Why is confidence so fragile?

Mary Poppins

Well-Known Member
Oct 10, 2004
13,662
4,789
113
Visit site
I so wish that I could magically transform into one of these super confident riders. I am really frustrated with myself at the moment and it is driving me crazy. Today I rode in a competition at my RS on my fave RS horse who is usually 100% in every way. However, there was so much going on he got very excited and turned into a bucking bronco between fences. We managed to get round the course (clear and without me falling off) but I lost my nerve and pulled out of the other classes I had entered. Lots of other horses went mental as well but their riders thought it was funny and enjoyed their antics. Why can't I just shrug it off and even enjoy the bucking. I thought that I was really getting somewhere with my riding and now I feel like I am back to square one!
 
sounds to me you have more confidence than you of aware of. im 37 and had my horse for 7 years and its only been the last year that i feel confident on him and hopefully doing my first ever show on him next year, infact it will be the first ever show iv ever done at all.
 
Because by the sound of it your expecting to fall off! Everyone has those moments where the "what if?" monster takes over and convinces you that somethings going to go wrong and the natural instinct is self preservation so you end up not doing it. If your confident you just override that gut instinct or you've done it so many times the self preservation instinct doesnt have a chance to kick in and you end up doing it anyway.

Some people are just naturally pre-disposed to being confident, if your the sort of person that doesnt like taking risks then the chances of suffering from confidence issues are likely to be higher. Some people just dont like being out of thier comfort zone where as others go out of thier way to put themselves out of it for that rush of adrenaline and others are just used to dealing with it.

I love the expression "what doesnt kill me makes me stronger", if you've done something you normally find scary doesnt it usually get a bit easier the next time you do it?
 
When you're younger you have absolutely no sense of your own mortality. This changes when you get older but very often the fear of falling is worse than the actual fall. Have you had a fall recently? If not, you are probably building a fall into something it is not likely to be.

Focus on this - the horse bronced through the course, you stayed on and completed. With the behaviour you describe it was probably the right decision to pull out of the other classes, so rather than look upon it as a failure due to lack of confidence, it was a sensible decision based on the facts.
 
Arghh, the dreaded "What If?!" feeling, I hate it and I sympathise with those who acquire, but admire those who conquer it. :D I had a fall about 4/5 years ago, it took me a couple years getting back to a better confident state.

It sounds like, in your situation it was more of the SHOCK and then your brain thinking "Warning WARNING, pending fall, ouch!" and so, like someone previously said, your natural survival to stay safe kicks in. :rolleyes:

What helped me is, working hard on getting a good secure seat. Because the more confident in your ability to sit well to a horse, does wonders with dealing with a wiggly one that has discovered springs in his/her hooves. :D

A GREAT WAY TO MAKE IT A MORE POSITIVE EXPERIENCE IS, you know now how if FEELS when a horse plays up, so you can now make preparation that will have you prepared for any future times.

Another thing I did was analise the situation, how did the horse move then think of the strong positions you can sit to ensure you sit well and can also bring the horse together again. ;) Because when you notice the horse having a fit underneath, yet you seem to to be sitting pretty comfortably, it isn't so scary and your like, tsk tsk, come on horsey.

Don't worry, sit up, feel confident, try not to grip and keep legs DOWN, if your legs creep up and you fold, then you are unseating yourself.

All the best luv :cool: xx
 
Some people are just naturally pre-disposed to being confident, if your the sort of person that doesnt like taking risks then the chances of suffering from confidence issues are likely to be higher. Some people just dont like being out of thier comfort zone where as others go out of thier way to put themselves out of it for that rush of adrenaline and others are just used to dealing with it.

My thoughts exactly. To me, confidence in the saddle is a matter of character - some people are naturally confident, others aren't - add to the fact that it's such a dangerous sport, and it's no surprise that many people are nervous in the saddle. But don't be fooled into thinking that being a less confident rider is a bad thing. There's nothing wrong with it as long as you can enjoy yourself. Personally, my confidence as a rider ebbs and flows in time with my confidence as a person. Sometimes I will go out hacking on a strange horse and go for a gallop or have a race or sit a series of massive bucks and it's loads of fun. Other times I won't even pop over a small cross-pole on a pony I trust and know like the back of my hand! My nervous-rider days are always the same as my shy-person days :rolleyes:

he got very excited and turned into a bucking bronco between fences. We managed to get round the course (clear and without me falling off)

I thought that I was really getting somewhere with my riding and now I feel like I am back to square one!

It sounds to me like you just need to change your perspective a little, and see your riding in a different way. The horse pulled out awful behaviour but you were capable enough to deal with it, and to go clear despite it. If that is not your definition of "getting somewhere with your riding"... you are one hard person to please ;) The point is that you are skilled enough as a rider that such a naughty horse did not cause major problems or send you flying!
The fact that you were too nervous to do anything after that round is not the important factor here.

Confidence is a fantastic thing of course, but you have to remember that nerves come from a sense of self-preservation. Being nervous is your mind's way of saying "what you're doing is dangerous, please take care"! Considering how dangerous horseriding can be, I don't think that's a bad thing :)
 
Last edited:
Thank you all for your replies. I am looking forward to riding him again tomorrow and hopefully my confidence will be restored. I am trying to think positive thoughts about it - it was the worst bucking experience that I have sat to and I didn't feel like I was going to fall off which is something. I did go and cry my eyes out in his stable when I took him back although no-one saw that!

I do think that I am scared of falling and hurting myself. I have been back riding after having a baby for a year now and haven't had a fall yet. I know that it is going to happen one day - 4 people came off at the same show and they just got right back on again. I am not sure that I could do that without bursting into tears and making a huge scene.

Before this event I was all set to ride in a bigger show in a couple of weeks. Now I am totally undecided if I should do it or not. It's supposed to be fun, but I will be so nervous of him bucking that I am bound to wind him up and make him even worse. Why is it all so difficult???
 
My sympathies are with you, if there's one thing in my old age I hate, it's a bucker.
 
Of course, being prepared as much as you can, and not doing something stupid is important, but another thing that helps when you get an attack of the "What ifs?", is to ask yourself: "Could I handle that?" Usually, you have to admit that you could handle that. Sometimes that helps make it go away or at least it loses some of its power of you! Hang in there! :D
 
Confidence with a horse is a lot of things. First and foremost it's realizing that you are sitting on A LOT of power. There needs to be a respect for, not a fear of that power. Once you have that and you can focus that power with lots and lots of practice, the confidence is a side effect.
 
My confidence is rubish on other peoples horses!

My confidence is always up and down.
On my own pony im fine i'll hack him out and do all the usual stuff, i was even fine at college but when i went to ride my friends horses i totally lose it i think its because she gets horses in and doesnt know them(deals horses) and 1 of them did take off with me but luckily i stopped him before he dumped me!!
Confidence is a strange old thing tbh cos sometimes i have it and other times i don't only on other peoples horses!!
My youngster plays up at times but all in all hes a good boy so i dont worry about him doing anything i have fallen off him before because he started bucking as his saddle didnt fit when i got a new saddle i was scared hed do it again but he hasnt so ive built my confidence again.

Good luck and if i was you i would go to the show as you may find your pony will be as good as gold and completly surprise you!!
And you will feel much better after youve done it yes you'll be nervous first but tell yourself you'll be ok and you will be!! :)
 
Do you wear a vest? Maybe if you wore one it would help you mentally because you'd be able to think, "I have a vest on, I'll be ok, I can do this." It also helps once you've fallen off a few times and been ok. :P
 
Thanks everyone. I rode again last night and although the confidence was fragile I did OK in the end. I found it amazing how much my nerves influenced my horse. He normally jumps everything that I point him at, but last night my mind was full of thoughts along the lines of "please don't buck me off" that he kept stopping. I found myself looking down at the jumps and doing everything I know that I shouldn't be doing. He was just looking after me by stopping as he knew I wasn't sure about it. He is such a lovely horse I need to be tough with myself and tell myself not to be so stupid.

We are playing 'games' in our lesson next week whatever that means. I am actually hoping that he gets excited and that I manage to ride him confidently through it. I love to see him enjoying himself and don't want to stop him having fun. He is a horse that potentially I may have the oppotunity to buy in the future so I need to get over my nerves.
 
newrider.com