What would you do?

Soot

Paranoid!
Aug 7, 2007
6,135
0
0
East Sussex
I'm still not really able to ride with my broken knee :(.

Called my RI to cancel my Sunday lesson, and she offered to ride Lucy instead & do some canter work. Alternatively, she said we could take it easy & do some physio style riding to see how the knee works with careful attention.
The lessons are over 1 hour drive from home ... On the one hand I am DESPERATE to ride! On the other, it might be nice to watch Lucy getting it for once ;). OR cancel completely and save the cash? Decisions!! Argh!!!
 
I'd be inclined to let your RI ride her, you should still be able to benefit without risk to your knee. You can watch and learn from how Lucy reacts to your RI and have the advantage of being able to see how she goes from the ground and your RI will be able to try stuff more instantly rather than having to try and explain to you what she wants. Hope your knee is better soon whatever you decide
 
unless you have the all clear to ride then DONT.You could do far more damage by risking it than by resting it.If you are having specific problems with your horse then get the instructor to ride her so you can see her in action and get advice on how to overcome them.Otherwise cancel and save your money.
 
I'd save your money. Maybe when your up to riding you could get your instructor to ride your horse for half the lesson to get her going really nicely, then you have the second half of the lesson so you can get a really feel of how it should feel after your instrutor has got her working really nicely.
 
I'd have the RI ride her. Great for the horse and interesting for you to watch too :)



I'm leaning this way ;). I think it's not fair on Lucy to be out of work just because I am? But on the other hand, it's a long way to drive to then pay someone to ride Lucy while I stand in the rain & watch.

Also I intend to ride a dressage test in 2 weeks and I have a feeling I'll only have been back in a saddle for a few days, so might be good for Lucy to have been schooled at least once in the 4 weeks of me not riding? A friend is hacking her out twice a week at the moment, but Luce is used to being ridden every day so is going a bit bonkers!

ETA: My RI runs an event yard & had Lucy for 10 days training livery this summer, so I know what they look like together ...
 
It depends whether you can afford it and whether you think she needs the schooling.

When I did something very simillar in March (broken tibia and torn lateral collateral ligament) I gave Clover the summer off, but he'd been hunting hard and needed a holiday. I started riding him again at the begining of October. It's basically ok, but still feels quite woobly if I canter for a long time.
 
I would get your RI to ride her. I always find it beneficial for an instructor to ride my horse. It helps them to understand how the horse ticks.
It will keeps Lucy' mind occupied too especially if you are competing almost straight after you come back into work! She will need to be on the right wavelength.
 
If you have faith in your RI i would go with letting her ride :)

As you said you want to do a test in a couple of weeks so for her to be kept in work i think is the best idea.

I think allowing RI to ride on occassion is beneficial to both you and the horse. They get a good feel and i think this is turn goes to help when schooling you.
 
Have just called RI to confirm that she will ride Lucy for me on Sunday. This way Lucy will get schooled at least once before my dressage test in 2 weeks, and I will feel less guilty about her meandering round the pasture! Will take loads of pics - Lucy looks lovely with Penny ... not that I'm jealous or anything *cough*.

To those who said I shouldn't get RI to ride instead of me -- can I ask why? Is it ust because you don't like someone else on your horse, or do you feel you don't benefit some someone else doing the schooling? Be interested to know!!
 
Have just called RI to confirm that she will ride Lucy for me on Sunday. This way Lucy will get schooled at least once before my dressage test in 2 weeks, and I will feel less guilty about her meandering round the pasture! Will take loads of pics - Lucy looks lovely with Penny ... not that I'm jealous or anything *cough*.

To those who said I shouldn't get RI to ride instead of me -- can I ask why? Is it ust because you don't like someone else on your horse, or do you feel you don't benefit some someone else doing the schooling? Be interested to know!!


I don't own at the moment but when I did I just did not like other people riding my horse- especially not for schooling. I think it's because I was the only one who rode him and wanted him to act from my aids and not another persons. As in, I wanted him to know what I asked. I'm not making any sense- it's just not for me!!
 
I get what you're saying, Sonnet. It was a bit similar for me with Rambo .. With Lucy (she's my loan horse) I am less precious, but mainly because I am aiming at a much higher level than ever before ... but am only at Prelim *lol* ... so I guess I need all the help I can get if I'm going to progress before I'm retired!
 
I get what you're saying, Sonnet. It was a bit similar for me with Rambo .. With Lucy (she's my loan horse) I am less precious, but mainly because I am aiming at a much higher level than ever before ... but am only at Prelim *lol* ... so I guess I need all the help I can get if I'm going to progress before I'm retired!


Ah yes, I always forget you loan her!! I can understand why you'd want to though- not that I've ever had any great dressage aspirations!!
 
newrider.com