Your feelings on using draw reins

amanti20

New Member
Apr 8, 2005
28
0
0
Do you think using draw reins to get a horse to do a headset is cruel? I am currently having a trainer use them on my horse. Someone today informed me that using these reins can place way too much stress on a horse's back.

What do you think?
 
To be honest I really don't like them. Personally I see them as a short cut, correct schooling should get you the same result and will be a lot more effective in the long run.

In inexperienced hands they are postively lethal and can cause permanent damage to the horses muscles if used incorrectly. My pony Beryl was schooled in draw reins as a baby by someone who had no business using them, all it did was teach her to overbend to escape the contact.
The focus to much on the head for my liking, outline involves the whole horse not just its head. I have seen so many horses being schooled in draw reins who are not being ridden properly. They end up with their heads tucked into their chests and because they are not being ridden though from behind the hock are trailing out behind them and a horse cannot be truly working properly like that.

You did say it is your trainer who is schooling your horse in them, so hopefully he knows what he is doing and will not fall into the traps so many people do. However what would bother me is having a trainer who thinks these are a good idea. Although they can help some horses I would much prefere to have someone training my horse who wanted to preduce the goods by correct and gentle schooling.
 
IMO draw reins should never be used to get a headset. That's not actually their real purpose anyway.

They were actually designed to be used in place of a martingale, or similar. They are designed to prevent the horse raising his head beyond the point of control - but only come into play once the horse does, and without interfering with the rein and action of the bit in the mouth as a running martingale does, or encouraging the horse to lean on them, as a standing martingale can.

Unfortunately they do also do a nice job of reeling a horse's nose in and making his headset look pretty to some people's eye - so that's what most people use them for. Used in that way they can very quickly cause irreperable damage to the tendons and muscles in the neck and don't actually achieve true flexion or engagement either.

I'm not a fan to be honest....
 
Sorry if I am being forthright but the ONLY way to get a horse to hold it's head "properly" is to develop the back and quarter muscles to enable it to do so for itself. Draw reins are not the way forward. As has been said previously they cann and do do untold damage.
 
I think this article (?) by Jessica Jahiel pretty well puts my opinion on draw reins: http://www.horse-sense.org/archives/20021109105116.phtml, which is (to me) summed up by this quote:
There's never a "right" time for draw reins, because if you're so good at riding and training that you can use them in a helpful way, you know many better, more legitimate and productive and effective ways of helping the horse, and if you aren't that good, you have no business using them at all. Interesting, isn't it? ;-)

I'd be asking the trainer a LOT of questions about why and how long for, etc. Depending on the answer, either asking them to change (if they're used for more than a minute or two) or looking for a new trainer :(.
 
mm..

Hmm ... Draw reins ... not really my first option ... I agree - it is a short cut, but unfortunately it works quite well.

One major problem that comes with these and other things used to pull a horses' head down is they rely on them - no string=no work. I agree, if you put the effort into it, it will be much more rewarding :) I guess I wouldnt mind them if they had a long setting (not with contact), but enough so if the horse threw his head about on the lunge it would give a small tug to remind him not to do that, but lose enough for him to move WITH NO contact ... dunno. I havent ever used them, and dont plan to.

My sis occasionally rides with a draw stringy thing that attaches to the girth, through the snaffle hoop and conects to the reins with a clip - I dont like this look because she goes a bit far on the forehand for my liking ... but then again I am more of a natural rider (no extra equipment) :P
 
Cheeky said:
Hmm ... Draw reins ... not really my first option ... I agree - it is a short cut, but unfortunately it works quite well.

I don't agree. It can appear to work quite well, because the horse's nose usually drops right down onto the vertical thanks to the way the rein works - they don't actually have a choice when draw reins are used to get a headset. But they don't actually work for two very important reasons - the first is that draw reins cause the horse to flex not *at* the poll, where you'd want him to for a nice headset, but further down - this is not true felxion at all. And secondly, and most importantly, the best headset will always be one that results from the horse dropping down into the bridle and softening because he's lifting his back, rounding, and working through from the hindquarters. Draw reins cannot replicate that - so no, they don't work. They approximate an outline, whilst at the same time making it harder to actually achieve that.
 
what do i think of draw reins?? hate them. they are no subsitiute for correct schooling. best place for them is tightly round the riders neck IMO.
 
I dont like them, but I have used them on Boo before. She'd snapped her martingale (managed to get herself caught up on a jump wing after a refusal), so my instructress gave them to me to use. She went nicely, but I've never used them since because they seem to pull the horse into an outline, rather than asking it to stretch into one. My instructress was watching me the entire time though, and I got told off whenever I tried to shorten them too much.

Jessica
 
i HATE drawrains. a headset should be obtained by exersizes to help the horse stretch and get it naturally, and with lots of work and practice, not by a cruel artificial device.
 
I'm really not a fan of draw reins but, if used correctly and sparingly, can be benificial.

I've used them once on Pink to help show her what I wanted. She seemed to have no idea that I wanted her lower her head - she built so that when she's balanced and stepping under, she has a very high head carriage (arably, although she's a heavy cob :rolleyes: ). I rode her for 15mins in draw reins, only using them very occasinally (they were fitted as a second pair of reins), when she brought her head too high. For 99% of the time, I never had a contact on them. She every quickly got the idea and it haven't needed to use them again. Since then, I've very occasinally used a market harbough, which as a similar but nicer effect.

So, they can be ok in gentle hands, but generally they're abused.
 
I don't think I'll ever be able to use things like that on a horse. I personally don't agree with using any equipment on a horse other than a bridle unless needed (ie, a saddle when learning something new. In my case this only really applies to anything other than flatwork, so my jumping lessons. I don't use a saddle outside of those lessons)

Even then, I'm one of those people who's dream is not to compete in the grand prix ring but to ride bridleless- to the extent of not using one of those ropes around the neck. I want to buy a young horse and start fromt he ground up and one day ride with the horse completely bare. But most people don't have that goal. :p

In my opinion, anything other than a bridle and saddle are short-cuts. They don't teach a horse or the rider anything. In a way, it's like locking away experience and information. then one day if your thrown on a horse that developes this problem in the middle of the ride, you won't have a clue as to what to do. I'm just gung ho, however. I also don't believe in nosebands, severe poll action (so basically leverage bits) and anything stronger than your general loose twisted wire snaffle.

I do believe that horses are doing us a favor by letting us on their backs and that we need to respect that gift at the highest level. I'm sure you wouldn't want to carry someone around with your head tied down, mouth buckled shut, and a big pinching bit of cold metal in your mouth either. I say go to a different trainer for some advice in curing the problem rathe rthan covering it up with something that's going to just cost you more money!

Refer to my quote ;)
 
hang on

Hey,

I dont like the draw reins - but they do work quite well when used correctly. As much as I kick myself for saying, they do an alright job - and they shouldnt force the horse to do anything they dont want to.

Yeah - deffantly a short cut, and it is nicer to put in the extra work so not only do you have a horse working well and understanding on the bit, but you also have the benifit of knowing that you dont need some other attachment to make your horses life any harder than it is.

But I still ***-like them.

Just curiously, how did everyone else here get their horse to go onto the bit ... seeing as we are not fond of the draw reins??
 
Cheeky said:
Hey,

I dont like the draw reins - but they do work quite well when used correctly. As much as I kick myself for saying, they do an alright job - and they shouldnt force the horse to do anything they dont want to.

Yeah - deffantly a short cut, and it is nicer to put in the extra work so not only do you have a horse working well and understanding on the bit, but you also have the benifit of knowing that you dont need some other attachment to make your horses life any harder than it is.

But I still ***-like them.

Just curiously, how did everyone else here get their horse to go onto the bit ... seeing as we are not fond of the draw reins??
In madam's case lots of schooling, and hacking on a long rein, encouraging muscular development of back and hocks so she can carry herself. She then drops onto the bit all by herself. Moss is different proposition, change the bit so he cannot stick his head out, take a long but consistent contact and lots and lots of leg. Oh sit out the temper tantrums as well!!! I have used draw reins with him once and hated it! He dropped behind the bit, went very overbent and I had nothing in front of me at all. I was later told he looked very nice!!!!!!!! He does when he is on the bit properly, feels good too.
 
Basically what Mossy said, adapted to suit whatever horse I'm riding.

Even Willow, whose conformation makes it virtually impossible to get a nice headset (sway backed so finds it almost impossible to lift and round her back and drop her nose down) and is much happier dinging along like Tigger with her nose poked up and out can, with judicious use of leg and very sympathetic hands, actually drop down into the bridle and have a nice headset. I figure if I (and I'm no great rider) can manage that on Willow with her problems (and in a simple snaffle, plain noseband and neither draw rein nor martingale in sight) then they're really not a neccessary item. ;)

Willow demonstrating nice headset with no gadgets and average rider... (forgive the huge amounts of clothing on me - it was cold!!)
 

Attachments

  • Willow.jpg
    Willow.jpg
    38.1 KB · Views: 92
Just curiously, how did everyone else here get their horse to go onto the bit ... seeing as we are not fond of the draw reins??

Mine didn't have a clue about outlines when we got her. We started having regular lessons and worked on getting her more supple and working into a contact with lots of leg. She got the idea very quickly. I swapped from a happy mouth FL to a hard rubber pelham with an elastic curb which really worked for her - the poll pressure makes it clear what you are asking for and the curb helps relax the jaw. At long last I've found a snaffle (KK ultra) that she likes as much if not better, so we're in that from now on. Correct working is well established, it was done without gadgets unless you count the pelham, and with very little force or battles along the way.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I don't agree with the use of draw reins because I have seen how they can ruin a horse when used by people who are a little too heavy on them. Someone at my old yard was a nervous rider but blamed the horse or ever mistake, held her in draw reins so tight her head was pinned to her chest and went around saying how nice she looks.

I am not against training aids, I have used one recently on Shandy, but I do feel there are better ones out there that help you achieve a natural carriage through the body and don't become to severe. The one I used recently was a bungie, Shandy knows how to use herslef just once in a while it helps to pu the bungie on for 15mins to remind her, but the big thing with the bungie is that because it is elastic she can come above the bit in it still so unless you are asking the horse properly for self carriage you won't get it.

I think on the whole they should only be used oce in a while as an aid to your training and should never be too tight that the horse cannot move away from the pressure - this is why I like ones that are fitted independent to the hands as it is harder to overtighten them accidently
 
I get my horses off the bit, not onto it. I don't appreciate having to have constant hard contact, so in all honesty, to get the horse "on" the bit, tighten your reins. However, to get mine off of the bit, I gain light rein contact and hold it there. No bumping, no tightening, and only loosening once they do what I want. What I want is for the horse to get vertical flexion and a nice working carriage of the head. I dislike the western pleasure head carriage just as much as I despize grand prix dressage head carriage. Anyway. I do this at a trot or canter/lope, not a walk. With the rein pressure, I push the horse through the bit with my legs. This doesn't cause an increase in speed because I've got light rein contact. Also, when the horse finds the loose part of the rein, that is it's reward. I will magnify it on a learning horse and push my hands forward slightly so they understand that the right thing is very comfortable and the wrong is not.

To throw out the "perfect position" ideal that tries to drill in a riders head "Hands over withers, forward, straight lines", I lower my hands extensively. I'm talking one on each side of the withers rather than over, pulling back towards my mid-thigh area. In my world this is how it should be done if you have no gadgets. Putting rein pressure on from above the withers (If I were the horse) would confuse me into raising my head rather than lowering it. The reason why *generally* you see the over-the-withers hand position in alot of english riding is that people who are really working at this in english often have some sort of martingale on. Their cheating. The reason I leave western out is because often they achieve low headseats in a different fashion. Their horses have long low necks rather than higher up working headsets, so in most cases a martingale wouldn't get the desired result.
 
newrider.com