What would you do......

Boofle bear

Member
Jun 17, 2015
87
44
18
55
Good morning all,I am just wondering what to do for the best... I have a gelding 10yrs old, I have had home for 12 months and I am learning to ride and all the usual horse care things that go with owning a horse ( I have asked questions about him before ). I initially got on well with him, then gradually he was trying to take charge and I got some help via a friend from a lovely lady who does natural horsemanship....He would not be brought in from field when she first came up to see him and when she attempted to he reared and jumped up and down a few times but he was brought in, she was not fazed at all... We worked on the ground a lot with him and leading is a lot better and I can put his food in stable without him snatching( we were told he was greedy around food when we got him) he was on is own for a bit and he is on our livery yard at home. I am on the look out for suitable company for him as been on his own is not good. We recently had a new arrival and a gelding and he gets on well with him ( a livery not mine) the trouble is when my riding instructor/ natural horsemanship trainer came other day he behaved just like he did when she first came, did not want to go past his friend in field( we were taking him down to our neighbours school to work with him) and was very hard to handle , all the way down he was spinning round and rearing up an down and took nearly a hour of her help to finally chill him out, he has behaved like this 4 times in the 12 months I have had him,. I am wondering if it is just a change to his environment that stresses him out or if he is just too much to handle and would be better with a more experienced person?? He is usually good to tack up, lift feet, rug up and groom, but if he is that way out he will let you know and become uncooperative to the point I want to give up....I like him but feel like I am not progressing at all and I am even now scared to take him out of the yard on my own to ride... Sorry for the long story and many thanks for listening...
 
Although twelve months might seem like a while to have had him it really isn't. I remember when Storm and I had been together almost two years and I felt like I knew her pretty well and had experienced pretty much all she had to offer. It was not true and when we brought them home to live it brought out new aspects of her character and behaviour. It may well be true that your gelding responds to an experienced handler but don't give up - so long as you are fair and consistent there is no reason you can't work things out together. Storm was still a challenge after six years! We have been together now 12 plus and she can still surprise me on the ground! It's good that your lad has a friend now, because that won't have helped him being alone. I think it's just time, patience and routine that works.
I appreciate it can be scary alone, even after all the time I have owned our two, if I am here alone and they are on a mission it can be hairy fetching them in! Make yourself safe: (or as safe as you can be) hat, bp, steel toe bootss and gloves. Take things slowly. Don't put yourself in a bad spot by forcing yourself into doing something just because you feel you ought to.
I am sure there will be lots of opinions on here, this is just mine and my experience. I am sure when I home shortly I will no doubt be asking for NR wisdom as mine take their time to settle and we are presented with new behavioural challenges! Lots of positive vibes to you anyway.
 
Not wanting to leave his buddy isn't massively suprising if he's been on his own for a while. The new horse will have changed the herd dynamics, the herd just grew from you and him to 3/4 so him playing up could well be him trying to find his position within that group, as trews says, being firm, fair and consistent will see that settle down pretty quickly. I would stress routine will make it easier, even if you don't plan to ride bringing him away from his buddy daily, for food, a groom etc, will help you maintain and build your relationship with him and his confidence that when you ask him to leave he will return :)
Being engaged woth a good RI to help you through it is a good plan :) what are her thoughts on his behaviour?
As a last, if his behaviour is scaring you it might be worth considering using a calmer, to help you both over the hump of the confidence vs bad behaviour cycle as unfortunately it can become a downward cycle before you know it, but if he were a little calmer and you could be a little more confident it can quickly become an upwards one, you might only need it for a few weeks :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Keren@serendipity
Thanks guys, never thought of a calmer, my trainer is not fazed at all by his behaviour and said it was purely because he did not want to leave his new mate and was making sure we both knew that... I just have a terrible lack of confidence?..cod you recommend any calmers?
 
You have done the right things working with your trainer and I would take her advice rather than a forum. However one thing I would say, there was a saying on our livery yard that the worse behave horses were those that had gone to a NH trainer. The implication was that NH was not effective.
I think the other way round - that people with a problem with a horse turn to NH for help. The NH works but the problem with that horse is never going to vanish completely - with different people or circumstances it will return, just as it did with your horse. So pretty normal and whether you can feel safe to keep the horse will depend on your feelings about him, rather than anything else.

So often it is a gut feeling with horses. One will work endlessly to correct a horse that one loves; my share horse bit - and would spin and flee for home, so some people on the yard refused to hack her. But I loved her so much. And I wasnt afraid of her.
Other clients' horses on the yard which behaved badly, I wouldnt have kept - It is always down to the owner and their feeling for an animal.
 
I
Thanks guys, never thought of a calmer, my trainer is not fazed at all by his behaviour and said it was purely because he did not want to leave his new mate and was making sure we both knew that... I just have a terrible lack of confidence?..cod you recommend any calmers?
I'd talk it over with your RI and see if she thinks a calmer might help, she's seen you work together after all :) I had some success with magnesium based calmer to slow dramatic over reactions but it will only work if there is a mag deficiency.
 
My horse trainer thinks I just need to know how to manage him. And once I can manage this behaviour when it happens I will be ok, she agreed when she first can he was not a horse for a novice but it was possible to manage him, I just have mixed feelings about him, I would not see him come to any harm and like him but don't have that feeling if you get me... Or am I just been silly?
 
Thanks seeing spots for that it makes sense... You see some days he is brill on all ways and i think brill we are getting somewhere... Then he will try and nip when I am putting his jacket on or doing is feet and it make s me nervous then I am back to square one or it at least feels like it! But yet I can tell what sort of mood he is in the moment I get him out of the stable, he is a horse that will push and definitely challenge you and try to do and go where he want.s......A lady who had her horse in our field once hit him with a feed bucket hard( I did not like this one bit) and he came right back at the in a threatening way, I would never and have never done anything to make him threaten me, but as he needs someone who will constantly keep him in check. When I first started riding him he was unresponsive to me, and walked like a slug, now he will respond to a little squezze and is a lot more forward going ....he does have a lot of good point and he definitely keeps me on my toes, I am allways watching his every move whatever we do as I don' t 100% trust him, which I surpose you allways have to be careful as anything can happen at any time , they are a animal after all .. Thanks for all your input it is really great thanks
 
  • Like
Reactions: SeeingSpots
Ive sold in the past on several occasions over the years because it hasn’t been working out. Total kudos to those who keep battling on... Im happy and willing to work through issues with a horse but one thing for me is a deal breaker; you said you are now scared to take him out by yourself. If I get to the point Im scared, really scared of a horse I sell, move on, rehome. Life is too short and horses are too expensive, if you feel like this after 12 months Id be thinking about my options. Horse ownership shouldn’t be like this, I feel for you. Only you can decide what’s best but don’t beat yourself up if you decide to move him on.
 
"My horse trainer thinks I just need to know how to manage him. And once I can manage this behaviour when it happens I will be ok, she agreed when she first came he was not a horse for a novice but it was possible to manage him"

That doesn't sound like the relationship I would want to be honest. I don't want a horse I need to learn to manage, because the behaviour I need to learn to cope with isn't happening.
Don't get me wrong, horse ownership comes with little pot holes along the way, but it's not about feeling scared.

"I am allways watching his every move whatever we do as I don' t 100% trust him, which Isurpose you allways have to be careful asanything can happen at any time"

Eh, no it's not about watching their every move because you don't trust them and he is doing things that make you nervous. Do you know why you feel nervous if he nips, instead of confident to correct?

It's your choice, but I tend to think it's a time consuming expensive way to be unhappy. Horses should be enjoyed, fun and a pleasure. That's why we have them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Keren@serendipity
All sound advice ladies, thank you very much, I don't know why he try's to nip, I do not know how to correct it...like you say I just want to be able to tack up and get on and get out of the yard...at the moment I will only go with someone else either on a horse or with them walking with me. We are looking for some company for him( he has company at moment but not my horse) but like you say can't change what he does , only manage it and to be honest, I am not sure I want to.....I surpose all horse have there little quirks but I can't cope with anything nasty or intimidating, makes me nervous so it's a catch 22 , I feel nervous and he knows and it just gets worse. When I am on him he is quite good and has never( touch wood) done anything dangerous but when he has been a bit horrible it makes me nervous on him as well. I feel I am going around in circles! I can truly say I have never felt genuinely excited about getting him out for a groom, or going on a ride, so I surpose I am answering my own questions really ..... I think he would be brill for a confident rider... I have offers from horsey friends to ride him for me to keep him going, but that's not really addressing the situation is it?
 
There is nothing wrong with selling on. On the other hand, there is no guarantee that another horse won't develop problematic behaviours too! I would not want a horse I could not trust so for me if I had a horse who was aggressive on the ground I would need to work out if this was to do with him (his personality/temperament), his history (learned behaviour, defensive aggression, resentment etc) or my handling - reinforcing unwanted behaviour, not protecting my personal space, inconsistency, no boundaries etc.

If it is mainly the first, there is not a lot you can do about it and I would sell on if we did not gel. Most horses are willing and generous but a few are grumpy buggers! If it's mostly the 2nd you can change things to an extent though I think fear is easier to overcome than resentment. I have come to believe over time that my kids' pony Zak was resentful and every so often carted them for no reason other than he no longer wanted them on his back. Maybe I could have worked that out with him but after 8 months of trying various approaches with no improvement, I no longer wanted to risk further injury to my kids, so he was sold. The 3rd possible reason is handling. Almost all horses will test the boundaries at some stage and some horses will re-evalaute where they stand in relation to you almost every day! (Oscar does. Also maybe @Jessey 's Jess too??) If handling is the problem and you do not develop handling skills you may just wind up here again with another horse.

Good luck with whatever you decide and remember there is nothing wrong with selling on. Horses take over our lives and empty our banks. We need to be enjoying it!
 
Jess does indeed push the boundaries regularly, its not that I don't trust her, but I do know her and loose in the field you have to keep half an eye on her at all times, she wouldn't dream of doing anything once you have hold of her as she knows she won't get away with it (or perhaps she would but she's taught me to be so consistant I don't realise I'm enforcing the line all the time). With her its mostly about pecking order and food, she's not bucket agressive but if she feels hungry she can have a major temper tantrum and part of that is moving the herd to food or to push lower ranking individuals away from food, occasionally she tries this with me but as long as I stay calm and consistent about the boundries she falls in line pretty quickly now but honestly she injured me a few times before I learnt and I would have sold her as a 2 year old if I could have got near her at the time :p but now my friends 6 year old is learning horse keeping and riding with her (never allowed in the field with her loose without me there)
 
Yes I think he does push it, most days leading to our field which is literally out the yard across a tiny lane , no through traffic and towards the field gate. I always make him wait while I open the gate, he does this no problems and ask him to walk and he does again no worrys and stands for me to take his head collar off. I don't even have to go in the field to put his collar on if I don't want as he will stand and let me put it on again no worries..he will allways be at the gate first and want to come out first and makes everyone ( horse) back up out of his space... Today I walked him down the road that he has gone down lots of times but with another horse. He was nasty biting other horse and ears flat back and trying to bite me, he freaked out everything he saw( normally very good when riden ) was a real hand full. When we came to a grass area, he stopped and would not move, every time I tried he just got all confrontational and jumpy ears back... I was upset when we got back to yard I burst in to tears, and I felt useless......
 
Roxy always takes a while to settle down if the dynamics in her herd change for any reason - she gets anxious as she's quite dominant and wears herself out herding 'her' mares away from the new arrival. Plus the spring grass has kicked in and ALL the horses on my yard are sharp at the moment, even the usually dopey ones. My friend went out to bring one of hers in today wearing a hat, gloves and BP! Roxy was dancing round me when I brought her in this morning too (I don't mind so long as she's not close enough to squash me!) Try not to worry. It took me about a year to get used to Roxy's ways. She wasn't really a horse for a novice either, and I was a novice, but you can learn how to manage them - you just have to be assertive and insist that you are top dog and not them. Again, it took me a while to master this, and I had some help from an excellent RI, but it can be done and once it's done, you're fine.
 
Hi all , a little update... My riding instructor/ natural horsemanship lady has been to day, I have told her about the past week and she was not fazed at all and said he is trying to be the boss again! We did a bit of ground work today and had him backing up a and generally going where we/ l said/ asked . Then I rode him and he was good...... She says I need to work with him everyday just to remind home who is the leader ..... Do you lady's/ gents think this is what I will always after do , like a constant battle for top dog seat...most people I know just seem to manage there horses everyday without any of them having to remind them everyday who is the leader.... I am certainly confused but I am going to try this every day with him and see how he responds , do you ladies and gents have to do this on a regular basis or are all horses different.. Thing been I don't want to have to have to constantly have to feel I have to figh with him( not literally ) every day...... Thanks again for listening guys
 
I have to remind Oscar regularly that he is not allowed to walk through me and drag me around. The others just learnt the rules once and never push it now.
 
I see KP I guess some horses like you say learn and are respectful , I am guessing my boy will allways try to push it, it's just do I want a horse I constantly have to remind??? See today I like him and feel terrible for having thoughts of changing him, other days I could gladly have some one take him away. ....
 
All horses are different and it's really down to what type of horse you get along with and where your confidence/ability sits.
I don't know how I feel about this being the alpha, I'm more 51/49 in my favour.
I wouldn't say I have to remind mine of her manners all the time, but lunging she might straighten the circle with you running behind to get her to bend or at least stop! If that makes someone nervous she isnt for you.
 
newrider.com