Working In An Outline Questions!

kate_yates89

Country Girl
Jan 8, 2005
48
0
0
Visit site
Working In An Outline Questions! *With a few pictures!!*

Hi, just posting to ask a few questions about "outlines". Recently in my lesson we've been working on our horses outlines, but im confused about several things!

Ok, so first question!: What is an outline? i have a pretty good idea from looking at dressage photos etc. but if you have any photos of the perfect outline id be interested to see! also ive noticed that different people have different views on a good outline?

Second question!: Why do we use outlines? my instructor says its to make them work properly from the back end?

Third question!: Is Feleo coming into an outline here? his head seems to be down in the correct position and it definetly felt different from on top but i can't tell whether his back legs are "tracking up"? I'm sure he can have a nice outline when he trys, but ive got to learn how!

goodoutlineintrot.jpg
[/IMG]

Fourth question!: When i get what i think is the correct head position and hes listening to me, how can i keep him moving forward? hes usually very forward going but when i contain that energy he seems to "ping" on the spot! Should i just squeeze harder to get him moving forwards?

I'll probably think of loads more questions as soon as i've posted this! And just because i know you all like photos, heres one of me and Feleo: :)

meanfeleobrightened.jpg
[/IMG]

And one to show you that he's not always got his ears back!! : :p

DSC03832.jpg


(By the way, i don't normally have such a bad "chair" position! I think it could be because of the different saddle? its a jumping saddle which could explain why!? :o )

Thanks x
 
Last edited:
hmm no replies :( maybe i should have put in the title that there are pictures?! c'mon i know some of you will be able to answer at least one of my questions! :o
 
Hello,

I'm not that knowledgable on 'outlines' as I posted a similar query yesterday, but IMHO (and i'm sure I'll get corrected if I'm wrong) an outline is when the horse is working correctly from behind. You should feel his back come *up* underneath you, his hindlegs will be going into the hoof prints that the front legs leave (tracking up), he should reach up and accept the contact of the bit and flex slightly at the poll.

Getting this elusive outline is another matter entirely:p and I can't be much more help except to say that you need to make sure that you have enough impulsion before you start asking for the 'outline'

I'm sure another NR member with more experience will be along shortly :D
 
I think "outline" is a very misleading and much mis-used and abused term. Basically, what it is usually intended by "correct outline" is the shape the horse makes when it engages its hindquarters and lifts its back, therefore carrying the rider in an efficient and effective way and collecting. As the hindquarters engage (and that means taking more of the horse's weight - nothing to do with how far their feet move) the centre of gravity of the horse moves back and its back lifts. as it does this, its muscles under the neck relax and the head drops down a bit.

What you often hear described as "corrrect outline" is when the horse's head is pulled down between its knees, or when it avoids the contact by over bending at the poll and going "behind the bit" or when it simply "paddles" with the back legs, taking great long strides, but not really taking any more of the weight. This is actually "poor outline" according to classical principles, because although the head might be down, the back and neck are usually tense, and the horse is still on the forehand.

We don't really "use" outlines - it's just a word to decribe a shape, but care must be taken that we have a clear picture of what we want when we try to achieve it. In the classical tradition, you don't really talk about "outlines" - it's all about developing the horse's co-ordination, obedience, confidence and strength so it can move its weight back onto its hindquarters. It's then considered to be at a more advanced stage of training, and producing the moves and shapes that go with that. In the modern competitive field, you hear about "outlines" all the time, and while the people talking about it may say they are pursuing classical principles, they are usually actually producing one of these "cheat" versions.

For the classical purists there's a good article on this in this months Horses for Life online magazine.. http://horsesforlife.com/content/view/566/595/

Bad news, Kate - no he's not coming into an outline in that photo. Sorry! He couldn't. Draw a line from your shoulder to your heel - you're leaning right back and you're behind the movement and centre of gravity. He's just bracing himself in case you plop down in the saddle, I'm afraid! Collection comes from the hindquarters taking more weight, and is nothing to do with the head. However, the horse can't start to take more weight behind until the rider is in balance and able to start moving the centre of gravity of the horse/rider unit around. Have patience - I love the pic where his ears are forward. You're in a much better position in relation to him here - and you're relaxed. Your back could be a bit straighter - but that might just be a billowy shirt that makes it look as though you're a bit slouched. Try to get that same balaced, relaxed feel while you're moving - and let outlines and collection come when they are ready - or rather when you and the horse are ready:) .
 
And...

Although the head position is the first thing we notice, its actually the last thing you should be concerned with.

Get the horse relaxed
moving forward
listening to your aids
school figures and transitions to help hindquatres get engaged,
and then if you are sitting in self balance with still receptive hands that maintain a contact....the head should drop down to just infront of the vertical with the poll being the highest point.

When the horse is moving forward ( you must get this bit first) and you contain the energy with your hands....then you can start to have 'impulsion' which is contained energy.

Its containing the energy that causes the head to drop down rather than poking its nose, and its your contact with the mouth that contains the energy.

If you don't contain the energy you will just have speed ( like a race horse)

If you take up a contact to make the head look pretty before the horse is really moving forward off your legs, you will not have engagement ie the hindlegs will not be stepping under its body, the back will be hollow, and you have no forward energy to contain...so not point to it all.

This is a very basic description...you can write whole books on the subject!
 
An outline is the sum of all parts working together - correctly.

So, if you and your horse can achieve an 'outline' then it shows you both can work correctly, independantly, and in harmony. Thats why its so stressed in riding lessons because it shows you understand the purpose of riding well and letting the horse do its job. That is what instructors want you to work toward because it shows you understand and can ride well.

As Kate started to say, a horse can't and wont be able to work in an outline if his rider isnt balanced. Because the rider isnt balanced, the horse must come out of balance to compensate for the change in his center of gravity. If there is no balance, there's no outline.

Creating an outline is a multi step process that takes alot of time in the saddle. The right muscles must be built. You have to learn to ride independantly so you dont interfere with the horse. And, you have to learn how to use your body to manipulate your horses paces and way of going so that you can ask him to engage from the hind all the while staying balanced. Its not easy.

If you want to work toward the outline with your horse, break the parts of an outline up into individual pieces. Work on getting yourself balanced so then you can work on getting your horse balanced. Then, try asking for more impulsion while staying balanced. And the final step (certainly no where near the first step) is reining in that impulsion by finding the right contact so the horse contains his frame and thats what you see in those pretty dressage pictures ;)
 
outline

looks like you have some good replies there, but just to add my two penneth, a horse is working in a correct way when by engaging more with the hind quarters, which involves a lowering of the haunches, stepping further under with the hind feet, lifting the back like a bridge by using the stomach muscles. this results in less weight on the front feet, an uphill feeling for the rider, and a proud, balanced and supple horse.
See the spanish riding school horses, or anything by Sylvia Loch :cool:
Your horse in the first piccie is still on the forehand and not tracking up, but it is a slow and gradual process taking many years, if you see any of the dressage to music DVD's you will hear that 9 years old is considered young for a horse to be able to work at the higher levels :o
In order to get there the first things to work on are calmness, straightness and forwardness, then by gradually enabling the horse to become more supple and strong through the quarters and back he will get greater balance, my OH has been lucky enough to get a schoolmaster horse who carries himself beautifully, if you could find a similar horse to try you would be able to feel what you are aiming for.
Good luck, really great that you care about it and are thinking about it!:D :D :D
 
hi, thanks for all your replies! there all very interesting and its taught me loads! seems theres more than i thought to "outlines" :p

kate.F - i wasnt too sure if he was in an outline since his head is down but not alot else! thanks for showing me lol. im a bit disturbed that you think hes bracing himself? i also thought i was a quiet rider! thanks for the advice - would you like a job as in instructor for me?! it also makes me wonder what my RI is going on about? or maybe shes waiting too for when im a more balanced rider? Also im surprised you think that my "chair" position is a better position? my old instructor would have killed me for sitting like that! she wanted my legs virtually straight!

thanks everyone else for your replies too.

so first things first i need to work on impulsion and balance! i guess i can work on these with shapes and lots of transitions?

and most of all ive got to be patient! is it one of these things which comes when youre least expecting it or do you have to work really hard over the years?

i'll try and have an in depth talk to my instructor - so far all ive been told is have a conversation down the reins :confused: and a normal contact when he lowers his head slightly. from what ive been reading now this seems like a "fake" outline. or not an outline at all!


xxx
 
kate.F - i wasnt too sure if he was in an outline since his head is down but not alot else! thanks for showing me lol. im a bit disturbed that you think hes bracing himself? i also thought i was a quiet rider!

I just meant that he will feel that you are behind his centre of gravity and the movement, and may well think "ooh-er! Something might be about to land on me!" hence he's tucked himself up a bit. That doesn't mean you aren't a quiet rider. It's just a balance thing.

Also im surprised you think that my "chair" position is a better position? my old instructor would have killed me for sitting like that! she wanted my legs virtually straight!

I'm afraid I disagree with your old instructor. I think straight legs are usually stiff legs. You need some flexion and mobility in your joints to take up the movement of the horse - and there should be a straight line from shoulder, through the hip to the heel. In the last pic you're pretty close. OK, the lower leg could come back a fraction, and you could stretch up a bit more (but as I said, you may just look a bit hunched because of the shirt - hard to tell!:) ) - and hey, you're just sitting around enjoying being on your horse.... but you're body is starting to find the natural balance without you even thinking about it - which is great! Also on the plus side, your heel is down but soft, whereas in the first pic. it looks as though you are pushing it down, making your ankle, knee and hip stiff.

i'll try and have an in depth talk to my instructor - so far all ive been told is have a conversation down the reins :confused: and a normal contact when he lowers his head slightly. from what ive been reading now this seems like a "fake" outline. or not an outline at all!

Possibly. However, there are plenty of people winning lots of ribbons who just work on getting the head down and don't worry about much else. ;)

For myself, I enjoy getting in tune with the mind and body of the horse and working with it - along with all the challenges that presents. I find that a lot more interesting and exciting than the "any road to the ribbons" competition approach - so I am drawn more to the classical school, which as others have said takes a lot more time and patience!
 
Possibly. However, there are plenty of people winning lots of ribbons who just work on getting the head down and don't worry about much else. ;) QUOTE]

So many instructors nowadays, infact all the BHS trained ones I've had recently, have been about making the horse look pretty, and not bothering to make it effective first. It's irritating, because I want to do it the proper way, not the forced way.

Something I recently learnt, about whether or not I'm balanced, is to stand in the stirrups for several laps of the school, at walk trot and canter, through transitions and circles. Takes a bit of doing, showing that obviously I'm not balanced. If you lift your thigh out from the saddle, and then relax it letting your leg hang, you should find the ideal position for your leg. I'm sure someone else can explain it better than me. I just find keeping my leg there to be the problem, which shows I need to do more stirrupless work!
 
The other thing to remember about 'outline' is that the ideal varies not just from horse to horse, but from discipline to discipline. A cow horse will work in an outline that would get you shot in a dressage class - but it's still working correctly, and still using itself properly.

The dressage outline is usually where the horse has a more upright carriage in front, the nose is on the vertical or thereabouts, the back is rounded and the hocks stepping well underneath him.

A cow pony will look very different; it will be longer, the nose is not on the vertical, and the head is carried much lower.

But the things they have in common are what makes an outline; in both, the horse is carrying his own weight; he's not leaning into the rider's hands, and his body is carried mainly by the quarters, which provide energy and impulsion. The horse is not 'on the forehand' - look at the way a cow pony can stop and turn, with an incredibly light rein contact, in spite of that long, low carriage. When a horse is using himself properly, whatever job he's doing, he'll bring his hocks right underneath him and 'lift' his back. The strongest line in the picture will be that along the topline, not that under his stomach. The whole front of the horse will feel light, and the centre of balance will shift back towards the quarters.
 
wow this is all really interesting - stuff you just can't learn from reading a book! it really helps listening to more experienced people and people who have had different experiences.

i havent really been riding all that long so i think im just impatient to get good fast! but if you look at this pic from 6 months ago, i think ive improved even since then:

Katelungelesson001.jpg


(might be a bit small to see but ..) Argh! look at how stiff i was! and such a hollowed back :eek: ... well i hope ive improved a bit since then!!

Youv'e all given me a bit to think over so iv'e decided just to go steady and enjoy the riding for now and try to improve my balance and position before the technicalities come in!

Thanks for your replies x
 
So many instructors nowadays, infact all the BHS trained ones I've had recently, have been about making the horse look pretty, and not bothering to make it effective first. It's irritating, because I want to do it the proper way, not the forced way.

Something I recently learnt, about whether or not I'm balanced, is to stand in the stirrups for several laps of the school, at walk trot and canter, through transitions and circles. Takes a bit of doing, showing that obviously I'm not balanced. If you lift your thigh out from the saddle, and then relax it letting your leg hang, you should find the ideal position for your leg. I'm sure someone else can explain it better than me. I just find keeping my leg there to be the problem, which shows I need to do more stirrupless work!


I think you've been unlucky in your instructors, Daffy Dilly - mine is BHS trained, and she never stops going on about asking the horse to go forward, then containing the impulsion ...

The RI at ths school where I ride is very keen on this standing in your stirrups exercise, at walk and trot and over trotting poles, not canter (so far!). It's hard work, because it demands strength as well as balance - the real killer version is two steps standing, two steps sitting, at trot .... But I don't know how this sort of balance is related to the sort of balance you have when you're sitting. Maybe someone can explain ...
 
I think you've been unlucky in your instructors, Daffy Dilly - mine is BHS trained, and she never stops going on about asking the horse to go forward, then containing the impulsion ... .


That's exactly the same with my trainer. Forwardness is the key, always. I've gotten told time and again by well respected clinicians that they would much rather see a rider getting the horse swinging from the hind end with its head up, then head down and absolutely no impulsion.
 
newrider.com