn't fall out then you use the lower bar as a stirrup to mount. I needed it for remounting from the floor, as I'm not very agile anymore, when I had a 17'2 that I rode sidesaddle. I had just pressed submit when I remembered where I bought the stirrup mount! They still sell them on Robinsons website and they're £5.50.[/QUOTE]

Old Woman personally I don't dismount when out and about hence no requirement for a step out of the yard but there are portable stirrup extensions you can buy from Robinsons etc.

.



You are indeed. I also happen to find the ageism implicit in the statement "for an old woman you are ..." to be condescending, if not somewhat insulting.

I - and many others, of course - was using mainframes thirty and forty years ago, and using elegant programming language, too. Computers did not enter the living rooms of the inhabitants of the Western world fully fledged from a magic egg, you know. We 'old women' and 'old men' were the ones instrumental in inventing the bloomin' things!



.



Shandy, saying "I don't dismount when I'm out hacking" is the sort of remark that looks like tempting fate to me ... All of us dismount at some time or other, whether intentionally or not. Old Woman, as long as you can manage to clamber up gates and the rest, you haven't got a problem :D I'm not quite as old as you, but not as fit either, and I'm still happy (well fairly happy!) using whatever's at hand to scramble on by ... And I don't think I'd be able to mount even the wonderful Fakur from the ground.


And wildponies, I agree with OW - age has nothing whatever to do with being a competent computer user. And a winky smiley doesn't make an offensive remark acceptable.
 
Old woman, I am holding you responsible for my tea sprayed monitor. Rollerskates and a shetland indeed...

Anybody who is being harrassed for being too 'heavy' at 13-17 stones, come here and ride one of our quarter horses.

Marshal_Coker-small.jpg


13-17 hands depending on line and blood percentage (taller ones tend to be part tb and leaner while the shorter ones are big boned, stocky and powerful, and routinely ridden by 250 lb cowboys + their tack).
 
Styric nobody is saying NO HORSE can carry them just VERY FEW PONIES.

Christ just from expressing a differing opinion to some members has resulted in myself and a few other members being chastised for having an opinion.

I am sorry but I feel the rider should be suitably mounted, that means a novice of 16stone with tack would way a darn sight more than an experienced rider with a good seat at the same weight now, plonk that weight on the poor ponies back and see how long its working life is!

It is a very similar reason why their are weight limits at RS they know people who are novices ride heavy and will cause more problems for their horses.

There are a number on here who say it's fine no probs etc maybe you are just in that blissful stage before you get the problems, I have no issue with Fjords, Welsh Ds etc of good conformation carrying that weight but would not reccomend you push the weight carrying ability too far as you will end up with the horse suffering for it.

There is a rule of thumb with most ponies that you should not make them carry over 20% of their own bodyweight, it will have exceptions that can carry somewhat more but for the horses sake I would stick to that rule to ensure a happy and healthy horse into their older years.

Linda I am not in the habit of dismounting while out, does not mean I cannot remount should I require it, but I would always get on from something as not doing so will also damage the horses back.
 
Here you go, here is my "little pony". He could carry you both - probably together;) I have no idea what breed he is but I guess a native something:rolleyes:

IMG_0629.jpg
 
This is getting ridiculous. If the OP does want to ride a horse under 14.2 then maybe she could get away with it on a few occasions. BUT her husband, as she has stated, is 16 stone, and I wouldn't want to put this weight on any pony so I don't think Shandy is wrong or rude to suggest that if they do want to ride horses under this height then they should lose weight.

i echo that :rolleyes: but then doesn't EVERY thread, regarding weight end up getting into a very heated debate making the 0P feel very embarrassed and awkward??
I have similar questions but wouldn't dare ask this forum :o
 
Old woman, I am holding you responsible for my tea sprayed monitor. Rollerskates and a shetland indeed...

Anybody who is being harrassed for being too 'heavy' at 13-17 stones, come here and ride one of our quarter horses.

Marshal_Coker-small.jpg


13-17 hands depending on line and blood percentage (taller ones tend to be part tb and leaner while the shorter ones are big boned, stocky and powerful, and routinely ridden by 250 lb cowboys + their tack).

000h don't tempt me!!! I have ALWAYS wanted to ride one of these beautiful animals!! x
 
Fákur is a very polite lad, but I do agree he would tell you, but only with a lot of tail swishing, if you were doing anything he was not happy about! :D :D


When my back is bad he will take me for a ride and he knows, you know. Everyone else will gallop up the canter track and I don't even need to hold him back, reins like washing lines and he walks after them, he's a dear boy.
 
A smaller, shorter legged horse will inevitably have a lower centre of gravity than that of a taller horse, regardless of the weight of the rider - and that can clearly only be a good thing in a weight-carrying animal. A rider's body length and weight remains the same whether they be on a short horse or a tall one, and will have less destabilising influence on a lower CG than on one which is higher.

If that's true, then why is it much more difficult for both my pony and myself if I ride my 10.3 section A compared with my 14.1 highland? I'm not too heavy for him, but he finds my height more difficult to cope with.

You surely have to consider the original centre of gravity of the horse, that of the rider and that of the combination of the two. With a smaller horse, the relative shift of the centre of gravity of the horse to that of the combination will be greater. So although the height of the rider doesn't change, no matter what they ride, what they ride has a huge impact on the stability of the combination.

Centre of gravity, however, is dictated by both height and weight. So dismissing any weight carrying ability, then a lightweight pony of a certain size will find carrying someone more difficult than a heavier pony of the same height because the rider:pony weight ratio is higher and therefore the centre of gravity will shift further towards that of the rider.

Any horse is capable of coping with its own centre of gravity, as it's what they have grown up with. By adding a rider, that is shifted and it is how far that shift is that will dictate whether they find it difficult to balance the rider or not (as I say, ignoring any confirmational weight carrying ability). It is not the height of the horse that is therefore a "problem" in that way and a shorter or taller horse will not really have an impact. It is the relative weight of horse and rider that is the critical factor.
 
My eyes must be decieving me because I could swear the OP asked "are there ponies around the 14hh mark that could carry my/OH's weight? what sort of breeds should we be looking at?" and not "can all small ponies carry 16 stone?"

At no point did the OP imply she was going to go out and buy a Newforest or a Welsh Sec A, I really don't see how a lot of the replies have had any relevance to the OP's perfectly reasonable question.

I actually applaud the OP for spending the time to research and consider what size and breed of horse she might feel comfortable riding and would be suitable for her. In answer to the original question, as plenty of people have already said breeds such as the Highland and Icelandic are perfectly capable of carrying a 16 stone man, and have done for hundreds of years! :)
 
Styric nobody is saying NO HORSE can carry them just VERY FEW PONIES.

If you'd read the part where I mentioned size, quite a few come below 'pony' stature. In fact 14 hands is common. You're telling me a 13.3-14.1 QH suddenly has a higher weight limit than an equivalent size pony of similar build (which quite a few native ponies I've met are), and if so how so and what is so different about their structure?
 
And wildponies, I agree with OW - age has nothing whatever to do with being a competent computer user. And a winky smiley doesn't make an offensive remark acceptable.

I was being sarcastic :rolleyes:

And as for 'offensive marks' being 'acceptable' or not.

HAHAHA!!

You might want to remind 'old woman' of that, as she has made derogatory remarks about the disabilities of posters in this thread.

Zingy - thank you for that educational and informative post. It's always nice reading posts so full of knowledge and understanding. :)
 
Oh my - it's a good job I'm not of a sensitive nature otherwise I would have been scared away by some of this! I haven't had the chance to read everything yet, but just to clear a few things up:

1) The whole point I asked the original question is to make sure I wouldn't be too heavy for a pony / smaller horse, therefore the animal's welfare is my highest priority, otherwise I would just go out blind and buy something unsuitable. If I was too heavy, I'd either go for a larger horse or go without.

2) I said my OH might want to learn to ride IF the pony / horse could take his weight - it wouldn't be a regular thing, just a way of him getting involved a bit more (he's actually terrified of horses so the fact he is even interested in learning means a lot). But even if he did learn, he wouldn't be a regular rider and it would probably just be a case of plodding around the arena on a lunge rain. And I've already said I would want a pony / horse that could comfortably carry his weight, not something that would struggle.

3) I have no intention of losing weight thank you very much - I have no desire to be a twig, and I like the padding in case I fall off! :p And my OH is a very fit rugby player, his weight is because of his stockiness - it's not like we're both carrying round huge beer bellies!

4) I do actually have a knee and back problem after a riding accident several years ago, which makes mounting / lifting saddles high difficult. It's ok in the yard if I can use a mounting block or wall (or bench in our case), but I wouldn't like to get caught out on a hack, and I'd rather get a smaller pony than struggle every time I needed to tack up or change a rug - at 14hh, the pony's back would be at about chin level. At 15.1hh it is above my eye level. It may not seem a big difference, but it is. A few inches can make all the difference ;)

I'll have a proper read through everything tonight, as I need to haul my big fat ass back to work now, but thanks to everyone who has given advice so far!

:D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
newrider.com