Why isn't grass good enough?

Wobblydeb

New Member
Jul 4, 2004
988
0
0
Northumberland, UK
Visit site
It seems like every magazine or book I read has a huge variety of advice on feeding - all of it in addition to letting your horse graze.

I've been puzzling about why we need to give our horses additional food, especially the native types who are designed to live off this fair land after all :) [I can understand that warmbloods may not get enough energy to both heat themselves and work, especially in winter, but what about our naturally hairy beasties?]

Any thoughts? Can I (for instance) forego supplements by using creative planting within paddocks? Could we manage laminitis by balancing the grass in the paddocks with other types of plants such as herbs?

Might need to get me a good guide to how a horses gut works, and feeding requirements! :D
 
Interesting point your post about ponies living off grass. My Fell lives out 24/7 but only does about 30 mins work a day and then not every day. I've never kept any of my natives in a stable. They live out all the time but in winter they do minimal work. It would be impractical for some of the natives to be kept out and live off nothing but grass as people use them for hunting, jumping, just every day riding then grass would not give them the 'fuel' necessary for this. In the summer on very good pasture if they were doing minimal work or being ridden by a small child say for half an hour a day that would be fine. A pony restricted to a field and worked on nothing else but grass would not have the energy to do anything more than say an hour a day provided the work was not fast. There is very little goodness in winter grass and in a field this gets trampled very quickly. The pony needs good hay (if nothing else) to supplement the supply of grass if it's to do any work at all. Even at rest, it is usually always necessary to provide hay in the field during the winter. The food supply can be run down as spring approaches to cut down the risk of laminitis. By the way, ponies can also get laminitis in winter too.:rolleyes:
 
Some horses need extra calories when they work; a wild horse wouldn't be exercising nearly so much as many domesticated horses.

The types of forage that we have available to horses--in their enclosed pastures--don't offer a lot of choice. A wild horse might be able to travel a good distance and pick up whatever plants it might need. A domesticated horse needs for us to provide it with a balanced diet. This usually means supplementing the minerals available through grass and hay, because they're just not quite right for the horse. We can't offer the kind of selection that a wild horse would have.

Too, we want our horses to live as long as possible. A wild horse's projected lifespan is about 6 or 7 years. In order to keep the horses healthy long-term, we must look at things that might not affect a wild horse in the first few years of its life. For example, if a wild horse doesn't get enough calcium while he's growing, leading to a predisposition for arthritis...well, he's not likely to get old enough to develop arthritis.

A lot of the care of our domesticated horses is due to the differences between their natural habitat/lifespan and their domesticated life. Wild horses don't have their teeth done, for example; they also don't have their feet shaped by trimming, they aren't dewormed. All of these may contribute to an early death for the horse, much earlier than if the horse were domesticated and cared for by people.
 
As far as I'm aware a lot of the pasture in this country doesn't provide a balanced diet and is short of various minerals, especially cow type grass. However if your horse is a good doer and only in light work then it isn't really necessary to feed much in addition to what is grazed. A lot of these sort of horses will only get a small bucket of chaff with a vitamin supplement as their dinner. Effectively the chaff isn't any more nutritious than grass or hay, it just acts as a carrier for the supplement.

If the horse is in harder work or doesn't hold weight well then you need to give them more. It isn't however necessary to give them cereals if you don't want to, as there are various higher energy fibre feeds available these days. As has already been mentioned the quality of grass varies throughout the year and depends on the weather. Spring grass can be like giving kids smarties, whereas grass in February will give next to no nutrition at all, which is why hay is generally put out.
 
In my opinion, more horses can work off grass than people realise. There are very few horses which I know which are in so much work that grass alone wouldn't do it.

My own horses live out 24/7 all year round, with just an hour or so in a day when weather is extreme - hot, cold, wet, windy - I think they enjoy this hour away from the elements, and they often use the time to have a nap, but are then ready to go back out after about an hour.

The thing about working a horse off grass is in the management. They need good quality grass if they are in hardish work, and not too much bulk of it, or they are too fat to move!

BUT, having said all this, I do believe that the majority of grass is short in some vit/min requirement. For example, I believe that most of the UK & much of the US is deficient in Selenium. It is best to have your ground tested, to see if you have any major deficienies, and I also personally believe in feeding a daily supplement, just to make sure that your horse is getting everything he needs.
 
Not everyone has access to good quality grazing, particularly if you are in a livery yard. but i agree , its not necessary to pump your horse full of feed that it doesn't need. both my horses are native types and get very little food. my cob gets calm and condition because he does quite a lot of showjumping.

And yes, ponies get laminitis at any time of year. my pony had laminitis two winters ago. you cannot turn a lamanitic pony onto frosted grass (the grass stores too much sugar in frosty conditions). even the compacted snow in a horses feet can cause enough pressure to trigger an attack.
 
We have a mixture of what is called "in bye" land and open hill, The hill is unimproved heathery hill with bogs and sedgy stuff in it. The inbye has been limed and treated with fertilizer so it grows a more lush grass.

We have a lack of copper and cobalt in our land so much so we do the unthinkable and give our sheep copper blocks.

In spring and summer the only thing our lot get extra is a mineral lick and in winter they get silage or straw, maybe a small sugar beet and barley feed.

They all do fine on this, but then they would they are Shetlands and ICelandics and the odd Fjordhorse. They would be done no favours to feed them anything fancy.

A lot of Sheltands manage summer and winter in the open hill with no extra feed at all and they all look like little barrels.
 
A lot of Sheltands manage summer and winter in the open hill with no extra feed at all and they all look like little barrels.

Like ours :D Well Pablo gets some haylage daily in the worst weather and Rupert (NF) and the shetlands get teeny piles to keep them happy while he eats his. Other than that they get no feed at all, summer or winter. They loose a little weight over the winter, but are still little barrels :D
 
We have a highland pony and she could live on fresh air I am certain of that!!! She has access to some rather good grass during the spring monthes, summer monthes and early autumn, but in winter she is only on turnout for a few hours a day. So we let her put on a little weight during the spring, summer, and she will loose this quite naturally over the autumn and winter monthes so as she stays fairly evenly balanced in the weight. This is what animals do naturally put on weight during the spring and summer and use this to see them over the harsher autumn / winter monthes. Therefore we only feed ours hay and chaff as someone said only acts as a carrier for the vitamin and mineral supplement she is feed. She is in work for about an hour per day as well as having a bib clip as well. This we have found works best for our little mare on this yard. In my ideal world I would have her out 24/7 with field shelter, but probably with the same feed regime, and rugged in harsher weather. But unfortunately do have the money to see this dream come true, so we do our best with what we have.
 
they all look like little barrels.

Lol, I have such a wierd picture in my head! :D

Drummer also lives on fresh air and at the moment is doing a good impession of a barrel on legs (picture gets worse, lol!)

I have a bag of happy hoof but it lasts me aaaages! I only give him something as its nice when hes worked hard. He gets happy hoof and carrots. He doesn't get the right ration and I know its not really worth feeding but..................!

Has anyone tried the Baileys low cal balancer? Apparently you only have to feed a cup full a day and it gives a good dose of vitamins etc!
 
mine lives off grass and the yard will provide haylage when the grass runs out (its okay still at the moment as the field is quite big!). on top of that she gets a couple of equivit pasture plus bicsuit things every day for vitamins and stuff. she doesnt really work very hard at all though, as i only ride a couple of times a week and its hardly strenuous work :)

julia
x
 
Wild horses generally have hundreds of acres of land to wander across to find food, whereas the domestic horse generally has 1 or 2. Therefore, the domestic horse is going to run out of grass to eat quicker than the wild horse. Also, domestic horses with metal shoes on do way more damage to the grass than their wild counterparts & so they can quite quickly turn fields into mudbaths with a bit of help from the good ol' English weather!

At this time of year (in the UK), the temperature is not high enough for enough of the time for the grass to grow sufficiently so the horses can live off it. Therefore, most people supplement their field-kept horses diets with hay or haylage &/or a small feed with a vitamin & mineral supplement.

Originally posted by Varkie
For example, I believe that most of the UK & much of the US is deficient in Selenium. It is best to have your ground tested, to see if you have any major deficienies, and I also personally believe in feeding a daily supplement, just to make sure that your horse is getting everything he needs.
However, having an overdose of Selenium is far more harmful to the horse than a deficiency as it weakens the protein keratin which is responsible for the growth of hair & nails so, in extreme cases of Selenium poisioning, the mane, tail & hooves can fall off.
 
I have top aggree with Volvic, an overdose of elements is far worse than a deficiency, blanket supplements are a waste of money. 90% of horses in the UK are probably over fed.

There is a company who will make you up a bespoke supplement based on your soil analysis. Ask Monty,
 
newrider.com