skib...great post
Please dont assume bitless equates with loose rein. It just dont happen that easily.
Ok, around here, it works like this.....when riding bitless in a halter, 1/2 bosal, leather bosal, rope hackamore or some wierd and wonderful rope 'thingo' we are playing with, the horses are trained or i should say, conditioned to give an acceptable response to a given cue, to prevent the need to retrain each horse, we use the same body, leg and hand cues no matter what tack we are using.
This is the big thing about going bitless....it does not mean just throwing away a spanish snaffle or whatever and buying a 6" buckle and cowboy hat.
It means going back to square one with your horse, and that is a beautiful thing. it gives us a chance to build that relationship we heard so much about.
the point is that if you spend the time to establish responses to cues that do not involve yanking on the mouth or nose...you can ride in anything, anytime and feel good doing it.
we all know that if we buy the XYZ bit or MR.XYZ bitless bridle our horses are gonna stop, turn and do a perfect side pass instantly...right.....right? NO.....it is the training that controls the horse not the tack.
i think the problem is no one believes it takes as long as it takes. we have a mare that after 3 years is still only ridden bitless in the large sq yard, due to an attitude relating to down transitions, but at the same time our 2 yo unbacked appy stallion moves in all 4 directions, speeds up and slows down by following a hand movement. when backed, he will be a hackamore horse for a couple of years, then bitted, but it wont matter as the correct responses to cues were astablished & rewarded on the ground...then it will be taken into the saddle....loose rein, as not one cue needs to have even light contact to the bit, bosal, nose or whatever.
This is easier for us as we train for pleasure riding. but shadow( horse in the pic, top left) does fully collect 1" off verticle, for demonstration purposes ,on a short loose rein. John Lyons head positon work is easy to learn and can be adapted for any style of riding.
as i said, great post....and many of us have a similar experience, sorry but i did have a laugh as i associate with the incident describe.