This is interesting - backing a mare

I couldn't watch it all...a) it costs me too much via Vodafone Hungary to watch it ...and b) I had seen enough! :(

OK, so some person put a vid of themselves on youtube 'breaking in a pony'.... As others have said, I too have never 'felt the need' to video myself doing this for others to see, nor would have had the time or 'concentration' for it! Backing and breaking takes too much concentration to worry about being filmed in my opinion!

Poor little pony! She was so scared when the 'rider' launched herself rather unathletically onto the saddle. How NOT to let a horse experience a person's weight on their back for the first time! The backing process should be a 'pleasant' and gradual experience, so the horse learns from repetition and reward, so it doesn't ever get into the 'panic, rear, be scared' situation! I backed (as far as I can recall doing a quick count up) 40 + horses last year, to different levels, some just needed a 'test pilot' others I started from scratch and saw through their schooling. It takes TIME...! This poor pony seemed so rushed - she just couldn't take it all in. I hope she isn't going to be scared for too long! :rolleyes:

As for 'join up'..... What was going on there? :confused:

And well done summercandy! Nice pony! Well done! :)
 
You know what the worst thing was? That ridiculous, hypocritical quote thing she put up;
"Rosie is a nervous pony so this is quite scary for her"

Um, yeah. It IS quite scary for her. COS YOU KEEP FLINGING YOURSELF AT HER YOU IDIOT! I don't think the poor pony had a clue what the rider was trying to do :(
Disapprove completely.

Also, one of the comments asked her why she hadn't used a mounting block and the nutter went 'it would of been dangerous'. WHY? What kind of mounting block does she usually use? Has she got some kind of exploding spikey metal one? Even if she didn't want to use a mounting block, she could have had someone to give her a very slow and gentle leg-up. Ridiculous.
 
Ok I have only been doing serious horse stuff since March and even I know that's just stupid.

For one thing I have been taught you NEVER let a horse run off with stirrups run down in case it trips or the stirrups get caught in something...surely this is basic knowledge?! 'Join up' was not join up it was lets chase this poor thing around til it is too tired to fight when we try the next mean thing. The leaning was not leaning at all, it was jumping on, surely this is meant to be done gradually not suddenly?! Like you stand on a mounting block or even something like a set of little steps (I use these as someone ran over our wooden mounting block) and lean slowly, then if pony is happy your handy helper leads you around? And to do the whole thing in 45 minutes...I am sure it takes at least a few sessions to do this, and aren't you meant to reward the pony then leave it be when it overcomes a milestone? Like I say I am new to all this compared to many people, but I do think I am more right that these load of clowns.

I also like the 'please only leave nice comments' thing she wrote. For goodness sake, talk about on an ego trip and refusing to take advice.

Note to self - don't let other people who like to play with video cameras break any ponies I may buy!
 
'Join up' wasn't join up. That vaulting on thing was silly, I wouldn't use a mounting block for getting on a horse that isn't likely to be too impressed with it either, I like a nice flat area with nothing that'd hurt to land on, but the person holding the horse could have legged up as well or the person filming could have done something more useful. She's hanging off the side instead of bellying over properly and pulling the saddle over with her weight which isn't going to help. Hopefully they were reasonably sure there wasn't anything for the stirrups to catch on before turning her loose with them down, maybe lunging would be better but you do need to do something to let the horse feel the stirrups before getting on the first time. Wrapping rope around the nose not the ideal way to do it.

But, the pony did end up ridden around the school quite calmly in the end and from the follow up video seems to be doing well so its not all bad :)
 
From my point of view the area was far too large, the pony was not paying attention to the 'trainer' as there were too many other distractions. Would gave been better in half an indoor school. It wasn't join-up, it was chasing a pony around, there was no consistency of pressure because the pony could get out of the pressure zone, hence the stopping to look over the fence. Mostly, round-pen work is recommended to be done in a pen which the horse cannot see out of, so he gives full attention to the trainer.

I agree the pony was terrified, it was known she was nervous, so it should have been done over days, if not weeks. Just because Monty Roberts can do it in 45 minutes, doesn't mean anyone can. They should have taken longer to introduce her to tack (Noticed that aspect wasn't shown on the video), she probably freaked. The saddle appeared to me to be too far forward, and the girth appeared to be catching the back of the pony's legs.

As for the leaning and mounting, she should have had a mounting block or at least something to stand on so as not to put pressure or twist forces on the saddle. I would have been nervous about someone jumping up and down next to me! The winding of the lead rope around her muzzle was just abuse, IMO.

Overall, I feel it will be fortunate if they haven't ruined that pony.

Cheers, Midori
 
Terrible :eek:

Also, in the video comments someone says she should have had a leg up and she makes out 'i could have done with an extra hand'.
The goon with the camera could have been a useful contribution.



pffffff
 
Well, I didn't watch the video, but then I very rarely watch anything on Youtube anyway, so I can only go on what the rest of you say, and I'm sure you are all quite correct in your comments.

So, I'm not registered to post comments onto Youtube, but if I were, I would say something like,

'I wouldn't let you on a wooden rocking horse of mine, let alone a real one'.

So if any of you are stuck for a comment, feel free to use that one.


I wonder why these people ever think they are good enough to post videos of themselves. Sad, deluded people.
 
Thank goodness, way too many people on the youtube comments seemed to think it was a great video, I was worried people all over the country were using this as a guide to horse breaking!

I wonder if she had loads of youtube accounts and put all the good comments on herself....?! Sorry that might sound a bit catty!
 
newrider.com