Yard Dilemma

Mary Poppins

Well-Known Member
Oct 10, 2004
13,662
4,789
113
Visit site
Last summer, before I bought Ben I put my name down on the waiting list for the yard in my village. There was no space and so I went elsewhere. This morning I got a call telling me that there is now space for me if I want it. Now I don't know what to do. Here is my pros and cons list:

Old Yard - Pros
I LOVE it there.
So supportive, resident RI and Head Girl really do support me and give me all the advice and help I need.
Huge fields
24/7 turnout
Huge floodlit arena - 40 by 60
Hacking to nearby RS offering lessons/clinic etc. (not that I do that at the moment)
Everything is included (food,hay,straw)
Onsite farrier who the yard organise for me

Cons
It is very expensive!!!


New Yard - Pros
Much, much cheaper. 1/4 of the price that I currently pay
Much nearer my house. I could walk there in 10 minutes, or drive in 30 seconds. My current yard is a 10 minute drive away
Has all the facilities - but smaller school and smaller fields.
Has direct off road hacking
Has a very nice YO - she offers assisted DIY and lessons

Cons
Major con is that there is a footpath running through the yard so it isn't as private as I would have liked.
The school is smaller
The fields are likely to become muddy in winter
I would have more responsibility with assisted DIY - at the moment he is on part livery so if I can't get there he is taken care of.


In my heart I really dont' want to move, but if I did I could probably afford to buy a little lorry in 6 months time which would open up so many possibilities for us. What do I do? Stay on a yard I love but costs the earth, or try somewhere new which might be as good and would free us lots of extra cash? Ummmm
 
Stay where you are! If its not broke then don't fix. I appreciate the cost but quite honestly unless you are megga struggling then I would stay put.
 
Difficult you sound really happy at your present yard, but closer and cheaper is very tempting.
 
If the saving was just going back into the household pot I would say stay put! But given the standard you ride at, I expect you would get a lot of fun and value from a little lorry. Would you like to get Ben out and about to competitions? If so, I would say move and save for your lorry.
 
Ooooo difficult one! :unsure:

Id probably say...stay put. If theres nothing really making you unhappy at your present yard then id definatly stay.

As serial yard mover (About to move for the 5th time :giggle:) ive always been very sure when its time to move on.
I think your current yard sound fab, if you & Ben are happy there and get everything you need then its worth the money?
 
If you hadn't been told about the space you would be staying. I would look at the pro and con for your horse as well.
Smaller fields but are they managed? Depends on how the turnout is worked out. My friends yard will not allow them turnout at night from October to April.

What is part livery and what is assisted diy? Is that not one of the same. Have you asked because assisted sounds like turnout in the morning or change rugs and feed. Also if you make friends, people do help each other out. Though if you are that close would you need the help, would it allow you the chance to have the responsibility?
 
I decided to remove my post. Because may be your OH needs to use the car? So it would be good for your family to have the horse in walking distance? We simply dont know enough about the new yard to give a reasonable answer. Sorry.
 
Last edited:
If the saving was just going back into the household pot I would say stay put! But given the standard you ride at, I expect you would get a lot of fun and value from a little lorry. Would you like to get Ben out and about to competitions? If so, I would say move and save for your lorry.

I honestly don't ride to a very high standard, but I do want to get out and compete. On the other hand (there are always so many different ways of looking at things) my local RS does loads of competitions if I were to get my brain in gear and hack my very safe horse over there! I frustrate myself so much.
 
What is part livery and what is assisted diy? Is that not one of the same. Have you asked because assisted sounds like turnout in the morning or change rugs and feed. Also if you make friends, people do help each other out. Though if you are that close would you need the help, would it allow you the chance to have the responsibility?

The way I see it, is that with assisted DIY livery you have to specify exactly what you want to have done, and this is added to your bill. With part livery, everything is done for you so if you don't come to the yard for weeks on end, your horse is still looked after (but not exercised).

Ben is on part livery. They bring him in for me in the morning (as he is out overnight), give him a groom, pick out his feet and if I wanted him fed, they would feed him for me. In the evening they leave him in for me, but would turn out if I wanted to. They skip him out during the day and make sure he has hay/water etc. I always muck him out in the evening - not because I have to, but because I enjoy helping to look after him.

There have been days where I couldn't get to the yard at short notice, or when I went away on holiday and he is always looked after. I cannot fault the care that he gets. We can use as much food/straw/hay as we want to. The fields are rotated and well maintained and are the biggest that I have seen in a yard. When he has had to see the vet, one of the yard staff looked after my youngest son and the yard manager listened to the vet and asked the questions I didn't think of.

The yard is perfect- it would make it more perfect if I had more proper friends there, but this is gradually happening and I don't feel so much like the yard idiot anymore. Just typing all this has made me realise that I can't risk losing all this. If I were to leave, I wouldn't get my place back if I wanted to return as there is a huge waiting list. That's it - I'm staying!!!
 
In all honesty, if you like the current yard and you can afford it. Stay, if it's not broken then don't fix it. I'm having the same dilemma myself at the moment so know exactly how you feel.
 
When in doubt, do nowt.

Personally this is the best advice I have ever been given.

Stay where you are would be my advice - yes it is expensive, but you are managing it, and you need the support you have for the time being.
 
i think if yu are happy and getting help and support and your horse is taken care of if you can't get here then I would stay.
The biggest problem most people have in yards is getting the chemistry right with other people which you have that sorted already but might be terrible at the new place, plus you have lots of turnout which is another big complaint.
You could stay where you are still save for a lorry (just slower) but allow yourself the odd treat of hiring a trailer/lorry or paying for transport to keep you going maybe ?
 
Think it's a great way to make a decision by listing all pros and cons and tbh both look pretty good, bit the old saying 'better the Devil you know' is a very true one and if you are happy there, which you seem to be, why move.....

Think you have made the right decision to stay MP :smile:
 
One thing I suggested in the post I deleted (which advised you to stay put) was that you decline the offer of a place at the yard nearest to you, but do so gratefully. Thank the YO, and explain that it isnt a good moment for you to move, but that may be when Ben and your sons are older, it might be just what you need. That way you leave your future choices open.
 
I think you have made the right decision without a doubt. They do a fair bit for Ben there, and any yard with so many things being done would be expensive.

And making friends on yards I think can take time, but you are getting there which is great.
 
Personally i would move but that is because i'm tight. lol Plus i would like to be as near as possible to the horses incase my car broke down and then i could walk to them, especially in the winter.
 
Just wanted to say thank you for all your comments. The best news is that I have managed to defer my place at the new yard. This place is going to go to someone else, but I stay top of the waiting list and when another place comes up I will be offered that. I explained that I have only just got him and he has just settled down properly so I didn't want to move him again so quickly. She understood and said that as I get to know him and become more confident I would probably be ready for a more DIY arrangement. It's a great outcome I think.
 
newrider.com