Winter yard coats

Jane&Ziggy

Jane&Sid these days!
Apr 30, 2010
22,074
10,564
113
66
Surrey Hills
My trusty winter yard-and-dog cold-and-wet-weather coat of 8 years proved today that it couldn't hack it any more. The rain came in everywhere. I tried reproofing it last year, but it is a goner.

Because I am a dull soul I have bought another Land's End Squall parka, which is what it was. But I know I'll be disappointed because in 8 years they will have had to reduce the quality and details (like lots of pockets) to keep the price down.

I bought either this http://www.landsend.co.uk/Womens_Squall_Coat/pp/P_38057.html?cgid=11299 or this http://www.landsend.co.uk/Womens_Squall_Duffle_Coat/pp/P_35086.html?cgid=11299 . One of them will be going back. But should I have considered something else? What would you have got?
 
I have given up on buying more expensive coats in the hopes they last years, I am apparently as adept at killing expensive ones as I am at killing cheap ones ;) plus I like to have several as I hate putting a still wet coat back on. The only coats I have that are really waterproof for hours even in the most torrential rain is a military one I was given and my musto warm up jacket (which I save for best as I nearly ripped it the first time I wore it at the yard), all the others leak eventually, including my regatta, berghaus, mountain warehouse ones :rolleyes:
My top tip on reproofing, don't bother with the in wash or spray reproofers, get the old fashioned paint on stuff for rugs, works a treat :D
 
I still wear my old Aldi ski jacket. Cost about 25 quid.
Used to really rate jack wolfskin stuff too but I fear they have gone the same as most in terms of quality and as they are so expensive I just dare not risk buying one now.
 
If I need to be really waterproof I just put one of my mum's old Goretex kagool type coats over the top - she was a keen birdwatcher and had several good quality proper rainproof coats - they're like a rain sheet though - no fill lol. I look a bugger, especially with the baggy waterproof trousers, but at least I'm dry. So I can't really help on decent quality waterproof winter coats, but if you find one, do let me know :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers
Musto - as daughter used to cox and Musto did her boating gear.
OH and I both have Musto winter weight Musto mac jackets with goretex (we wear a fleece underneath but not the matchy lining) and I wash them only in Nikwax. They are both 14 years old and my OH wears his out and about in London all the time.

For summer tho I have a very light Berghaus - goretex - again that was what one of my daughters had and I saw BBC foreign correspondents often wore those on camera. It rolls up small for holiday packing or out walking in summer.

My view is that none of these modern macs is as waterproof as the old rubberised ones used to be when we were kids. The shoulder seams start to leak. Which a dryasabone mac does not. However I hate riding in a long mac and it trails round working on the yard. And water gets in at the neck, especially if you wear polo necks sweaters to ride in in wnter which I do. So you wear 100% waterproof mac and then provide a wick which lets water run in at the top.

Like jessie - My mustro snug (not a waterpproof jacket but I wear it a lot to ride in in between weather) is ripped slightly where share mare bit it (I often post that she was a biter) but I mended it with an iron on patch and have added more adhesive over the years.

As for cheaper ones - they dont have the goretex (expensive) which stops you getting sweaty. I still have the cheaper Puffa I got when I started riding in 2001. I wear it for gardening. And a friend today was wearing a similar of about the same date. They seem less flexible than the more expensive ones. I really hate feeling I am in a lot of heavy rigid clothes when sitting on a horse.

I dont know about Landsend - we tend to go for brands that specialise in sports and hiking wear. One of my uni friends swears by Rohan. But for dogwalking (my new occupation) I have a ridiculous and very warm scarlet Timberland coat. Not waterproof, no sensible pockets but almost identical to the fur trimmed red anorak I owned when I was 20. I bought it in a sale two years ago - just nostalgia. But has come into its own.
And it taught me that if you want an expensive winter jacket - the time to buy one is Spring. When no one wants a winter coat and the prices fall very low.
 
I have just looked at the Musto site - I think they did change hands and the fact that some of us bought Musto years ago, doesnt mean they are still the best. North Face for instance is very popular among my wealthier and very active grand children.
My OH has a mountain horse jacket - he likes a lot.
 
Like jessey I've killed both expensive and cheaper yard coats off. I have two that were as cheap as cheese unbranded from local tack place and they leak but only when it's really hammering down. I just have lots of them hung up in the tack room and reach for the dryest one. I have a knee length Jack Murphy but I hate the silly yolk that flaps up and whacks me in the face in the wind so don't bother with that one unless desperate and it's a two coat day with one underneath for warmth. I have a MH one which cost lots which is okay, but isn't very warm, but it is waterproof. I would love a proper ski jacket but can't afford one.
 
@Skib I have a Musto mid weight jacket, perfect for spring and autumn, and it's easily my best jacket. If Musto had a similar coat on its Black Friday deals I would get one, but I can really only afford to buy in the sale!
 
When I was coat hunting I looked in Amazon and Ebay. Got lucky with ebay for both my winter and my Hi viz ridden summer weight.
 
I've got a Trespass parka - it's snuggly and warm and waterproof and my go-to yard coat for winter, and not as expensive as the equestrian brands but still designed for snowy, cold weather!
 
I think it is my goretex fixation. I saw the high prices of Musto these days and that they are not doing Goretex any longer. I bought my Musto winter one cut price at the Olympia horse show shopping village.
 
I also think riding wear is a bit different from walking. Walking, one moves one's legs and arms more and can get much wetter. But one can also wear either a longer coat or waterproof hiking trousers. OH has those but I dnt.
 
@Skib yes my yard coat does horse chores and dog walking, but not riding. For wet cold walking and yard work I like a coat to fit quite closely over and below my (ample) bottom, whereas for riding I like one with flaps. I have a long riding coat, waxed cotton, but TBH I find it quite cumbersome and only wear it if I'm going to be riding in the rain for a long period, which happens very, very, very, very seldom!
 
this one gets my vote-
i bought it last winter and its the only thing thats kept me warm on the top of an exposed, icy hill in north aberdeenshire.

https://www.sportsdirect.com/karrim...5-dEvAPWMKuPpbEzXT0BbzwxY8tDfP8xoCN-cQAvD_BwE

Ive got a bit of a thing for jackets though... i have a mountain horse winter riding jacket with flaps/vents at the back for winter hacking. For schooling indoors Ive a few softshells, i dont like anything heavy for schooling, even in cold weather.
 
When I lunge I wear next to nothing- that sounds bad let me re phrase!!
I mean I wear lighter layers, today despite it being cold I had my summer jacket on because I know I work as hard as she does. :D

I have a blousen jacket to ride in, I hate sitting on the dam thing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CharliesAngel
I have one of these and it fills all my criteria....covers my bum, waterproof, padded and warm and easy to spot so I can ride in it too (double-ended zip). Cheap too!

Screenshot_20171128-191518-600x1067.png
 
newrider.com