At a good yard working livery can work very well, and not just for first time owners either.
Our yard is a small yard with very high standards, none of the horses (either school-owned or working livery) are ever over-used.
Because I can't afford full livery and am not in good enough health for DIY I have 2 choices - full livery with a sharer or working livery. Having Tali on working livery gives me much more flexibility than a sharer would, and means that he is only ridden by other people in a lesson taught by one of 2 people. I prefer this to the sharer option as I have heard too many horror stories about sharers.
Tali only does 2 to 3 hours a week in the school, over the last few weeks he has had a breathing problem so has only done 1 hour a week (my lesson!). He isn't used for novices because he is not currently suitable (he is a cheeky youngster!). If I am away he does extra work and is sometimes ridden by yard staff or put on the horse walker. There are 4 other working liveries at our yard, 3 of us are on our second horses kept there at working livery. The amount of work our horses do tends to depend on the temperament of the horse and how much work they need. Obviously the quiet safe cob does more than my young cheeky pony, but to be honest she needs more work than him as she needs to be quiet enough for her owner to ride.
Tali and I compete regularly in dressage, the yard owner is very supportive of this. I don't compete on Saturdays as the school is busiest then, but if there was something I particularly wanted to go to on a Saturday the yard owner would try to accomodate this.
I have only once turned up and found that Tali is being used for a lesson when I wanted to ride, and as it happened one of the school ponies needed some extra exercise that day so I rode her (and I think it is important to ride other horses and ponies when the opportunity arises).
Without the help and support of the yard I am on I don't think I would have dared to make the transition from a quiet steady cob to an energetic green younsgter, and I don't think I would have made the transition as smoothly as I have.
Does this pony look like an over-worked stale riding school pony?