Time to admit defeat

Sandi_Mac

I love western riding!
Feb 3, 2005
85
0
0
Kent
Visit site
am so sad tonight as I finally have to admit defeat an sell my beloved Cedar an look out for a plod instead!
To fill you in briefly have ongoing back problem, have owned Cedar, a 9 yr old, idx for 2 years she was very green when she came to me and despite my back has come on along way, I have worked extremely hard on her in this time both on the ground an ridden, but sunday shook me up an I count myself very lucky to still be here went out for a hack with hubby on his horse in the morn, had lovely walk an trot out on our local bridle path, got to where we usually turn back for home an thought we would have a nice canter back up the hill.
All fine until we reach the top, small bush to our left hand side which I had spotted further back, an was plannin on takin her around it! She at the same time spotted it an spooked :eek: an shot off the opposite direction managed to stay with her until damn lost my stirrup, wasn't to worried as just stretched leg down further, as we were coming back to canter, then don't ask me what happened I lost the other stirrup :eek: an don't remember much after that apart from heading off down her shoulder, got her knee in my eye an her hind footprint on my elbow! Ended up with air ambulance as was out in middle of nowhere an although ambulance got out to me, the ride out would have been horrendous for me. Don't really remember an awful lot of events after that, was very lucky indeed not to sustain worse injuries, an because of my existing back condition OH said there was alot of worry i may have done some more damage to it.
Came away with stitches above my eye, bruised an battered all over an feel like crap lol!
It has really knocked my confidence though an I know I will neva be able to rider her again, not her fault at all she was only doing what horses do with in there eyes scary things they run!.I love her so much an it will break my heart to have to part with her, but it is time for me to admit defeat I have taken her as far as I can with my back problems, but can't trust her anymore, not to do the same again at some point an dump me.
Sorry for my rambling but just wanted to share with you all, I feel so down at the moment.

DSC00066.jpg

09-09-07_1133.jpg

DSC00070.jpg
 
OMG Sandi. That was a very close call but very glad to hear that you are ok.

As for defeat !!!!! You have certainly not been defeated. You have given your hoss a good 2 yrs of love and care. I am sure she has come a very long way with your help. Find her a good home and you will have finished your job. ;)
 
:eek: Blood, *faints* (this coming from someone who wants to be a nurse!)

Glad you have come to the decision though, it took me a little longer than you...


severly twisted tendon in my ankle, bone chipped off in my wrist, several bruises,extremely damaged confidence and many months of tears later and I have finally come to the decision to sell my boy on.

gentle (((Hugs))) coming your way.
 
Last edited:
I don't think there is any defeat in deciding that your partnership with your horse isn't right for you both.

Let me put it this way, if I got you to marry a man off the street and told you to make it work, try as you might if it isn't going to work then it isn't going to work. There is no shame in that.

Horses for us isn't just a hobby they are a way of life so you need to make sure that you have the right one for you :)

Best wishes for a speedy recovery xx
 
I am sorry to hear about your accident.I do kind of understand what you are saying as having had a previous spinal injury myself I know how worrying it is that you can do more damage by falling off again.I hope you are feeling a little better by now but I do know what you are saying about making the decision to sell on your horse for something less spooky and more sensible that you can feel you have more trust in.I wish you good luck with your search for a new horse and as I am in the same county as you will keep my eyes peeled for anything that may be suitable.What do you intend to do with Cedar? Are you looking to sell her on or loan her out? at least by loaning you could keep an eye on her progress with new people and have some say in how they care for her but I do also understand that if you want another horse you have to sell in order to have the funds.
 
OMG what gruesome photos - so relieved you didn't sustain worse injuries.

Echo what the others have said - there is no shame or defeat in this at all, it is definitely a sound decision under the circumstances.

Take care of yourself ((((hugs)))) from Slovenia
 
OUCH so sorry to hear about you accident, you have made the right choice you gave her the best possiable time and love and there is not point in keeping horse that you cant enjoy after all that is one of th reasons we have horses, hope you are feeling better soon
 
What a horrific fall! Make sure that you take time recover and don't try and do anything too soon. I understand that you will be sad to part with your horse, but if the trust has gone you have made the right decision.
 
Flippin eck looks pretty nasty, I think you've made the right decision for both of you to get rid of cedar, it's not surprising you've lost confidence in her, if you did perservere you probably end up knocking your confidence worse and maybe hers too, hope your search for another friend for you and Cedar works out successful, gentle hug
 
Can someone remind me- WHY do we do this again?!??!;):eek:

Seriously though Sandi Mac, all the best and get well soon.

And three cheers for the Air Ambulance! Hip hip etc!!!
 
SandiMac, what a nightmare! :eek: Glad you're OK, I'll keep my eyes out for a plod too - You're not far from me, I'll keep my eye out in tack shops etc and give you a shout if I see anything remotely ploddy ;) Though I suspect, right now, that a new one is the least of your worries, as you need to decide what to do with Cedar first... good luck with it all, let us know how you get on.

PS NUTKIN!!! Hello stranger! How are you??
 
I am sorry you got hurt and it must have been very frightening at the time.

BUT it was an accident, the mare didn't deliberately try to hurt you. I fell off Rosie on the downs in October, very similar to you, i let her have a gallop and didn't have her on a short enough rein and she propped and kangarooed when she pulled up and i came off and bust my ribs.

Now I could also have been kicked by her etc as you were but i wasn't and Rosie is a bombproof totally unspooky horse, yet she hurt me very much at the time. Like you i was in the middle of nowhere and ambulances were called etc but in the end i had to walk out and home with Rosie and walked 4-5 miles to get her home, settled,then off to a&e.

So while it was a horrible accident, it wasn't the horse's fault - there is no horse incapable of spooking, even my saintly Rosie.

I hope you feel better soon, and with your existing injury, yes maybe it may be better to get a safer conveyance, but the 100% no accident horse doesn't exist, accidents can happen with any horse.

If you have had a huge history of her being worrying, then I apologise for butting in, all i am saying is rather than rush rush rush into an instant decision, give yourself some time. I have parted with unsuitable horses myself so I know how you feel but just give yourself a bit of time to get more perspective on it. Landing badly can happen to anyone at any time on any horse.
 
That doesn't sound like 'Admitting Defeat' at ALL ! Sounds to me like a rational, well-reasoned decision bearing in mind the pros- and cons.

No, no horse is ever 100%, apart from a wooden rocking horse .. but some are considerably less fall-offable than others. Out of my four, there is one who is perfect (IMO), and not very fall offable. One who is a real stroppy old bag - and still not fall-offable (she'll tell you when she's not happy) ... and then two more mares who no matter how well-trained and used to it all they're going to get, they'll always be the type to put in big-assed spooks when you least expect it. And they're always going to be fall-offable. You know yourself if your mare is like that - and she sounds like she is. It depends on the horse, and what their role is in the herd ... but my perfect boy, in that situation, would go head-high, bug-eyed, plant his feet and snort and wait for his instructions. My Stroppy Mare would look, slow down, calmly turn round and get very beligerent about it - but slowly.

And my two other mares would likely bronk and I'd be on the floor. In fact one of them bronks so hard, she darn near broke my foot even without me falling off.

It sounds to me like you're always going to be left with an element of doubt with this mare, and with a pre-existing injury that's only going to get aggravated - well, I don't think I'd be enjoying taking that risk either.

BUT - just to be contentious - remember you are warned not to take ANY decisions, while you are still on pain-meds. You're considered by law to be not of sound mind for 24 hours after the accident, and for me, I know I'm still affectd for a week or so. No Rush.
 
Oh ber-limey! I really, really REALLY feel for you...
That was me a year ago, (minus helicopter, but all the rest), and it doesn't half shake you up!

The bestest of good vibes to you, and my advice is, take as much time as you need to recover; don't try to be 'normal' just to please others ;)

LD xxx
 
newrider.com