In my humble opinion much of a horses 'bombproofness' comes from the rider, we have 3 pones and they are totally different with my daughter, than they are with me! My daughter is very calm and confident and I'm a nervous nelly!
This this & this 10 fold!!!
I was beginning to contemplate selling xander as he makes me so nervous & he's so spooky & silly. Then I started to let other people ride him & he never put a foot out of line. Then I just assumed they were better riders than me.
Then because of my nerves we did a horse swap the other day. A young girl (well, 18

) has the most rock solid bomb proof horse ever. It simply will not go & plods around painfully slowly everywhere. So the idea was for me to be able to see x being ridden & 'dealt with' to gain confidence that way, but mainly to get some confidence riding in different situations on this brilliant bombproof cob.
So we tack up & get on. We were meant to be going on the farm where my real fears were, but decided to get there the road way rather than through the back of the yard.
The moment we set off the mare started being silly! She was planting, snorting, shying, spooking, trying to turn & spin, diving in the middle of the busy road (whilst my just-turned-5 year old walked perfectly & happily behind).
All the way round her owner was saying "she's never done that before" "she never does that" "I've never seen her walk that fast!".
Constantly. We made a joke of it - it was funny as I've been out with them on hacks before (me riding my own) & *i* know she's a bloody bombproof cob!
Half way round I was begging for my own sodding horse back it was that bad! At least I can predict him...
Any way we made it back, nobody else could believe how she'd behaved.
My horse looked all smug as he'd had to take charge & lead the way past scary things, he never batted an eyelid at half the stuff she was going ballistic at.
So I now know that it's not about the horse at all (well in some circs it obviously is!) - its about the rider
I look back & the people who've ridden him aren't better than me at all - they're just more confident than me.
So no point at all in me getting a different horse when there's nothing wrong at all with the one I've got. He behaves immaculately with anyone else. And I'd get what instead? A mature been there done that bombproof horse that will transform into something completely different when I get on it?!!!
Yeh - no point at all
But now I know 100% it's me, I know I have to change me not my horse, which is the best thing as I bloody love him! in fact I'd rather just not ride again & keep him as a pet than swap him.
But seeing how I change horses & how good he can be, I also know there's hope
I've bought a carrier bag full of Bach rescue remedy & got tactics to start doing something about it this week on my week off
I already tackled a big issue this week after that big realisation, so fingers crossed!
Oops sorry, this wasn't meant to be so long & self indulgent but I thought it relevant to the thread
