What Actually is Waterproof?

Frances144

Spam Sniper!
Dec 21, 2011
8,427
3,348
113
Shetland, UK
www.myshetland.co.uk
Waterproof to me means it does not let in water.

All my rugs are good brands but they are NOT waterproof. Not all night waterproof. I hate finding a soaking rug on a horse that is wet underneath. It upsets me. There is no such thing as waterproof, I don't think. Not really. Rainsheets are not waterproof even if they say they are. I don't think it is sweat from the horse going upwards. It is not that hot and the horse is not soaking wet underneath but there is definite dampness under a rainsheet after a night's wear. Obviously I change the rug for a dry one and off we go again. It does not last the night being waterproof.

Thank you for listening to my rant.
 
I find there are a lot of things in the horse world that are not waterproof. Boots are one of my biggest beefs. Doesn't matter how much I pay, wellies or country boots the darn things are usually leaking within a week. I haven't noticed any of Zi's rugs leaking, but I know rain does drive down around the neck at times. Your rugs should last the night being waterproof, that is annoying. Grrrr.
 
My no fill rug isn't fully waterproof - but it does say so. If they don't have necks, I find the rain seeps in when they have their head down.

In very wet weather, I layer two up which seems to help.
 
I find there is a big difference in waterproof-ness depending on the denier, my 600d no fill is shower proof at best, my 1200d no fill is rain proof, my 1200d 100g is torrential rain proof, even when we have had day after day rain Jess is still bone dry underneath.
Totally waterproof (as in impenetrable to water) would also mean they were not breathable and perspiration would pool under them, I think that's why the 1200d 100g is so much more rain proof than the no fill, because the filling gives a little air movement gap between the rug and skin so it can breathe better.
 
I've never had a problem, but then I'm not putting rugs on thick winter coats. Even my rainsheets have stood up to prolonged proper rain, and they aren't mega expensive ones.

A friend who tends to buy cheap ones for a rug killer (or more accurately a wimp who lets others wreck his rugs) paints them in Fabsil or similar and that seems to work very well on ones that may otherwise be of rather dubious waterproofing.
 
I am putting a rug on Haakon. He is 26, stiff, retired now and feeling his age. He gets a rainsheet when it rains as I think he should live outside and stretch his legs as much as possible.

Though it is Force 10 tonight with torrential rain so he’s coming in to a big stable/shed with his friend.
 
I wasn't questioning your choice to rug, merely meaning my experience with rugging is generally with at least partly clipped horses. LU would probably claim he needed a rug all year round if he lived at yours!
 
My light weights dont seem to last long before they start letting water in. Ive actually gone to the medium weights as the boys were getting too wet in lightweights. They might as well not of had them on. I actually need to try some other rug proofers on them. The wash in one doesnt do anything. Im going to save the lightweights till spring when it warms up.

Its like leather boots that say waterproof. I wear them on the farm and i frequently have wet feet. I end up wearing wellies instead but at this time of year its a catch 22, as my feet get colder in wellies much quicker.
 
I rug my very old girl in a new rain sheet as she has Cushing she has a think coat but is in her thirties I was very annoyed when she cane in wet underneath it. So I feel your pain

Never had the problem with gingers rugs
 
I do wonder with rain sheets if it is like tents, where if you touch the inside they will leak........

I used the gold label rug proof and after that water beaded on the surface and ran straight off, the likes of nikwax wash in ones are useless by comparison.
 
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse
Thank jess i knew youd remind me what one you used. I am going to get some next time im at an appropriate tack shop. Im fed up of leaky rainsheets. The boys shouldnt be in medium weights on mild days but i dont want them soaked through giving them cold backs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
Ella is dry under her outdoor rug. But has a fleece under it as she is clipped. I will have a look at what brand it is. I have not ridden massively clipped horses before. My shaggy fun pony has been turned into something quite posh.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frances144
Ella is dry under her outdoor rug. But has a fleece under it as she is clipped. I will have a look at what brand it is. I have not ridden massively clipped horses before. My shaggy fun pony has been turned into something quite posh.
Thank you - that would be helpful.

An addendum - the rug must have leg straps. It is essential kit up here.
 
newrider.com