Cvb I still hold with my opinion that if the horse was in the state before riding that the OP describes then common sense should have dictated that she didn't ride. She was there the owner wasn't therefore it was her judgement call & I still feel she made the wrong decision & the owner would have had every right to be annoyed if there had been an accident.
As I said before I asked my RI to ride my sometimes sharp horse while I was away recently but it was on the understanding that if he was wound up she didn't ride. I would have been livid if I'd come back to find him hurt & she'd said words to the effect of "oh yes, he was in a right state when I was getting him ready but I decided to ride anyway!". That sort of attitude is exactly why I'm so careful about who I ask to ride if I'm not about
Thanks a lot for your answers!
For those of you who share this view, I hadn't really thought of it this way. It
is quite difficult to explain the situation just in writing, on here, especially when one hasn't exoperienced the exact situation. It was difficult to judge as I am inclined to be stubborn and determined rather than reclining, be that 'wrong' or 'right'. The horse was not jogging, jumping around all the time or strong.
You are absolutely right that I am partly 'to blame', for want of better words.
Perhaps I shouldn't have ridden her as I was well aware as I was riding her that it was not safe: but it's not so black and white - and I did not knows he was inclined to rear and buck. Plus, she was an absolute angel last time I rode her. That said, I felt that I couldn't say no as:
a) the owner is a friend and I would like to ride the horse again: I don't want her to think me incapable or nervous.
b) She doesn't really understand as, afterwards, she kept insisting that the horse isn't normally like that and she is still very sweet and "wouldn't do anything". I don't even think she really believed me!
c) She was unable to look after her horse that day.
Also, despite the horse's behaviour and obvious nervousness I didn't feel the answer was just to put her back in the stable, as I wanted to try and make the experience positive and confidence-giving. I felt in a position to deal with the situation and his owner was, as I said, quite insistent, laid-back and almost disbelieving, as though i was exaggerating. I felt that I had no reason to mistrust
her judgement on her horse.
The hack was short and can everyone here say that they would leave their horse in the stable if it seemed nervous, rather than trying to do something about it? And I had no choice but to hack. I would have led her but I think I was in a safer position on her rather than off (I normally believe the other way round is best and helps to give confidence and more control to the handler, but in this case I believed the opposite).
I was also wearing flourescent gear and a body protector, as well as my hat of course, for extra safety.
If I were the owner, I too would have done things differently.
How easy it is to look back more objectively, afterwards!
More opinions always welcome!
x