Sugar free polis have sweeteners in 
Marmite sandwiches are my answer to all woes of feeding issues!
Marmite sandwiches are my answer to all woes of feeding issues!
I think you are right to ditch the muzzle. You know your horse and you are best placed to see what suits him. I won't use a muzzle either, Arns hates them. Stabling part of the day does not work for him either as he gets very stressed and then gorges in the time he is out knowing he would come off the grass later. I have def found out all the time with pregrazed grass best. I then electric fence off a square in the middle so they have to walk round a track to graze thus making them move more than traditional strip grazing.
You may find that as he loses weight he might not need the metformin anyway so hopefully it is a short term issue for you both.
Makes me realise I am lucky Arns eats the tablets. When you say 48 tablets do you mean divided into two doses? Not all at once?
Somebody else I know had success with Simple Systems Lucie Nuts which you soak and make a green paste.