We're getting there...

According to last dressage instructor, I dont open my hips enough. Almost every lesson I would hear "Get those legs underneath you". She tried to fix this with no stirrup work. But, as Es says, no stirrups right now on Bonfire is not an option :D

Also, person taking pictures is a friend, not instructor and when I reviewed the pictures later that day, I asked her why she isnt telling me to get my legs under me. She said that Bon's tempo is too all over the place for me to be able to keep my legs under me. That sometimes Im above the movement, behind the movement, etc. Whether thats valid about my legs I dont know, but his tempo is a bit uneven right now. Nothing terrible, just spurts and slow spots here and there.

I could spare a hole or two in the leathers to lengthen my leg. Do you really think thats the issue though - that my stirrups are too short?

Thanks for that so far cvb!
 
I could spare a hole or two in the leathers to lengthen my leg. Do you really think thats the issue though - that my stirrups are too short?

it's certainly possible - but if you just lengthen your stirrups without sorting the underlying hip whatsit, then you'll just end up reaching for the stirrups and losing the (very good) security you have at the minute. i have a dodgy hip that seizes up in winter, and one thing that is useful for me is to take hold of the muscle at the back/inner thigh, and pull it out and up, and at the same time think about pushing my knee down. this will put the flat part of your inner thigh against the saddle, so giving you more leg on the side, and also help open your hips.

you'll find at first you'll have to keep on putting your leg into place, as it will want to spring back to where it was, but over time it will get easier to keep it where it ought to be.
i can keep my good leg in position for the whole ride, but have to re-align my bad leg about once every 10 minutes now - at first it was about every 30 seconds!
also keep in your mind 'how would i land if bon was spirited away' and try to keep the legs underneath you.

She said that Bon's tempo is too all over the place for me to be able to keep my legs under me.

have you tried riding to music at all? even a ticking clock or a loud metronome might be useful - horses like rhythmic music and it would help him maintain a good rhythm. on the one hand, i know it's hard to keep a good position when the horse is all over the shop, but on the other hand, if your position isn't stable then he will find it hard to find his rhythm as he will be compensating for your changes in position.
 
arg - 3rd time lucky at posting this I hope ! (I keep typing it and having problems)

You should be able to keep the shoulder/hip/heel alignment regardless of stirrup length - eg when you are at jumping length vs dressage length - the only difference is the angle of the knee.

However some saddles make you work harder at certain lengths of stirrup and will tend to pull you out of alignment. eg if you have a forward cut GP and are trying to ride dressage lengths, some designs will naturally sit the rider correct for a shorter stirrup length and you end up having to work more than you should to get the right alignment for a longer stirrups.

Few of us have the luxury of a saddle per purpose, so we have to work with what we have. I think its worth experimenting a little to try and find a length that helps you a bit more - why not try an extra hole and see how it goes ?

A more stable leg and balanced position will help you stay in balance, and hence help Bonfire balance. Whereas right now he is throwing you off balance at times, and you will be returning the favour by making it more difficult for him to carry your changing position !

Another though would be to see whether you are controlling your rise when in trot, (or rather the 'fall' of the rising trot) rather than just letting gravity do the work :p So what happens if you slow and control your rise - Bonfire should start to match and mirror you. Music helps here as it gives you both something to cue to - if you keep your tempo even (rather than just following him) it should encourage him to be more even. A slower tempo may also help him balance more - but you can experiment with this as well. (At what speed do you get least changes in rhythm ?)

I appreciate the problem with working no stirrups - could you try it a halt with a helper to hold him ? Then just think about lossening, lengthening, relaxing - do stuff like circling your feet from ankles (both direction), move leg back and forward from knee, then from hip. Lift leg away from saddle from hip. All with as little change in upper body as possible. Bring legs up to pommel (like a jockey) and then gently lower back again (this is good for checking that you are really sat on your seat bones).

and so on.....
 
newrider.com