Will I Regret Buying Him?

imabrit_us

New Member
Feb 6, 2004
98
0
0
Eversley, Hampshire
Visit site
I've been riding for about a year and a half. I'd say I'm still definitely a novice, but I do feel I progress with every lesson. I'm a very thinky rider (sometimes I'm TOO thinky) and try to work hard on "feel."

I've been riding several horses up at my riding school . . . but one in particular has really caught my attention. He's a big lad . . . probably about 16.2hh . . . a thoroughbred (so he's a tad flighty and spooky) but he's not overly sharp and he's very honest and (mostly) willing. He and I really seem to suit each other . . . several instructors have commented on it . . . he goes well for me (he has a tendency to lean too if you're too heavy handed, but he's never leant on my hands) and despite his spookiness in the school, he's a dream to hack (he used to hunt). He's not the bravest horse in the world (won't go to the front of the ride), but he's sensible and fun.

He has an owner but she almost never rides him. Aside from his spookiness (more about that in a minute), he's not really sharp or fit enough to be an intermediate or advanced horse at the moment . . . so he suits me perfectly. He jumps. He's sound. And did I mention that he's a) gorgeous and b) very affectionate and well-mannered.

His spookiness. He doesn't usually do big spooks . . . just cat-jumps sideways or does the stand, snort and walk past something sideways routine. He usually puts in a couple of spooks a lesson and if you keep him thinking, put your leg on and tell him to get on w/ it, it's no trouble. It's never phased me.

But he DID put in a big spook w/ me in the school (in canter) this week and I came off (badly injured my back, but that's another story). I think he was just fed up and arse-ing about . . . it was literally five minutes before the end of the lesson and I'd worked him really hard . . . and we'd turned in two minutes before that and I KNOW he thought he was done. Or, someone made a noise in the yard (we were heading for the side of the school nearest the yard) and that startled him. Either way, he went sideways and I ended up briefly suspended in mid-air . . . just like a cartoon.

It's the only big spook he's ever done w/ me. And it's the biggest spook my instructor has ever seen him do.

I feel pretty confident that if I made his owner an offer, she'd consider it. I'd leave him in working livery because a) I'm not competent enough to school him and he needs it; and b) while I'd continue to ride him twice a week and go up and see him as often as I could, I couldn't commit to "doing" him every day; and c) I get such great instruction at that yard (and they really take care of their horses).

But would I regret buying him? Would his spookiness become a big issue? It's not getting worse . . . in fact, he's much better (i.e., less spooky) than he used to be. If he was mine, I could spend much more time w/ him and perhaps do Parelli or some other trust exercises with him which might cut down the spookiness. And I guess if I left him at the yard, I could always opt to still ride one of the other horses now and again if I felt like a spook-free ride.

On the one hand, his spooks are so seldom unseating. On the other hand, he just unseated me, and there's part of me that says if he did it once, he could do it again . . . or never. What to do? I really do love this horse.

N
 
remember, if he's a riding school horse he's probably had a hard life and he will be used to working several hours a day. he may not like the change of pace in a private home. (sorry! just read you will keep him on working livery. would you really want anyone riding your horse? i wouldn't)

i would be very concerned about the spooking, it will end up denting your confidence, you really need a little more experience to sort a problem like that out. save your money, have a couple more years of lessons and then start looking, theres a horse out there for you somewhere :)
 
The school only works horses 2 hours a day max., and they only work four days a week. They get one day a week off (turned out) and the other two days, they're just lightly hacked or schooled by an instructor. Hacks w/ students count as work (so their 2 hours a day won't necessarily be 2 hours in the school . . . and could be 2 hours of hacking).

As schools go, I think they treat their horses extremely well (which is probably why it's so expensive). I actually like the fact that staff ride him . . . it keeps him well-schooled (and certainly better schooled than he would be if I were the only one riding him).

But I do take your point about the spooking denting my confidence . . . and that's what I'm struggling with.

N
 
is it the spooking denting your confidence, or that you fell off? remember we all fall off at some point, it's a very rare horse who has never lost a rider.

one thing i would say though, is speak to the yard staff first, and see if the owner would be likely to sell if you asked or whether she might be offended. just because she doesn't ride him, doesn't mean he's not the world to her. i haven't ridden my chap for over a year - he is in working livery, on loan to a riding school client via the school, and i compete 2 others - but he is everything to me and i wouldn't sell him in a million years.

i think it's worth you sounding out your instructor - remember we've never seen you or the horse, so she would have a much better idea of what kind of long-term partnership you'd make - and see what she thinks.
 
I think judging by the title to your post you already know he's not quite right for you. I agree about the spooking denting your confidence, it's one thing him doing it in the school but what if he then starts to do it out hacking? you also mention he won't go up front on a hack, what if you want to take him somewhere by yourself?

There are plenty of safe and equally lovely horses around so I really woudn't rush into things, or maybe if you really are keen on him you could have him on a trial basis for a while and see how things progress?
 
hi imbarit-us, I would echo eventerbabes comments. spooking can be a difficult challenge to deal with for an experienced rider, let alone a novice. I would wait a while or go for a horse more suitable for you. Sorry i hope i dont sound patronising but i am in a similar situation with my pony,( not spooky but nappy ). I wonder if his spookiness is the reason his owner doesnt ride him very often? rrx
 
when we were looking for a horse, we very nearly bought a horse from the riding school we rode at. he was a 16.2hh warmblood who was about 18 years old. all the instructors told us he was perfect for us, despite the fact that i was only 9, my sister 7 and we were more suited to a 13.2, not a 16.2!! he had all sorts of problems they never mentioned and i am so glad we never bought him. you want your first horse to be fun, one that will build your confidence not destroy it. its easy to fall in love with a riding school horse, believe me i would have taken home most of the ponies i used to ride!! but with your level of experience and the horses problems its not a wise match.

i know working livery works for many people, but i chose to do everything myself. it would break my heart to see someone else riding my horse. he wouldn't like it either!! its so much more rewarding if you can say "oh. i taught him this" and i think you bond better with your horse.
 
Has the owner actually said that she wants to sell the horse? Or has the owner mentioned that they plan to change the situation with the horse at all?
If you aren't really sure if you want to buy the horse and there is no sign of his owner taking the horse away from the riding school or selling it, why not keep riding the horse as you are now and if it comes to a time when you think 'yeah i really want this horse and am ready to deal with all of the problems he comes with' then you can see about buying him.
 
This is a very personal thing as only you know what your confidence levels are like and how confident and brave a person you are generally.
However, I would say one thing (and this is from personal experience), if you have ANY doubts whatsoever about a horse you want to buy, don't do it. Also don't buy with your heart, buy with your head....which can be an extremely difficult thing to do.
Lots of people said these things to me when I bought my last two, and I ignored it and bought them even though I had doubts. With my current boy, the doubts were about his spooking and low and behold, I've now had to reach to painful decision to sell him on.

Like I say, it is a personal thing, but these are the two 'golden' rules that I was told to follow, particularly when I was buying my first horse.

Good luck with whatever you decide.

S
 
It's the only big spook he's ever done w/ me. And it's the biggest spook my instructor has ever seen him do.

It sounds like this one has taken you by surprise and perhaps shaken your confidence a bit? As it was just this week, perhaps at the moment you would be better seeing how you feel about getting back on him again? You may find yourself getting more scared, not less, over the next few weeks - in which case you have your answer.

I think I understand how you are feeling - I could deal with a horse if I knew the most he would do was snort or a small cat-jump. But now you know he could do more, and the question is whether your nerves can handle it? Some people would be okay - for me, I would struggle with my confidence from now on.

It doesn't sound like he is going anywhere, perhaps a bit more time is a good idea? :)
 
Have you considered loaning this horse once or twice a week from the owner / riding school? This would then perhaps suit you as you said you could only get up two or three times a week, so the rest of the time he would be on livery etc. So why not loan and have him to yourselvf for the days you can get up there. This will give you more time riding, you can still have a lesson, but perhaps a private lesson one every so often instead of a group lesson. Also he will get ot know you and you him better over a period of time. Also if he is not just the right one you would not have spent out lots of money and then have to resell (if you could bring yourself to do that).
Good luck.
 
Looking into a loan is a good idea. Maybe the owner would go for that.

I agree that if you have doubts anyway (and you don't even know that he IS for sale) then these doubts will only increase once you're responsible for him.

Prior to getting Saff I would confidently deal with spooks, bucks, falling off (even got back on and carried on jumping when I broke my ribs) and 'naughtiness' on the ground (my favourite school horse was known to buck at everything and everything) but when I got Saff I found my confidence dwindling as she initially spooked in the school (nothing worse than I'd experienced before), reared all the way down to the field the first day that I got her and then started rearing in the school. Because I was responsible for her it all seemed so much worse. I sat the rears (and got a bloody lip to prove it) but it knocked me. I'm still not back to my previous confidence though I'm better than I was.

When people tell you that you feel like a beginner when you get your own it's true, so true. I didn't really believe it but I soon learned! I suddenly realised that for all that I DID know there was SO MUCH more that I didn't know!

Good luck


x
 
Well it's all pretty academic at the moment

. . . as I'm having trouble walking, never mind actually getting on a horse!

I like the loan idea. I do actually have private rather than group lessons . . . I think the first hurdle I need to get over is recovering physically from the fall. Then I'll get back into riding (it may take a couple of weeks) and then talk to the YO about approaching the owner to propose a loan.

I don't want to overhorse myself . . . if he's the right horse for me, it'll be obvious and there'll be a right time. If he's not, I'll wait.

N
 
I agree with others on this on this board. Dont rush into anything. Consider very carefully that even if the horse is for sale do you really want one you cant hack out alone, or that spooks badly at things? There are plenty of animals out there that would make good 1st horses (and teach you a lot as well) that are relatively 'problem free'. Dont rush into anything. A horse is expensive to buy, expensive to keep, expensive to insure and if you cant safely ride the beast..... give that one a miss!
 
I think a loan sounds like a great idea. Even if "this" horse is a good match for you, that isn't the whole question. The first question is, do you really want to buy a horse just yet? If you aren't confident working with a horse on your own, want something that is being ridden regularly by others, and only plan to ride a couple of times a week, a loan may be just what you are looking for. It will likely be more cost effective, will still allow you time to bond and do ground work, and will gain you more flexibility as you can more easily change horses if you find that the one you started with isn't a good match (or any other reason).
 
I would absolutely agree with Bay Mare here. Owning a horse is very different from riding in a riding school, and taking on a horse which has already knocked your confidence would be a very risky thing to do. The loan idea is a good one. It would give you a chance to try horse ownership before the big step. Like Bay Mare, I was staggered by how different owning a horse is. I remember hacking out on my own for the first time. Ooer:eek:
 
You seem to have had your confidence deted by this spook- I have been there. My newfie is very spooky- so empathise. But Jas my arab is very laid back..........

I could not help pick up you said that you are not experienced enough to school him. That is why I would say he is possibly not right for you. Regarading working livery- yes it is a great thing but personally I would not like loads of people I had no say over riding my horse.
There are many horses for sale or loan- so do not rush.
 
Perhaps I'm getting old, I'm not what you'd call novice and I can cope with most things but spooking is something I don't like, I find it annoying. Maybe it's because I don't suffer it the horses that I have soon grow out of it.
Cymro used to have mega kittens at all sorts of things, he knows now that I just won't get involved with his sillies....he's stopped it and is an old plod-bless him.

Unless you have the brass neck to ride a spooker through his sillies and keep your nerve then spookers can get worse with nervous riders.

If you feel you can ignor his spooks and get on with things then go for it. But you'll come off, as mentioned, 'tis a rare horse who has never lots a rider.
 
newrider.com