*Warning* - Rant alert......

domane

Retired cob mum
Jul 31, 2005
15,978
6,023
113
As you all know, I'm currently contemplating my future with horses... well, if you didn't, I am... my accident has really knocked me mentally as well as physically and obviously I can't ride at the moment but the thought of getting on another currently fills me with terror. This is probably due to me still being broken and I'm assured that in time it will pass.

However, it doesn't stop me looking at adverts :tongue: (which I take to be a subconscious good sign... as well as being a bad habit :redface:)

But what REALLY gets my goat at the moment (other than the over-use of the word "stunning" :banghead:) is just how many horses and ponies I see advertised as "bombproof" when they are only 3, 4, 5, or 6 years of age. No-one can guarantee a horse is bombproof, least of all a baby one!!!!!! :timebomb::stomp::timebomb:

And.... breeeeeeeeeeeeathe.......
 
I dunno, I've met some unflappable youngsters? I know you can't guarantee they'll stay that way, but there's no reason they can't be as described.
 
I don't believe that ANY horse is entirely bombproof, but there's no reason a youngster can't be as close to it as an older horse can. Being young doesn't automatically make a horse less dependable - it's character rather than age that makes the big difference. I have known a number of very quiet, sensible youngsters who I would trust more than a lot of the adult horses I know!

Twirl is 3 and was backed less than 6 months ago, and she's one of the most sensible laid-back horses I have known for a long time. She doesn't spook or take fright at anything, and never has done. Out hacking, even going solo and/or on a new route, she is about as sensible as they come. She doesn't so much as look at strange objects, she's entirely unconcerned about being passed on narrow lanes by large noisy farm machinery, even when something takes her by surprise she doesn't show more than the most cursory of reactions. I did some homemade XC jumps in her field the other week, Mouse was loose in the field cantering alongside us / behind us / next to the jumps and she didn't bat an eyelid. I tried some "desensitisation work" in the school with plastic bags etc which proved a total waste of time as she was far more interested in getting scratches than anything I tried to surprise her with :giggle:

That being said - I do actually agree that it's silly to claim in a sale advert that a youngster is bombproof. Not because it's not possible, but because IMO it's highly unlikely that a 4-year-old has been exposed to the same number and variety of frightening objects / situations as a 10-year-old.
 
Hehehe take a chill pill missus! Lol. Good that you are looking at the ads...... I think this is telling you something....(Hope you are healing nicely btw).
 
The reason I sold my youngsters was the "unknown entity" part.... I just couldn't fact getting them through the first 2-3 years of ridden work, introducing them to new things whilst on their backs. On the ground, not a problem but the thought of them spinning, spooking or bolting scared the cr@p out of me! :redface: Don't get me wrong, I can sit all of those (or I thought I could :giggle:) but I'd much rather go for something with a long proven track record... when the occasional "moment" can be overlooked....
 
There is no such thing as a bombproof horse. Horses (healthy ones anyway) are flight creatures by nature, no one can get away from that it just has to be part of the package as does falling off on occasions. This was instilled in me from a very young age, you always, always have to be on your guard no matter how good they are.

I have three good ones but I have had to work, and think, very hard to get them that way, for me I am totally passionate about them but I never, never forget that they are horses. Big, strong mighty lovely creatures. My best friend and field owner was one of the first lady jockeys bless her, one of the old school, she is great with horses (and yes she did beat Kelly Marks:giggle: before her face lift) she would agree with me, you have to always be aware.
 
Domane you are still in a bad place, good you are looking at the ads, your accident was so unfortunate, really.

I have been trampled and crumpled and alsorts, it was just the luck of the day.

If you were nearly killed in a car accident would it stop you ever getting in a car again? I don't think so. Just get better and move on with the lovely mare and foal you have and the lovely big bay, they need you:smile: I know you can do it, just take time to get well and don't think to much. I love your posts and I think you are on the right track so don't let one daft horse put you off. Feel free to rant cos I know I upset you at times:unsure:
 
In my humble opinion much of a horses 'bombproofness' comes from the rider, we have 3 pones and they are totally different with my daughter, than they are with me! My daughter is very calm and confident and I'm a nervous nelly!
 
I think you need a Highland!

I happen to have a rather lovely one you are most welcome to come and ride if ever you venture down to the New Forest. He is the kindest pony in the world and would always look after you.

The only things he obejcts to are crab flies and the hunt or the drift (pony round up) going by. Other than that he is super brave.
 
I would definitely have agreed with you before I met my mate's five year old highland (who sadly had to pts). He was the boldest, most inquisitive wee guy and very happy to help out my Flip by being the lead horse.....flip being double his age at the time. I guess it depends also on the amount that they've seen in their short life. Friend had him out walking inhand for miles and it did him the power of good.
On saying all of that - I still wouldn't describe any horse as 100% bombproof. As I was told - a bombproof horse is a dead one.
 
As I was told - a bombproof horse is a dead one.

I quite agree!!!

Some by character are more dependable than others, but they are still half a ton of muscle that is overruled by an independent brain.

Puzzle is probably the most dependable mare I've ever met, I've taken her all sorts of places including through East London (I used to ride her home on Christmas Day), through Fun Fairs, past Circuses (never understood why the Zebra was what bothered her the most), round the Newmarket Sponsored Ride etc. I've fallen off relatively few times given that I've had her ten years, but the old bird is still partial to a broncing fit if she is in high spirits and will still bog off with me if she deems it appropriate.

She used to bog off with my little sister who was about 16 at the time, more than once she had to be escorted home by the forest rangers who were also on horseback.....one very sullen looking 16yo riding a very naughty but very pleased with herself coblet.

When we let my 5yo neice have a little sit on (me leading and OH holding her on), she is steady as anything though.
 
I think generally you are right in that young horses are less likely to have seen enough of the world or been exposed to enough things to describe them as 'bombproof'.

There are though some youngsters that are just so calm and take to things so sensibly that it's not unreasonable to call them bombproof.

I had a fell pony that was 6 yrs when I got him (vels mum on here now ownes him),and I would have said he was as bombproof as they come,and he had been like that since young AFAIK.
He was driving on a dual carriagway at 3 yrs so am guessing could call that bombproof!!

Personally though like you if I was buying I would take any statments of safety on a young horse with a pinch of salt,but that doesn't mean they're not out there.
 
Is it the pony or is it rider? I do some odd things, my loose stuff is one and leading through hoops is another thing people ask why. But the cob is only 4 years old so if i would like her to grow up able to deal with strange things besides me, then i need to show her.
Oh and i have plans for mounted games ;)
But does the bombproof ness depend on the underlying character of youngster and the person handling. How many homes could a horse have had by the time it reaches 4?
 
Last edited:
A horse doesn't have to be 'bombproof', being reliable and trustworthy are more important in my book. It is normal for horses to be unsure or worried in some situations, but if you know they're going to stay with you mentally and look to you for guidance, and get it from you, it makes all the difference. I do trust both of mine, I never get on them thinking 'you're dangerous' and they have yet to prove me wrong.
 
Not sure what thread or even what I am talking about anymore (NR bit drunk) I just judge every step. Each horse/pony is different but I have never turned out a bad one, it takes time and thought and intelligence, its a small or sometimes a big challenge but thats what I like, bringing out the best in the horse/pony (and the bloody dowg as posted on another thread:giggle:) People say to me my horses are lovely, they only see the tip of the iceberg lol. They ride off into the sunset. It takes much patience, much love, and perseverance to get a real good result, but so worthwhile, for me anyway:smile: Total horse lover:inlove:
 
Can I join in the rant?!?

I HATE it when a 3 or 4 year old cob is advertised as suitable for a novice rider :banghead:

At this age they're still learning and a novice (even with correct tuition) would really struggle to bring on a baby horse correctly.

Maybe I'll get shot down for saying this but it's my opinion.

I've seen plenty of quiet 3/4 yr old cobs bought for children on our yard (and others) who are fine to begin with and then get to 5 or 6 and have a total tantrum as they've not been shown the rules or the basics properly and it suddenly all builds up and goes bang
 
I HATE it when a 3 or 4 year old cob is advertised as suitable for a novice rider :banghead:

At this age they're still learning and a novice (even with correct tuition) would really struggle to bring on a baby horse correctly.

I've seen plenty of quiet 3/4 yr old cobs bought for children on our yard (and others) who are fine to begin with and then get to 5 or 6 and have a total tantrum as they've not been shown the rules or the basics properly and it suddenly all builds up and goes bang

Yes, I agree with this post.
I think people who buy youngsters often just look at how the horse is NOW, rather than giving more thought to its stage of learning and how its behaviour / character may change as time goes on. You could buy a 4-year-old who is suitable for a novice at the time, BUT without experienced handling and training they could be a complete nightmare in a year's time. I often wonder how many so-called "difficult" or "bad mannered" horses are just those who were in inexperienced homes as youngsters.
 
Can I join in the rant?!?

I HATE it when a 3 or 4 year old cob is advertised as suitable for a novice rider :banghead:

At this age they're still learning and a novice (even with correct tuition) would really struggle to bring on a baby horse correctly.

Maybe I'll get shot down for saying this but it's my opinion.

I've seen plenty of quiet 3/4 yr old cobs bought for children on our yard (and others) who are fine to begin with and then get to 5 or 6 and have a total tantrum as they've not been shown the rules or the basics properly and it suddenly all builds up and goes bang
Yeah - that too! :timebomb: Perhaps that's what I actually meant in the first place, Sparklie! :giggle:
 
I to look at this ad's and think "yeah right", and when looking to buy my minimum age was 10!
But there is a girl where i keep Ace, and when i was trying him out nearly 2years ago, i was there when they had this little mare there also to try out. This mare was unbroken 4 yr old ( I think, but dont quote me ) and i remember them trying to see how much they could do with her before they had to decide to keep or return. Well they kept her, and got this trainer in who teaches in some kind of natural horsemanship and all i can say it WOW! She is a super little pony and much was "bombproof" then my lad for sure.

I still wouldn't buy one though :mstickle:
 
I think you can fairly describe a horse's temperament from aged 3/4. Thyme is very calm/laid back. Her 'reaction' to being unsure is to startle, stop dead and raise her head. Charlie's was to shy or run. The number of things that bothered Charlie reduced as I widened his comfort zone, but his basic response did not change with age. I imagine Thyme will be the same - just a much less hot/sharp reaction to stuff.

I agree that novice riders should not be responsible for a young horse's education even if they are safe enough for them to ride.
 
newrider.com