Veterinary records

Cortrasna

Grumpy old nag
Aug 5, 2009
9,950
3,481
113
Ireland
Sorry me again - you can tell I am having a very slow few days on my website and the old brain cells are churning lol! Just seen very briefly a comment on another forum about a horse's vet records having to follow it around much as it's passport does.

Haven't read any deeper than that but I rather think if it could be enforced, and that is a huge 'if' it would be a very, very good idea. I can imagine many 5 stage vettings would arrive at a very different conclusion than the ones they might write up based on their examination alone if they had previous vet treatment to browse through?

But on the other hand how much heartache and and fraud would it take out of a lot of the horse buying minefield we all have faced at some point or other? Of course there will always be the real crafty crooks and fraudsters that will find a way around any safeguard......but I know of several cases where well respected and generally considered honest producers and dealers have held their breath while the vetting is carried out, based on what knowledge they have of the horse's prior health and fitness issues.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers
With the current lass I was told about her issues.
I knew about her health and I had contact with the vets that did the operation (theirs)
I also spoke to mine and the physio.

So as I only wanted to hack I was told that yes she probably would be ok for that- if she is sound when you get her going.

A vetting is only as good as the day it was done. It's also an opinion based on what that person says they want the horse for. So mine would have failed if someone wanted her for anything more than hacking and fun.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna
You were fortunate Newforest - and so was I with Dolly. Her seller very unusually over here, allowed me to bring her home on 2 weeks trial and get my own vet to vet her once I had assured myself she suited me. But no prior history was given as he had only had her in for 6 months over the winter as a hunter to get him through the hunting season while his own hunter was recuperating and he genuinely I later found out, had very little knowledge of her prior history.

My vet and I suspected sweet itch and it was not a deal breaker for me, she was such a superstar in every way for what I wanted, but this was February and it was some two months later when I realised just how bad the poor thing had it :( so for her, even a medical history pointing out the sweet itch wouldnt have been a surprise and wouldnt have stalled the sale......and 8 years on I am pretty certain there wasn't anything in her history that has caused issues while she has been with me.

but i can recall some horses I have bought over the years that had I known previous vet records I most definitely would NOT have bought.
 
  • Like
Reactions: newforest
Is this a new thing? I went with a friend to the vets about 3 months ago with a horse that had been investigated there with the previous owner, we were there for the same problem (navicular/ddft) and even with the prior owners permission to access the records we weren't allowed to see them just the vet to use them for comparison and tell us same or worse. They wouldn't even give us a run down of what was previously found. It would have been great to be able to get full access.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna
I dont think it is new Jessey or even in existence or used at all - just something that is being suggested elsewhere in the internet horse world. That seems very very odd that even with the past owners permission they would not reveal records to the present owner! :eek: I had thought as far as the point that owners would have to sign off any vet examination or treatment as happy to be disclosed at any given future date - never occurred to me the vet might object? Seems bizarre that they would take this stance - and one has to ask why?
 
It did seem very odd, I did wonder if covertly the previous owner only gave restricted permission for them to be reviewed but not passed on. The practice have never objected to giving me my xrays, nor the new ones for that horse. Perhaps it was different before they went digital and they never release actual films.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna
I don't think I actually had access to her records, but the vet that treated her was more than happy to chat to me about her.

The insurance company gets access to everything if you put in a claim. That makes sense.

I kinda hope that the horse mentioned above wasn't considered 'beyond hope' and that's why the vet won't disclose.
 
I have full vet records for Mylo from when he was 3 years old.
His previous owner asked her vet for a printout of every note on his file, which she forwarded on to me.
My vet has actually used the report recently to double check something in regard to his teeth, so it has proved useful.
I don’t see why any honest owner couldnt ask for the same from their own vet when selling on a horse?
 
I kinda hope that the horse mentioned above wasn't considered 'beyond hope' and that's why the vet won't disclose.
They injected his coffin joints with steroids and adequan with a guarded prognosis. He was sound for a bit then not, I've been working with him since and he's now 99%, just got to see if we can keep him there.

I don’t see why any honest owner couldnt ask for the same from their own vet when selling on a horse?
That's probably a good question to ask to weed out dodgy sellers.
 
I think it would be a good idea that their records were transferred. Would certainly prevent a lot of heartache and pulling the wool over a first time owners eyes. But then again, that's assuming the horse was treated or examined. Could be that previous owners knew something was wrong but chose to sell rather than treat / deal with.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna and MrC
I think it would be a good idea that their records were transferred. Would certainly prevent a lot of heartache and pulling the wool over a first time owners eyes. But then again, that's assuming the horse was treated or examined. Could be that previous owners knew something was wrong but chose to sell rather than treat / deal with.
I think it would be a real risk that people would be less inclined to get things checked out if it could put a 'black mark' against the horse when it was sold on which could be a negative effect.
 
I think it would mean a lot of horses without insurance.

A lady I know bought a horse that was described as lack of time forces sale. So they weren't fit as needed bringing back into work. Price reflected this though.
However on work they went lame and the vet knew they had issues!
They put down because the vet advised that the other owner do this and they just sold them.
Had they had access to vet records they wouldn't have bought and wouldn't have insured either.
Can't recall if insurance paid out or not because it had exclusions with the old owner!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna
I suppose a part of me would like to have seen all my horses medical records, purely out of curiosity as much as anything. It would make interesting (or not) reading.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna
Do exclusions disappear currently when you insure a horse you just brought? as in if you don't know about them or is there some way an insurance company can track previous exclusions like microchip numbers? Most of mine have been young/direct from the breeder so I have never even thought about it.
 
As far as I can see there are still holes in the Pet id and Passport systems, IMO until such a time as the Passport is seen as proof of Legal Ownership and not just a keeper record and the failure to have one fully enforced by all equine professions then the additional requirements for all equines to have microchip for me is not enforceable either, I think it would enhance animal welfare if it was , that the central database held records held all the history for that equine, including previous owner and medical History but I think we are a long way off any sort of ideal, I would imagine the cost of administrating this type of system would be a large stumbling block.
How many actually follow the current regulations in the passport accompanying the equine whilst travelling, we do and suspect many on here do, but how many have purchased an equine with a duplicate passport raised by PIO at a Sale, for that to happen they have to have travelled to that sale without, it cannot be sold without hence the issue of duplicate passport, the PIO should be able to access MC records by scanning and that should go on the duplicate passport, so for the vet records attached to work it would need to be attached to the MC record rather than the passport number itself, the MC record is the Individual Pet id number so in theory that would work, providing all equines have the Pet ID and that is enforced properly, again that would mean Vets/insurance companies would need to change systems to attach records to the Pet id on a central database, I suspect a few may balk at the cost of system development on that scale.

We bought Myst who the owner had purchased via a sale on a duplicate passport, all injection records where blank, the seller had her for 6 months and had not completed the change of ownership, not an issue as we were allowed to perform our change of ownership on the original sellers paperwork which had to be raised for the Duplicate passport to be issued. We have no history other than from the society knowing she has bred 2 foals. her MC had been scanned and entered on the duplicate passport this is were it does work. We know she has not had injections during the 6 months after her sale so we have started them off again. We were not told she was on a duplicate passport until we collected her however been wise on this we ensured we had a signed transfer form from previous owner and I recognised the breeder name on this and rang society and validated. It would be nice to think we have history but have to accept we do not, we would still have purchased so it was our risk to take.

A nice to have and would love to see- but suspect it would be open to abuse like most things.............. unfortunately we have members of society who will find a way round most things driven by greed mostly IMO,
 
Do exclusions disappear currently when you insure a horse you just brought? as in if you don't know about them or is there some way an insurance company can track previous exclusions like microchip numbers? Most of mine have been young/direct from the breeder so I have never even thought about it.

Exclusions can be lifted can't they after a certain time?

I think there are big holes in the leisure industry. I still have the passport in the previous owners name- just keep forgetting to do it!

For racing all their records are traceable and they have blood tests before each race. The vet makes good money out of this industry!

However I do think insurers scan social media and the Internet like employers do to see what's being said about a particular horse and to see what type of a person you are.
If you post things online about how much trouble you are having with the horse and the insurers find that discussion was a long time before you got the vet involved. They could argue you had a problem you ignored.
Some insurers won't touch you without a vet certificate- which as we have seen isn't always carried out properly, and its only subjective on that day.
 
Exclusions can be lifted can't they after a certain time?

I think there are big holes in the leisure industry. I still have the passport in the previous owners name- just keep forgetting to do it!

For racing all their records are traceable and they have blood tests before each race. The vet makes good money out of this industry!

However I do think insurers scan social media and the Internet like employers do to see what's being said about a particular horse and to see what type of a person you are.
If you post things online about how much trouble you are having with the horse and the insurers find that discussion was a long time before you got the vet involved. They could argue you had a problem you ignored.
Some insurers won't touch you without a vet certificate- which as we have seen isn't always carried out properly, and its only subjective on that day.
Some exclusions can be but some can't, like ppid, so if I brought a horse with no symptoms can the insurance check a special insurers database to see if the horse ever had exclusions before? I would guess not, unless you were unlucky enough that the same company insured both times.
 
Some exclusions can be but some can't, like ppid, so if I brought a horse with no symptoms can the insurance check a special insurers database to see if the horse ever had exclusions before? I would guess not, unless you were unlucky enough that the same company insured both times.
Or is it customer confidential thingy. I would cancel the insurance once sold.

Dunno I wouldn't want to lie because I would want the new owner to be happy and keep the horse. So I would be giving them the good, the bad and downright ugly. The ugly being in season she might bite you. Because I couldn't do that Gosh she's never done that before crap.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
newrider.com