WHY do so many loans go wrong?

fairlady

New Member
Jul 14, 2007
10,260
1
0
Bristol
I have been both a loaner and a loanee. One loan went horribly wrong when having two small children and being up the Yard every day without fail for the previous 18 months, despite the fact that the Owner lived on the premises about 10 yards away from the stables, I mentioned that although I could come up to put the Horses away on Christmas Day I certainly would not be riding and would be willing to muck out etc., when I put the Horses away.

Well you would have thought it was the 'end of the World' and we had a major row with me basically losing it and telling her to put the Horse where
the sun does not shine. This had without doubt 'been brewing' lol, for a
long time and I had in all honesty put up with having had the 'mickey taken' for a long long time. It was as they say, the straw that broke the camels
back. We DID, I hasten to say, make up, lol, and are now the best of friends again, and have been for the last 20 years but it left a nasty taste for a long long time.

When I was in trouble, same girl as above loaned my Arab, it was fabulous,
tbh I couldn't have found a better person, she hit a bad spell with the Death of her Mother and suddenly wanted to buy, I didn't
want to sale and Horse came back. I then found a part loaner and that
worked out really really well until the final demise of my marriage and I had to
eventually sell him about a year on.

I read about so many loans on here that go wrong, poor Sarah being the latest, and quite honestly have witnessed the state some
Horses have come back in when loaned by Members on here to OTHER MEMBERS!!!! I just wonder WHY do these loans go so horribly wrong.

Do people genuinely not care as much for other peoples horses or are we,
Owners, once we feel the Horse is settled with suitable people, a bit guilty
of not keeping 'tabs' of what is going on. This isn't meant to be an accusation in any way shape or form, honestly, but I just wonder why so
many loans go as wrong as they seem to do.

I personally, would loan, maybe part share one of mine should the
need arise again, but I think I would only share one of mine now from my
own Yard where I could keep an eye on what is happening.

I guess with the amount of people who do either loan their Horses or indeed loan somebodies Horse, some are bound to go wrong, but
why does it all seem to end up with such nastiness.
 
Last edited:
I honestly don't know either, like you experience of it on both sides

a) loaned a horse, went to see him/ride him, he was being moved to our home from a london yard, had him a year, owner didn't inspect us before he came to us, I decided to send him back as he needed to be somewhere with other horses his own age, didn't really like being only horse with the donkeys. He came to us naked, i equipped him with saddle bridle rugs, paid his insurance premiums (her policy as he was loss of use), and when we had to claim on something i paid the vets bills, and she pocketed the money.....

b) loaned a horse from charity, mad tb, she was difficult, had her a year, got her going quite well,then she reverted back to how she had been on arrival - almost as if she said right time to go back home. kicked me on hip, nearly broke it, till then had been not bad to ride, then she began to misbehave even doing that, finally though to myself why keep a horse that scares me, gives me nothing - sent her back with regret.

c) have one on loan now, she is basically mine, owner hasn't seen her in nearly 3 years....i could be doing anything to the horse. ok we are a distance away now but even when we were closer, didnt visit.

d) put mine out on loan, came back a wreck, injured,thin as a rake. loanee didn't insure it, didn't pay £2500 vets bill caused while in her lack of care, came back covered in lice and like something out of the Brooke hospital - this was a veterinary nurse by the way.

e) had one i shared, owner difficult, always changed our riding times, so i ended up paying but never riding! loved the horse, hated the owner who neglected him. he got sold in the end.

f) shared 3 with their owner, got to ride whichever one he wasn't talking to, worked brilliantly, got to ride really nice horses till they got sold

g) shared 1 when owner had young baby and not much time, worked very well, till i moved. also was coming to the end as she now had the baby in childcare and had more time.

each time i have been totally honest and above board, and have ended up paying for 3 x times saddles, rugs, none of the loan horses even came with a headcollar......and naturally none of the stuff fitted the next one.

if there is any rhyme or reason in this, let me know.
 
i loaned a pony and it went completely wrong. I think it was down to the owner being jealous of my relationship with "her" pony. The owner was my RI/YO and she'd bought the pony for her riding school. when that folded and all but 2 liveries (including us) had deserted her, she offered us many incentives to stay, including completely free, full loan of this pony. the bossing around and being told what to do i could tolerate, but she hated the fact that princey and i adored eachother. she finally removed him without my knowledge or consent to another family who (a) weren't interested in him and (b) the mother of the family was FAR too heavy for him. prince was part of our family and treated as such. his owner didn't treat him half so well. we really should have had things tied up in a contract i guess...
 
Our horse went on loan for 12 months only - this was stated & agreed from the start & was for a specific reason.
He was fit & well, total novice ride. He went with a full wardrobe & we visited regularly, when everything seemed fine.
Loaner started to drop hints that they had been gifted their other loan horse after 6 months. We stated clearly that wouldn't be possible with him.
They requested to extend the loan, we said that we couldn't.
They were due to bring him back but refused to. We went to his yard, but he had been moved. Another livery told us they didn't intend to give him back, that they had been beating him when he wouldn't load. They had left no new address for new yard.
We tried & failed to contact them by phone, & went round to address on loan agreement - where they had never lived - so had lied from start & we stupidly hadn't verified home address.
We found where our horse was eventually & they then told us to collect him within 2 days, but couldn't as we had to take our little daughter to a specialist hospital in Oxford for neuro-surgery. We had also been told he wouldn't load anymore. We explained that we needed another couple of days for him to be collected.
They moved yard again without us knowing where he was.
We eventually located & collected him. It took over 6 hours to load him as he was now so frightened. His rugs were lost, leather headcollar also missing, feet a mess, etc.
We got him home & it took weeks for him to return to the chilled horse we'd loaned.
Nightmare!
 
Gosh what nightmares some of you have had:eek: I have never loaned a horse myself but have loaned out to others - BUT always horse to be kept on my yard under my (hopefully not to much) watchful eye.

Been very, very lucky and now have life long friends with my ex loanees. Not sure about my new 'share' type loanee yet - seems to be going OK but will comment further in next few weeks;) - wish she was more careful with grooming girth and bridle area before tacking up and untacking - just minor stuff but gentle little hints will hopefully smooth these issues out? Watch this space?:p
 
I have loaned and loaned out horses...

1. I loaned a connemara x 14.2hh pony. His owners were lovely and I was very happy with him. Unfortunatley within 3 months of the loan starting he had damage to both hind suspensory ligaments (which vet thought had been there prior to the loan due to him being a jumping pony, I only did flatwork). Anyway he had shockwave treatment and 3 months box rest at mine before his owner and I decided it would be better if he went home as it was mentioned he would need further shockwave treatment (which i funded) and another 9 months field rest and even then might not come completely sound. So although he and the owners were lovely I had a very expensive six month loan with hardly any riding!

2. I loaned my older 12.3hh sensible mare out at a first pony to a nearby lady, for a little girl to ride and gain confidence on. I was lied to from the start and it turned out the little girl wasn't a novice rider but did pony club and jumped as well as hacked out! I found out my little pony had been worked hard by that child and other adults who weighed a lot more then she could carry, she was jumped too high for her age and fitness and smacked when she started to refuse. I went to check on her 2 weeks into the loan and had a huge argument involving me taking the pony home minus all her stuff incld rugs and tack (which i got back later). They had also scalped my pony and clipped her so badly she looked like a zebra (she was white/grey with black skin) she also had a bad back, laminitis and had lost weight and was nervy and spooky. It took another 6 months to get her back to the pony she was. I puther on loan (was a loan withh view to buy) and I was having a baby and was worried I wouldn't be able to cope.

In the end I did sell her after she had recovered to a lovely family who keep in touch and are a true forever home having lots of fun with her at a level that is acceptable for her.

3. I have a sharer currently who is really good, friendly and rides/handles well. Although she's a bit untidy!! She's onl;y 13 so sometimes the teenagers are better then adults!!

Would i loan again....um, probably not. If I had to I would loan from my yard only but I don't think I'd let a pony go out on loan again away from my yard.
 
I think often the problem is that the loaner does not really want anything to change and the person loaning wants to treat the horse as their own and may have different views on how to work with horses.

Imagine loaning someone your pet eg dog/cat and imagine the issues. Very easy to see the problems that arise even with people with the best intentions.
 
I think often the problem is that the loaner does not really want anything to change and the person loaning wants to treat the horse as their own and may have different views on how to work with horses.

Imagine loaning someone your pet eg dog/cat and imagine the issues. Very easy to see the problems that arise even with people with the best intentions.

Very true!
 
I hate this thread it's really upsetting. Some of you have been treated so badly and lied too and thats just you not your beloved ponies.

I have had two loans/shares

1) Awesome arab, girl went to uni and had no time for her anymore. I had her 3 years she was amazing. we did everything together I paid for anything new but when she needed a new saddle I spoke to the owner as I wanted to part ex the old one she was happy with that and went in half the cost. Only gave her back as I joined the RAF. Even then the owner gave me £100 as a thank you.

2)Sharer again ace partnership never a crossed word, had her 5 years again only gave her back as I moved camps to Lincoln and she would not let me take her. (she had been saying for years I could take her with me as she only rode once a week if I was there to tack up etc)

But in all some of us sharers are good and really care for the horses we look after. I wish you all better luck in finding the perfect one
 
"Break down of communication" is usually my problem... I hear of a problem with the loanee, and can't deal with it:( I think i'm seen as a soft touch, and when I ask for something like, when my big 'un had a bad back, I asked for my sharer to take it easy and not to push him. it went "over" their head, and they just carried on, as if the horse was a robot:mad:
At the moment, I have no sharer, as I worry history will repeat itself, and will defo never loan him out, as I'd worry too much, I suffer anxiety as it is...
he's just getting himself right and starting to enjoy his work again:) My instructor said that despite not doing much with him, we've made a lot of progress (3 lessons in 10 weeks, and three 20 mins sessions in 3 weeks, with nothing in between, and we've improved immensely!
She reckons he'll make a good show cob, when I've re-schooled him:D And a great rider out of me:)
Out of 5 sharers, over 4 years, I only had one good one, and she can only get over to see him every now and then:( she no longer "shares him" but still comes up to spend time with him:)
 
most of my shares have worked well, particularly the ones where i have shared older horses who can work but who you need to look after, and they have been a joy to ride, as i got to ride some talented high performance horses at the ends of the their lives, when they were still active and happy to hack out for 3-4 hours but gently, gave them fun but again, gently, not galloping the socks off them. I was quite happy to do this sort of riding on the south downs, equine tourist, and we had some wonderful times.

Humphrey, my last share, was in his 20s and a 17hh ex showjumper who was an absolute luvvie, just adored going out, just point him out the yard and off he went for hours - but slowly, nicely, just walks and trots, sometimes a little canter, but taking care of him. He was my nicest share, I adored him, he wsa such a gentleman. it was a priviledge, for the year i had him, to care for him.
 
newrider.com