Who's stabled 24/7?

One of the main reasons I left my first yard was because of lack of turnout. Although techincally you are not doing anything cruel by keeping horses in 24/7 it is not good for them mentally - and for mine - physically, as their legs swelled up. I know we have to make the most of the situations we are put in - had I known that the yard had a keeping in policy all winter I would not have gone there. As a novice owner and rider I was very ill advised and I knew no better. I know there are yards which keep horses in 24/7 such as racing yards (I might be wrong but I don't think they get turnout as such). I always think of it like this: if somebody made me sit in our downstairs bathroom (which is tiny) for 24 hours I would be pretty fed up, despite being given 2 meals a day!!!! Plus, the other way of looking at it is this: when the horse does eventually get turned out its more likely to injure itself having a hooley! (some people believe winter turnout to be dangerous and detrimental to their health). It sounds like you are doing your best by riding or lunging every day - but if it were me - and my horses I would have to consider a yard move - I mean, the glorious weather we've been having lately must be driving the horses nuts being kept in!
 
saying keeping them out during winter is bad for their health, im afraid i disagree, horses in the wild do not have the option of going into a stable all day to keep dry and clean, they grow coats to protect them selves, and they survive very well like this, there is no reason why we cant do the same for ours, ok we have to use artificial coats as we clip etc etc but they should still be allowed turnout! being locked in ** bedroom all day everyday with no tv, 2 meals a day and a drink on supply for the rest of your life would prob send you nuts, as it does some horses. some people cant help the sittuation they are in tho and like u said uhave to work with what u have! but i think the issue is on people who choose to stable 24/7 for no realreason,,,to keep the horse clean isnt a fair excuse! i can understand if you have a show horse you dont want them getting muddy and dirty but i think where you have the turnout, use it.
 
My girl is stabled throughout winter due to fields being flooded as they arnt the best draining. Every morning she is turned out in the sandschool with her best mate and stays out most of the day with haynets dotted around. She is ridden 5 days per week also. This is the best we can do until the fields dry out. I woundnt keep her in the stable all day ever, unless she was on box rest!
 
Being rather new here and new to owning a horse, I tend not to answer any questions specific to horse management because I dont consider my little knowlage of any use.
Most of my friends have horse that live out 27/7 and I used to think that keeping a horse stabled 24/7 was cruel .

BUT

My daughter has a part/loan pony{kept at its own yard} who can suffer very bad laminitis, she is stabled most of the time because she has to share time in a no grass paddock with other laminitec's and also a stallion, so she has to wait her turn.
every effort to allow her to be turned out didnt work, grazing muzzles didnt either, we go to her everyday, and is either riden ,lunged, taken for walk or put in paddock whilst her stable is mucked out ect, but she is drug free, healthy and well cared for.
I have now seen that sometimes comprimises have to be made and wont judge a situation on first sight, we consider ourselves lucky to have her and love her to bits.

Ducks under table now to hide
 
I know of other ponies like that - mostly stabled due to laminitis issues. However ideal turnout is, you can't sacrifice the pony's health for that ideal!
 
Hi
My guy 21 and starts coughing and gets swollen legs when stabled 24/7- I moved yards 7 months ago as I do not like to keep my horses in 24/7- I have my own field and my guy has been out all this week - well rugged with loads of hay and feed twice a day-I do stable him when wet as he hates rain and wind and the field offers no shelter- We had a week last month when he was in 24/7 for 4 days- I could not go back to 24/7 for 4 months of the year- That is the only reason I moved yards.
 
sometimes you have to, its not ideal but there are reasons for it. i've only done it when J has been on box rest and although he didn't mind, he would rather have been out i think! the posh yard up the road has a "free use of horsewalker if you keep hoss stabled" policy, which i can't abide personally :mad:
 
Skye's been in 24/7 stabling for weeks now. She has a back injury and her vet doesn't want her to move. In some cases it is cruel (young or very fit horses) but it would be even more cruel to have her outside.

In 1 and a half weeks (and counting :D) she goes out to half day turnout.

In winter during the worst month where it rains non-stop for about 5 weeks she'll be in 24/7 again. She panics when it is raining and bucks. By bucking she pulls the muscles in her back, which is why she is in 24/7 in the first place.

It is unfair for people to say that 24/7 turnout is cruel. It is not always cruel. Sometimes it is greatly needed, more than turnout.
 
The phrase 'can of worms' springs to mind lol. :p

I think it's unfair to say being stabled 24/7 is cruel. I know it's not ideal but like I said, Mol is stabled not through choice, but through yard policy and I love my yard so moving isnt an option anyway. She is exercised every day for an hour plus, and I try to turn her out in the sand paddock when I muck out etc. She seems happy enough - and if she's happy then so am I. :D
 
This was posted about on previous thread by willielove and this was the answer I gave: -

http://www.newrider.com/forum/showthread.php?t=136047&highlight=willielove

WL is seems your getting a lot of stick for keeping your horse stabled 24//7, so I'm going to stick up for you here, I agree it's far from ideal but sometimes needs must.

I keep mine stabled 24/7 in the winter from about November - April/May, in between that times she is turned out if I'm lucky about 5-6 times, we have limited turnout to save grazing for the summer and we all abide by those rules. It is not ideal but it is popular around here and I put up with it for a number of personal reasons some of which I have control over and some of which I don't. But generally all the horses on our yard are happy they know the routine and have lived liked this for many years now with winters in.

It hasn't created any problems with behavioural problems like cribbing, wind sucking, weaving, box walking or the like. The first few weeks they're pretty fresh as they're fit from lots of summer work but soon settle into the routine and remain (relatively ;) ) well behaved healthy and happy horses.

I think in an ideal world we would all have access to 24/7 turnout 12-months a year but we don't and I think getting all evangenical about it and denouncing people as cruel and basically unfit to be horse owners is out of order and getting a little tedious. I challenge anyone to come to my yard and tell me my horse is mistreated, miserable and subject to cruelty.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TiddlerandButters
I have a horse stabled 24/7 thoughout the winter, his choice not mine, my others all go out during the day but he wont, if by chance you do manage to catch him off guard and get him into the field he stands by the gate all day refusing to eat or drink till someone gets him back in, he's thoroughly miserable being out in winter and his lack of eating/drinking usually ends up in impaction colic, after yet another episode of him with colic last winter my vet has insisted that he stay in 24/7 and guess what?? no colic and a happy horse, he's so much happier and chilled as he's not stressing about the cold and lack of grass and making himself miserable, he's warm, out of the wind with a constant supply of feed, anyone who says stabled horses are miserable obviously haven't met him he loves it :)
 
I have a horse stabled 24/7 thoughout the winter, his choice not mine, my others all go out during the day but he wont, if by chance you do manage to catch him off guard and get him into the field he stands by the gate all day refusing to eat or drink till someone gets him back in, he's thoroughly miserable being out in winter and his lack of eating/drinking usually ends up in impaction colic, after yet another episode of him with colic last winter my vet has insisted that he stay in 24/7 and guess what?? no colic and a happy horse, he's so much happier and chilled as he's not stressing about the cold and lack of grass and making himself miserable, he's warm, out of the wind with a constant supply of feed, anyone who says stabled horses are miserable obviously haven't met him he loves it :)

Lol Rascal is like that too! He stands by the gate and at best munches a haynet attached to it!
 
Even a little bit of T/O is better than none

My land is a mud bath at the moment but I would rather have land like that and turn mine out in the day.
They cant wait to get out in a morning and are really reluctant to come in at night unless the weather is really bad.
Even if I didnt have a paddock to churn up, I would turn them out in a menarge or something.
I am afraid I dislike 24 hour stabling unless there is good reason.
Think how you would feel in bed 24/7 for the winter, through no choice of your own:).
 
Last winter Daffy was in from mid september, until easter, which was early april I believe. This year however, he didn't cope, they were brought in at the end of October. On Christmas day I made the decision to look for an alternative yard, he was almost crippled with stiffness and other issues, but if I wasn't able to find the right yard, we would stay put and I would try some other things to help him.

Luckily we found a lovely yard, where he gets to go out almost every day at least for a few hours, if he's stuck in, he gets worked in a good school. I still get the chance to look over at the old yard, and although they've had a couple of days out since we left in January, they will be really restricted until it has been dry for at least a week. Apparently the YO there is getting tighter on turnout every year.

Like I say, we were lucky that the option was there for us. :)

ETA, these threads always seem to go on about how cruel it is to keep horses in 24/7. Not everybody has the choice, some horses prefer it, so perhaps if you can't answer the question - that is if your horse is in 24/7, how long will it be in for, maybe you could start your own thread?
 
Last edited:
Just to add to this can of worms...
My mu has an arab mare who loathes going out - even though we all know it is the best for her she hates it and will out herself at considerable risk... ie/ running through wire etc etc
The vets has also said that although it should be the best thing for her - it is not what she wants and is not safe for her... So she contentidly goes for walks instead...
She is VERY heavily in foal - we think she's having a litter!!! lol x
 
I think it is definitely bordering on cruelty keeping a horse locked in all day for months on end for no good reason, unless the horsey truly despises being out and not just wants to come in out of habit. personally I would just rent grazing and stuff the livery. If their fields flood they should invest in drainage or at least make a dry turnout area like a large sand school or something. Bringing a horse inside at night isn't too bad, but not in during the day. It is so unnatural to keep a horse locked in all the time. :(
 
Last edited:
I have added to these posts in the past and will again...

All 120 horses at my barn are stables 24/7..... there isnt really any permanent turn out due to constraints of space and sometimes its just too damn hot !

If people will steal your cat or dog for their next meal, imagine how many people can feast on a horse !!

so NO I will not be renting a field and turning mine out :rolleyes:
 
If people will steal your cat or dog for their next meal, imagine how many people can feast on a horse !!

so NO I will not be renting a field and turning mine out :rolleyes:

Totally understand - like I said in my post to this thread, you have to make the most of the situations you are put in - ie, if the culture where you are is different then so be it. It just gets me mad when I see yards where they have oodles of land and still won't let you have the odd hour!!
 
newrider.com