Trainer Riding Thyme

Thyme & Me

New Member
Nov 23, 2011
1,403
0
0
Well after the advice to get other people riding Thyme, in preparation for viewings, I took her to an Equestrian Centre yesterday for training/schooling livery. And today I had a lesson/demo by one of their trainers.

It was really interesting. Thyme turned 4 in June. She was backed in Feb. I thought I had done a reasonable amount with her: walk/trot/canter/jump/hacking alone and in company. But I had been fairly relaxed about working into a contact, not expecting instant responses, letting her mooch about sometimes! The focus was on stress-free learning and figuring out how to balance with a rider on board.

The trainer rode her sympathetically, but was working her really forward. He said she needed much sharper responses. She scratched her nose on her leg at one point - he said that was unacceptable: when she is working she is working! She was also totally knackered after 20 minutes! :sleep: (I school and have lessons for up to 45 and she is fine, so I think I have been very easy on her.)

So Thyme is in boot-camp :wink:. She did not seem to object to being ridden with more focus and energy. There was nothing I saw that worried me. But it has made me wonder what I will do when she comes home. Chill again, or keep the momentum going. If the latter, I need a few lessons with this trainer, I think. My own RI (an EE instructor) is fine about me riding the chilled way we have been saying 'she's young, she needs to learn balance, she's just being a wobbly baby' etc. Today's trainer's view is she is not that young! She is ready to work. I don't need to make excuses for her.

Incidentally she didn't bat an eyelid about being ridden by someone else so that's one worry gone.

Thoughts?

Here she is WORKING!


DSC02499 by Team KP Nut, on Flickr


DSC02497 by Team KP Nut, on Flickr


DSC02504 by Team KP Nut, on Flickr
 
glad she was good for the other rider. I think you need to keep the momentum when she returns to you if you are adamant on selling. (However, i still really think you should keep her but i know its nowt to do with me!)
 
I think you've done a good job with her so far, she seems to be very relaxed and willing and takes everything in her stride. The fact that she has been ridden by a new rider in a strange place and accepted it so well suggests that she is a very easygoing little horse, and much of that will be down to your steady and sensitive approach to her early education.

However, if she was backed in February, that means she's been in ridden work for (more or less) half a year. This to me is a time I would be aiming for a little more "technical" progress. She's working quietly, you've established the basics well and she clearly has a super attitude to her "job" and to learning new things. Mentally and physically I should think she's ready to take on a bit more.

Asking for more forwardness should actually help improve her balance. I think with youngsters sometimes we worry so much about not being "too harsh" that we go completely the other way and end up being considerably more soft than we need to. Allowing her to mooch along might feel beneficial for her balance because she's taking it easy, but in reality a youngster's balance is more likely to improve if they're working with a lot more forward energy.

As for what to do when you get her home, I would suggest carrying on where the trainer left off. I don't see a reason not to. You're selling a horse, and you've sent her off for schooling, presumably to increase her sales value, so I don't see why you would then take her home and not reinforce what she's just been learning.
 
I think she's ready to do a little more.

She needs to learn to balance and build the correct muscles and this can only be achieved by working correctly. I'm not one for pushing babies. I don't like people forcing them into an outline or rushing them through their growing up but she looks lovely and content in those photos and that she's taking things on board well :smile:

I'd think that schooling continuing on from where the trailer has started along with hacking to let her get out and about would be a good way to go forward.

She's a lovely horse and sounds like she's got a good work ethic too
 
Perhaps it is time to start riding her a little more forwards and start asking for a little more but I think the trainer in those pictures is overbending her. In my opinion at her age (she is still young for a big horse) she should still be working with he nose in front of the verticle. You need to start the focus on her bringing herself through from behind, at 4 she won't have the strength to do that well AND bring her nose in.

It is hard to tell from stills but in the last two she looks overbent and on her forehand, to my eye anyway.

Every time I see Thyme I just think about how much she'd suit my OH! I'd don't suppose you'd consider a loan home swap with a 22 year old retired, lame chestnut monster who just wants to eat grass all day? :wink: :tongue:
 
To go back to the previous thread - where I said it might be hard to reconcile everything taught by Mary Wanless with things taught by Mark Rashid. It sounds as if you are in the same situation here.

Adults need to understand that there are different opinions on almost everything ijn riding. Including how to train youngsters. With pros and cons on both sides.

Our RI at our yard does it very slowly, in the classical tradition - much as Werehorse describes. And much as you may have done till now. Gradually building up the movement from the back.

This other trainer is of a different school of thought.
Please take some time to sort out your own opinion and dont simply take as gospel the view of the last trainer you heard.
You need to sort out the type of training you agree with and to be able to give reasons for your choice Take your own decisions, factoring in the needs of this particular horse, and then find a trainer who does things the way you prefer. You cant please everyone.

Give yourself credit for having prepared your horse for a multitude of new experiences and for not having rushed her physical education.
 
I think the trainer in those pictures is overbending her.

It is hard to tell from stills but in the last two she looks overbent and on her forehand, to my eye anyway.

Agreed, she is a bit overbent and tucking her nose in, and overbending and going on the forehand tend to come together. But seeing the photos out of context and not watching the whole session or a video clip, it's impossible to know whether the trainer's riding is causing it or if the horse is doing it unprompted. A lot of youngsters overbend themselves when asked for more forwardness or to work into a contact - can be due to a lack of balance, stiffness / using new muscles, insecurity, not understanding the rider's aids, etc. Sometimes even when you present them with a soft contact and encourage them to relax and stretch into it, they overbend instinctively because they don't understand what's being asked, and/or because they find it easier, physically - having unestablished muscles makes it very difficult for them to carry themselves properly, and dipping behind the vertical is one way of avoiding doing so. So while it does look like the trainer was trying to force her head down, I don't think you can tell for sure from a few photos.

I'm not surprised she's on the forehand at the moment - she's bound to be, at this stage of her schooling, as she has neither the education nor the muscle development to get her hindquarters properly underneath her and lighten the front end. Even the best trainer can't change that in 1 session - it's the sort of thing that you start to see as their schooling progresses and they become physically stronger and more capable of working properly.
 
Last edited:
I am glad someone else has ridden her and put your fears at bay:smile: I more or less agree with what everyone else has said.

If you are still selling and don't want to spend on further schooling I would advertise her as backed, three nice paces etc ready to bring on.

You have done an excellent job on her, she will be ideal for someone who wants a youngster to bring on and compete. Well done you.:smile:
 
She is a lovely compliant little horse and her attitude will stand her in very good stead for whoever buys her.

I am sure she will find a good and loving home.
 
Oh she really does look lovely. I agree with Joosie that young horse over bend themselves as they are not sure what you are asking all the time.

Albi accepts the bit and the contact and it would be very easy for me to ride him round looking very pretty but he is not working over his back and is on the fore. My RI and I are working on forward and straightness then and only then when he is working off my leg when I ask will I start to re enforce the contact but for now if his head comes up I not worried if he over bends I give away the contact and send him forward.

This to me is what your trainer was doing. You have started Thyme so well and this is what will make her a wonderful horse if you where coming her how you bring her on from here is up to you but as you are having to sell her then getting her more established now will gain you pounds on her selling price.
 
I agree that you can't actually tell much from photos but what was described sounded like the trainer was pushing the horse quite hard and I'm not sure that that is a good thing to do with a young horse. I would expect a young horse trying to find its balance to momentarily overbend and come in and out of a more correct outline and I would also expect them to be on the forehand and perhaps that is all that has been captured in the pictures.

All I am saying is that *if* the trainer is driving her forwards into a firm contact and actually *asking* for the head carriage we see in the photos then that is not something I would be happy with. But plenty of people would disagree I'm sure.

I perhaps worded my first reply a little clumsily as well.
 
Thanks for all the replies. Sorry for not responding to all the excellent advice - been offline for a while.

I think with youngsters sometimes we worry so much about not being "too harsh" that we go completely the other way and end up being considerably more soft than we need to.....

Agree with this. At the Mark Rashid clinic there was a recently backed horse being ridden. There were a few questions about how much 'babies' should do. He said that once his horses had been started then they went to work and he expected them to cope. Harshness is more about how you ask than what you ask for....

P
Every time I see Thyme I just think about how much she'd suit my OH! I'd don't suppose you'd consider a loan home swap with a 22 year old retired, lame chestnut monster who just wants to eat grass all day? :wink: :tongue:

'fraid not!

I am sure she will find a good and loving home.

Really hope so. She certainly deserves one

You have started Thyme so well and this is what will make her a wonderful horse if you where keeping her how you bring her on from here is up to you but as you are having to sell her then getting her more established now will gain you pounds on her selling price.

I don't care about the price but I am keen to maximise her desirability. If that means working a bit more 'correctly' then so be it. I'd love to carry on with her myself but I have made my decision - everyone around me (OH & kids and even in-laws) are so pleased that I 'will be around more' that I'm not going back. I'll have a horse again one day. But not right now. Sadly have had little interest in her, so I might have a few months yet.... I'm enjoying it while it lasts!
 
I don't care about the price but I am keen to maximise her desirability. If that means working a bit more 'correctly' then so be it.

Hi Thyme and Me - I'm a bit slow on the case here, so maybe this has been resolved, but in case you haven't sold her yet and are still considering desirability, I'd offer this:

http://www.sustainabledressage.net/rollkur/behind_the_vertical.php

It's rather technical, but it explains very well why putting the horse behind the vertical is not a good idea.

There's a massive battle going on at the moment regarding what is desirable and what isn't. I think it's epitomised in the dressage Olympics - gold went to the more classically trained, classically ridden, ride on the snaffle, nose in front of the vertical and think about pelvic tuck school, silver went to the "modern" nose behind the vertical, crank up the curb, flick the front legs up and forget the fact that the hindquarters are trailing school.

Which is more desirable? If you are looking for a good home over price, then put the emphasis on behaviour and being a calm and cooperative ride. If you are looking for maximum return to investment, you can go down the silver medal track - but it's a gamble. The classical school is starting to win. Even for competition purposes, I think horses that have been brought on slowly and are not going behind the vertical are going to be desirable now or in the near future.

It's a bitch to retrain going behind the vertical - and once horses have learned to do it, it can be almost impossible to get them going properly "back to front" again. You can get them in front of the vertical - but getting proper engagement over the back is tricky.

If you're looking for desirability, I'd go for training that is focussed on manners and ridability - ie stop, go, turns, quiet riding out - all the things you were instinctively doing anyway. The new owner can decide which direction they want to take on competition training.
 
Well Thyme is home.
Thanks for the comments, Kate & everyone. By 'correctly' I didn't mean being pulled into a false outline. I meant forward, straight and responsive. Not the 'wobbly baby' my RI was happy with but a well schooled horse with good basics. I really hate pulling horses into a frame. The trainer wasn't doing that at all. He was riding with a light contact and Thyme was tucking her nose behind to balance/evade. When she does that I have been told to just ride her forward.

Thanks for all the lovely comments about her great attitude being due to good early years training! I'd love to take credit. But honestly, it's just her! She's as laid back and willing a horse as I've ever known! Not a bad one to pick for my first attempt at backing!

She had a nice time at the trainers I think: Here she is looking chilled in her new surroundings!!


DSC02661 by Team KP Nut, on Flickr

So where are we? Well 8 weeks after putting her up for sale I have had ZERO viewings!! Price isn't the issue - she has been advertised at everything from 3-4.5k She is most definitely worth more than 3k according to everyone I have asked (3 RIs, an equine agent and the trainer) so I have given up on selling this year. Anyway, I like her and I can tell my OH I TRIED. And I really really did. Long-term she needs to go, because all the issues in my OP are still true. The children have lost all interest in ponies. OH never had any and it is just too selfish for me to have such an expensive & time consuming hobby with such a huge impact on everyone.....

But for now we are having fun :skip:

She was on livery for 4 weeks and had 3 weeks being ridden 30 minutes a time, 5 days a week. Here are clips from her final session:

Halt - Walk To Trot:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vu0LASmELUk&feature=plcp

Trot - canter right rein:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Xs8_KA_dnU&feature=plcp

Canter Left Rein:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J-xgBff6Ywc&feature=plcp

Then I had a lesson. It was strange because in some ways our connection had gone. The ability for me to think trot and her to respond. She's more 'push button' now. But then horses need to have those buttons! I plan to go back to riding by feel/energy, at least sometimes though. While making sure she remembers where her buttons are too!

Today we jumped and she jumped HUUUUGE. Over a 45cm fence! OMG. I like jumping but that was scary. WAY WAY too big a jump for my nerves to cope with. So not sure what I am going to do about that. A jumping lesson I guess. She was calm going in to the fence, and pulled up easily afterwards. Ears pricked. Keen and enthusiastic. So there is no problem apart from my abject cowardice. Anyone want to come and jump a horse......

Talking of jumping: anyone who remembers the lovely Charlie may be interested that he has qualified for the Royal London and is now jumping 105cm tracks. Was reserve champion his last show. Clever boy. Wasted on me. As is Thyme, it seems. I must stop buying jump-monsters :tongue:
 
Last edited:
newrider.com