Vices And Breeds

fairlady

New Member
Jul 14, 2007
10,260
1
0
Bristol
Just wondering if any of you have a horse with a vice (I know some of you have) such as weaving, cribbing, windsucking, and what breeds your horses are?

This is not about whether you would buy one or not, or to criticise in any way shape or form, I myself have owned a windsucker in the past. It is just purely a personal curiosity to see how many of us own horses with what is thought to be a 'vice' and if it relates more to a certain breed than others.

I personally have never ever come across a weaving/cribbing/windsucking Arab. Do they not exist?
 
I know one weaving Arab in particular, who has been a weaver pretty much all her life. I've also seen other Arabs showing tendencies in this direction.

I think it's much more to do with lifestyle and temperament than a particular breed.
 
You see a lot of TBs with the vices listed above. I don't think it has much to do with the breed, but the fact that quite a few of racehorses are kept inside for the majority of their lives, so these vices have a tendency to develop.

You tend to see weaving and cribbing in horses who are kept stalled for too long or have so much energy due to lack of stimulation - particularly the hotter breeds like TBs and Arabs
 
McGreevy (he's done extensive research on equine stereotypies) identified some Thoroughbred families that seemed more prone to developing steretypies than others so there does seem to be a (slight) heredetary component to this.
 
foals will copy their mums actions too

so how do you difine heredetary? if its passed on through genes or through copying mum?
 
foals will copy their mums actions too

so how do you define heredetary? if its passed on through genes or through copying mum?

Thoroughbred families that seemed more prone to developing steretypies than others so there does seem to be a (slight) heredetary component to this.

shall i answer my own question then?

you can't really, can you?

how come i'm such a smart arse at this one? i've seen it with my own eyes, with my own horses
 
Yes and no. Management practices are still key. Horses in similar environments may be more likely to develop into cribbers even when they are not related just based on what's amiss in regards to horsekepping practices (low forage, high grain, limited turnout, etc.). Certain individuals out of certain lines are just more prone to respond in that way.
 
so how do you difine heredetary? if its passed on through genes or through copying mum?

The 'horses don't develop stereotypies by copying/learning from others' has already been beaten to death so I am not going to waste your time on it again. ;)
In the studies they took surveys and traced the lines and then added up the occurences in different lines. Cribbing foten develops years later after they long left their dam, etc. It's not like: oh wait, I remember I saw my mom do that once back on soandso farm...
 
Last edited:
It's not like: oh wait, I remember I saw my mom do that once back on soandso farm...
is it not? i'm always amazed that we can be so certain (dare i say arrogant? yes i dare) in our arrogance, how equine brains work, thankyou for putting a simple soul like me on the right track ;)
 
i know and IDxconnie who cribs
2 TBs who weave

i guess that the more 'stressy' breeds are more prone but its management that causes it really.
 
i guess that the more 'stressy' breeds are more prone but its management that causes it really.


ummm i would have trouble accepting that 100% as the cause too

having had two foals off the same mare and sire who were kept in the same conditions how come both didn't develope her vice?

one was a colt and one a filly

just out of interest, for anyone reading this,

which sex do you think copied/inherited/was managed so that they developed (cross out according to preferrence) their mothers vice?

and which breed do you think it was?
 
My friend owns 3/4 thoroughbred, 1/4 moose (joke!:p) and he wind sucks, crib bites and weave's - but he's still a lovely boy.

:D :D :D
 
i would just like to add, unless there is a damned good reason (which very rarely happens) my hosses are given 24/7 turn out, lots of good quallity haylage (ad lib) and 24/7 company
2 high fibre feeds a day with vits and mins


if anyone would like to tell me what i did wrong (ie blame it on my management) please feel free to let me in on the secret
 
I sort of agree with what a lot of you have said. All the studies in the world make great reading but I agree with Teabiscuit, 'who really knows' other than the horses, and I truly believe that certain foals would copy their Mum, if she is of that nature, and some foals would not. This was not really to get into discussion about who or why as such I was just genuinely interested how many people have horses with a 'vice' and what breeds they were.

It sort of comes back to a conversation with a friend who does not really do 'thoroughbreds' and views them all as stressy windsucking/cribbers (oh blimey, did I really just type that:rolleyes:) and I admit that my mare was part TB and a chronic windsucker (HOWEVER, I still loved her at the time:rolleyes:)

I can relate to an Arab weaving, maybe and I mean maybe, due to management, or box walking,however I am still waiting to hear from anyone who has an Arab that cribs or windsucks. Is there anyone out there who knows of one? I have never, ever, come across it, but that does not mean to say it does not happen.

I always related my TB to a smoker:) Some people do and some people do not:) simple as that.
 
i think the numbers are also skewed by the fact that a lot of TBs are kept in a very unnatural way which would predispose any horse to vices - keep any breed like some TBs are kept and they'd crib, weave etc, but because the TBs are kept like that more often, that's what we see.

i do think horses vary a lot in how they react ot stress - some will pick up a habit at the drop of a hat, others can brush off all sorts of things. some copy, some don;t, some are affected more by a less natural lifestyle. we have some who copy every habit going - they fling buckets, bang doors, gurn for food, and others who look at the copycats in a faintly puzzled way and pick nothing up.

if a perfectly happy 'copycat' sees a stressed one across the yard and gives it a go and then gets hooked on the endorphins, that's just bad luck.
 
we must also remember that TB's are likely to be the most researched breed, because of their racing value and easy access to lots of horses kept in similar conditions
 
Rosie cribs - and she's half arab, does that count ? To the best of my knowledge she has never been kept in a stall, lives out 24/7, never rugged. She has a stall she can go in if she wants and she frequently does. She finds any piece of wood she can find - a tree, the fence - anything, to chew and hang off with her teeth. She hasn't started windsuckiing yet, and she's about the most laid-back calm, even lazy araby-pone I've ever met.
 
Someone once told me that dressage horses are more prone to vices as they are under more stress than others and if they are high level competition horses they are usually stabled and grain fed and the combination often means they cant cope so they develop vices.
 
newrider.com