One of the main reasons I left my first yard was because of lack of turnout. Although techincally you are not doing anything cruel by keeping horses in 24/7 it is not good for them mentally - and for mine - physically, as their legs swelled up. I know we have to make the most of the situations we are put in - had I known that the yard had a keeping in policy all winter I would not have gone there. As a novice owner and rider I was very ill advised and I knew no better. I know there are yards which keep horses in 24/7 such as racing yards (I might be wrong but I don't think they get turnout as such). I always think of it like this: if somebody made me sit in our downstairs bathroom (which is tiny) for 24 hours I would be pretty fed up, despite being given 2 meals a day!!!! Plus, the other way of looking at it is this: when the horse does eventually get turned out its more likely to injure itself having a hooley! (some people believe winter turnout to be dangerous and detrimental to their health). It sounds like you are doing your best by riding or lunging every day - but if it were me - and my horses I would have to consider a yard move - I mean, the glorious weather we've been having lately must be driving the horses nuts being kept in!