What do you think...

Nor would I Trewsers....I can see the horse replacing the door kicking with a whole load of other unwanted habits...like box walking for one...He looks very close to being a box walker already in the first bit before he starts kicking the door.

I think I would be completely reviewing how he is kept and looking for other ways to sort him..I dunno really, just doesn't seem to be the right fix to me.:frown:
 
agree that i would worry about them developing another habit.

Moet kicks if she knows she's getting feed. If the spray happened she would definitely hit her head on the door frame, and then be nervous of the door.

Rosie would just turn around and double barrel the door, being so 'offended' that i had used such a tool lol
 
Easy answer... don't stable horses!! My Harvey is a door kicker. He hates being in and I can understand why.

I leave mine out 90% of the time because of this. If I had a field shelter I would leave them out 100% of the time.

Horses should be in paddocks!! Unless on box rest, but even then I would confine to a tiny turnout area instead.

I hate seeing horses shut in :-(
 
Easy answer... don't stable horses!! My Harvey is a door kicker. He hates being in and I can understand why.

I leave mine out 90% of the time because of this. If I had a field shelter I would leave them out 100% of the time.

Horses should be in paddocks!! Unless on box rest, but even then I would confine to a tiny turnout area instead.

I hate seeing horses shut in :-(

Ahha! Someone who takes my view on this. If Solly was ever kept in (very rarely)he would kick the door at feed time, which is pretty normal I guess but still not ideal from any horse. I'm sure if he had been kept in on a regular basis he would have happily kicked away at his door all day long until someone set him free!

I know we aren't all lucky enough to have the choice on how they are kept on livery yards.....but if I have not owned my own land in the past, I always rented fields rather than keep at livery....it is far more natural, leads to far fewer health and behaviour issues.

As for setting your horse up to be 'sprayed' every time he does kick the door instead of finding another way to keep him occupied and happy? Well words (almost:wink::giggle:) fail me!
 
Oh my gosh that's horrible!

I really REALLY don't like it. If they are kicking the stable door it's for a reason!! (Mine use to do it because it was dinner time :rolleyes:)
 
As always silver is The exception - she has to be stabled to keep out the sunshine. Ideally I would have a massive open plan barn and she would live in there with hay 24/7 in summer and the barn opened up onto turnout in winter.

Aside from that this isn't something I would ever use - negative enforcement has been evidenced to not resolve problems
 
Ahha! Someone who takes my view on this. If Solly was ever kept in (very rarely)he would kick the door at feed time, which is pretty normal I guess but still not ideal from any horse. I'm sure if he had been kept in on a regular basis he would have happily kicked away at his door all day long until someone set him free!

I know we aren't all lucky enough to have the choice on how they are kept on livery yards.....but if I have not owned my own land in the past, I always rented fields rather than keep at livery....it is far more natural, leads to far fewer health and behaviour issues.

As for setting your horse up to be 'sprayed' every time he does kick the door instead of finding another way to keep him occupied and happy? Well words (almost:wink::giggle:) fail me!

I suppose we are lucky though C that we have ours at home and can do what we like ... a lot of people on livery don't get a choice though which is a shame.
 
I get why people don't like it I really do, and the horse in the advert looks to have other issues as well, but I personally would use it in the right situation on the right type of horse.

Minnie was once stabled next to a door kicker and it ruined my time at the yard with her immensely, the YO took action and squirted it with water when it did it and it stopped, it didn't box walk in response/instead or have any other issues while I was there, it just stopped kicking the door for hours on end.
 
Bob's only real vice is he hates being in the stable.....well he hates it in the summer but in the winter when its cold and dark and all his friends are coming in too he settles ok. He has to come in last and go out first though or he starts to get very upset. He's a man of routine I guess and just stresses out massively if he has to come in unexpectedly, even if there are other horses to keep him company. He does the works, box walks, kicks the door, tries to knock the door down, sweating, diarrhoea ...poor thing. This water thing would definitely NOT work it would just stress him out even more.
 
"Think I'll box walk instead :/"

Shadow learnt to kick the stable door after finding out he got haylage when he did it.. He saw kicking got him rewarded, hence encouraged him to carry on. He never used to do it.

Now a days, he doesn't always actually kick the door, just lifts his leg up and swings his foot, sometimes making contact but not really banging it as such. If not seen doing it, some people would assume he's weaving, but it's just a begging response, there's people about, he wants fed and out.. But he'll never really going stop doing it now, habit is engrained, I can only ignore it, and give him less reasons for him to see it as rewarding behaviour..
 
Nor would I Trewsers....I can see the horse replacing the door kicking with a whole load of other unwanted habits...like box walking for one...He looks very close to being a box walker already in the first bit before he starts kicking the door.

I think I would be completely reviewing how he is kept and looking for other ways to sort him..I dunno really, just doesn't seem to be the right fix to me.:frown:

Exactly, I would be looking at how the horse is managed. For example, if they are on box rest due to illness, then not a lot you can do bar, spend time with them and make toys etc available. But if they're spending time in for no good reason - well, what do they expect?! Time to review how things are done me thinks...............
 
Just wanted to add; our Chloe kicks the door when she hears me making her breakfast, but it does not matter and I certainly wouldn't punish her for it. Storm hasn't picked up the habit and I can't see her doing either.
 
Tobes kicks the door when he thinks I am taking too long to get him organised into going out.

But then he also tries to get his foot through the gate when he thinks he should be coming in!

So I suppose with him, tis a matter of the grass is always greener on the other side!

He loves his stable - but he wouldn't want to be in all the time, and he loves outside, but he doesn't want to be out there all the time either.

Have to say though, that the other horses around him haven't learnt his foot through the gate, or banging on the door.
 
If my horse kicked the door I'd replace it with wooden bars giving him nothing to kick. That thing spraying him regularly would I think be liable to make him nervous of doorways & if it did he would become dangerous to put in & take out. Have had to deal with a horse that was frightened of doorways & it's no joke as they rush in & out,a good way to have injuries either to the horse or yourself.
 
Dont like gadgets that give of electronic sounds. Not keen on stabling horses unless for medical reasons, my own opinion is they are easier managed when out the way nature intended, however as i am a big softy i leave the stable doors open and they go in and out as they please, but as horses are horses they prefer to stand out even when its cold or pissing with rain, mostly in when its hot.
 
newrider.com