Wintec Saddles??

NoviceNic

Sexy Dressage Pony
May 7, 2003
10,180
2
0
On my horses back...
Visit site
I am considering buying a new saddle for Captain. I want a nice one just for Shows. I was looking at Wintecs and I have had a fitter around who has said that Captain would need a Wintec VSD 16 1/2 inch wide fit. The thing is though my friend has a wintec 500 on her cob and it constantly slips. Really badly slips.

Does anyone else have experiences of Wintec saddles?

Should I invest in a wintec or should I convince my OH that "I need" a leather fitted one? ;)
 
Hiya nic...

I had a wintec 500 on my warmblood when I first got him and I've got to say I loved it (for the price it was!). No slipping problems and my boy was typical wb, wide but with high withers. Is your friend sure she has the right width gullet in it?

Anyway, of course, since then I've had an Albion leather one and now have a barnsby and have to say that I prefer them, but for the money you pay for a wintec, I thought it was great.

S
 
I have a Wintec 2000 on Cheeky, and I have no issues with slipping. But remember it isn't like a one size fits all glove. And it's not all about gullet size. Get your saddle fitter to check everything else on the saddle fits your horse too. For example, the 500 doesn't fit my horse, but the 2000 does...the panels on the 500 didn't even fit on his back!
 
SarahC - The fitter came out again and said that the gullet needed changing as Fagen had slimmed of a little. So she had to buy a wide gullet. Another lad has ridden Fagen today and I noticed he was unbalanced. Not sure if this was the saddle or just his experience.

The fitter looked at Captain for me and said he would suit a Wintec VSD. I had a look on the website and they are cut different to the 500. I think it is because Captains current saddle doesn't give him the freedom around his shoulders. He actually moves his body to the right when I lay his saddle on his back.. Something I hadn't noticed until the fitter showed me the other day. Saddles can be soo complicated can't they? I don't want to damage Captain.
 
I recently bought a wintec because my pony changed shape so much and it was hard finding any saddles that fitted. But now i have it i love it - sure i prefer the look of a leather - but theyre 'cheaper' to replace and v. comfortable. You can sit really deep in it and it has helped me sit to canter easier so i would definitely recommend them.
 
I didn't get on with the Wintec 500 at all because it's quite forward cut and pinched my pony's shoulders, and then I had an albion selecta which was lovely because the panels are straight cut, but now he's drastically slimmed down and has high withers so now i'm about to have a made to measure 16" saddle made. I tell you, saddles are a nightmare!
 
I have found that a wintec is a good fit for narrower high withered types not flat backed and low withered ones, my pony's back was screwed up by a wintec saddle, it also is very round through the flaps which can restrict the shoulder, I have found thorowgood griffin cob far better and a lot more comfortable too
 
I had a wintec dressage saddle, on my fat round pony. I found that the back was prone to wobbling around all over her spine, so I quickly got rid of that saddle! Also, I have found that they are not very hardwearing. Mine was a year old when I got it and already the saddle flaps were rubbed until they were shiny, not a good look.

If you are on a budget, why not try a thorougood instead? They are probably a lot better suited to the 'wider' horse and pony ;)

Edit : opps i just realise shandy had suggested that :)
 
I've owned a few Wintecs with various results. I had a Wintec 2000 with Cair which I hated!! It never fitted my horse despite repeated efforts and tipped me forward. I eventually had it flocked by a saddler to make it fit and sold it on with the horse. I then got an Isabel Werth, which I love and which fits a wide variety of horses. I love the flared skirt as I am a larger rider, it distributes the weight over a much wider area.

I bought a Wintec 500 for my daughters pony Merlyn, a wide cobby type with almost no wither. This didn't fit him at all and there was no way it would. The saddler then fitted a Wintec Close Contact jumping saddle which fits him like a glove, but really isn't suitable in the showring (doesn't stop her though : ))

So, in conclusion I can recommend the Isabel if you can get one wide enough, but if not, then talk your OH into a custom leather one :) :) :D ;)
 
Can't add much to what people have said, I had a Wintec 500 for the short time but it didn't suit either of us (Rupert is round with very little wither) and I felt perched, plus it slid forwards. But they do seem to suit some horses, just be sure as Cochise says to get the whole saddle fitted not just the gullet.
 
Ah yes, Cair. I will not say much more than this on that matter, as we have had numerous debates about it here in the past. Only that it doesn't suit every horse, so be careful. It suits some horses, and others not at all. I have gone for flocking, because it suits my horse.
I whole-heartedly agree with the stories here, the Wintec suits some horses and riders, and it doesn't suit some at all. Whatever works best for you and your horse is the best advice I can give you. :)
 
Nic I think Fagan's Wintec was slipping because he was so wide!! Not fat, that's just how he is built but it might helped if he has lost a bit of weight lately? It sure was fun trying to stay balanced so I didn't slip off the side when I rode him!! :D Doubt that all Wintecs slip as a rule but I've never had one so couldn't say for sure.
 
i have a throughgood one and highly recommend them, my pony is extremely hard to find saddles for, she is wide with no withers, she had a leather one fitted but that slipped up her neck and to the side and everything. was impossible to jump in.
she now has a thoroughgood (sp) pony club one which fits her really well, they kinda mould to the horses shape as well cos its got gel in. very easy to ride in aswell
 
I had one I tried to use on Rio when we first had her and she was fat as a barrel, and we had terrible slipping problems with it. Not only that but it wasn't wide enough and the tree was the wrong shape for her as she then was.

If captain is a traditional cob type then I'd take a serious look at the Thorowgood Cob or particularly the Jill Thomas Endurance saddles. They're very straight cut, have nice wide flat panels, a wide gullet channel and the tree shape suits a lower withered horse. I got one to try last week, but unfortunately the tree didn't fit Rio front to back, too much wither:D
 
I'm not really a fan of the Wintec 500 GP saddles, although I do love the Wintec Isabell dressage saddles (my friend's Isabell fitted my Welsh Cob very well and didn't move, and she has a 17.2hh Trakehner X (probably Shire lol poor Yo!)). I had a Wintec Pro dressage saddle on my Welshie and it was great, so I bought a Wintec 2000 GP which was also great, sold with the pony and the new owners think it's the bee's knees (as is the pony lol), and the saddle was at least a year old and not in particularly wonderful condition when I bought it off eBay. Most of the people on my yard (about 10 horses at the yard) have at least one Wintec, and if they don't they usually end up buying one soon after they arrive!
My instructor is quite good at fitting saddles and she thinks the Wintecs (especially Isabells) are good all-round fitting saddles, as thinks my saddler. So really I think it depends on whether it fits the horse and suits you as a rider. Like any saddle. Although if you're going for price I agree with the Thorowgood people on here, I like them too and they are cheaper.
Rachel
 
Sorry Rachel but every professional saddle fitter I have spoken to (that has been a lot because of all our problems and even our vet) agree that wintecs are a skinny horse saddle as a norm because the shape of the internal structure and the flaps are entirely unsuitable for most wider and bigger built horses.

Saying that after the damage it caused I would never get any one but a qualified saddle fitter to fit a saddle especially when i have seen qualified instructors agree use of a very badly fitting saddle before now it does take your trust away from their knowledge.
 
I had a wintec 500 for Pink and had no end of trouble with it.

She's a very wide, broad chested cob. The (proffesional apparently :rolleyes: ) saddle fitter who fitted to her the first time put a wide (red) gullet in it. After months of slipping, temper tantrums etc, I got another saddler out to have a look. She took the gullet out and tried it to her back - it'd been fitted a good 30degrees too narrow :eek: . The previous saddle had fitted it to get the balance right, and ignored the width. So the saddle was sitting preched on top, causing to to slip and nipping like hell.

When I had the gullet bent to fit, it sat much nicer at the front and Pink was much happier, but the front then sat far too low and it still slipped. The tree was also too curved for her back and lifted up everytime you stood in the stirrups.

After finally getting fed up of falling off every time she cantered a circle :rolleyes: I bought her a thorowgood cob saddle. And it's brilliant - good width fitting, tree right shape for her back, NEVER slips, moulded well etc. It sits a little low at the front but thats just her shape and I'm going to get it reflocked for a perfect fit.

So, as shady has said, if Captains a wide cob, it's never going to fit - they're just the wrong shape. You'd be better cuttiing you're loses and getting a new saddle. You could buy a new Thorowgood Cob maxam new for the price you'd sell a second-hand (good condition) Wintec.
 
I have the most basic Wintec saddle for Falcon. It's his first 'proper' saddle. It's very comfortable and fits him really well. When he stops changing shape and growing, I'll get him a really nice one. It's not worth it at the moment as he's rising 5 and has still got a lot of growing and shape changing to do. :rolleyes:
 
newrider.com