This is interesting - backing a mare

Elcon_Poet

New Member
Jul 4, 2008
243
0
0
I'm having a youtube evening haha. Anyway I would really like to know your opinions on this video of this girl backing a mare, the comments on youtube are mixed, but to me she is going completely the wrong way about it even if she did 'break' it in at the end, but then again I am a very soft person when it comes to horses and ponies. Its a longish vid but I'd love to know your opinions many of you being experienced horsey people.

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=UaJQaeB1hmI
 
In particular pay attention to the bit where the mare has her tack on and the girl is attempting to put weight on her.
 
Wrapping rope around her nose was cutting off her breathing and scaring her.

Dont see the point of all the chasing away when you are trying to teach her new things. This was not join up at all it was just chaseing, teaching her that saddles and stirrups will get you chased.

NEVER hold on to the back of the saddle on the most sensitive part of the back, the pressure hurts the horse.

Use a mounting block and slide on quietly and gently. Then sit there and do nothing till they are happy.

Both handler and rider, were showing off for the camera and more the horse performed the more they laughed.

Where was the quiet reassurances!!!!!!

Disgusting only watched to the end to make valid comments, wouldnt otherwise, poor poor scared horse. It will probably never forget this.
 
having watched that vid I was sat shocked and really feeling sorry for the poor pony.In the comments it said that she took 45 minutes from start to finish.You could see the confusion on the ponys face and as for join up...alot of what the girl did was ok but there was also times where she put far too much pressure on the pony and it was more chasing her round the school than join up. I know they said that the pony had been ridden before and been turned away for a few years and was nervous of people but to me it seemed that the people who were dealing with the horse didn't have much understanding of what they were doing and I wouldn't be at all surprised to hear that since they made the video things went wrong and the pony labelled as difficult. They basically rushed what they did with her and left her confused and beaten into submission rather than spending time working on her trust and allowing her time for things to sink in first.
 
That is exactly what I thought. All those people on youtube were praising her and I thought "why?" I backed my welsh section A and I can tell yah I didnt go about it in that way. My boy didnt rear at all when I did sit on him for the first time, he just stood there and was led forward happily which goes to show if you go about it with love and kindness it makes it a lot easier.
 
Didn't like the vid.

Wasn't 'join up'.

Mare looked genuinely scared.

Always get a leg up when backing, not this fast and furious vaulting. Suprised she didn't end up on the floor!
 
Well i just felt so angry then when i watched that video! The poor girlie looks confused and petrified, surely if there was a lot of groundwork leading up to the big day then i think she would have been a lot more confident and would be backed easily. Even when she succumbed to it she still had her tail tucked into her bum so she wasn't relaxed about it at all. I agree, it will take her a long time to get over it. i know every horse is different but it just looked so wrong to me. Oh and the rope around the nose?? Say no more but GRRRRRRR!!!
 
this is a pic of the first time the youngster I backed was sat on by his owner.This was done after several weeks of leaning over him from the mounting block and patting his sides where your legs would be,wriggling around and ensuring that he associated a rider with nice things.(food in this case)I know its not ideal as it is on a concrete yard rather than a school but as you can see he was more than ready to accept a rider.It took about 8 weeks to get to this stage,not 45 minutes.
winfirstbacking.jpg
 
poor poor pony :(
i used to work at a yard breaking horses in and that poor little horse was so not ready to be backed she looked scared 99% pf the time :mad:
 
from my experience, genuine "nice" horse people dont post videos on youtube of themselves backing a horse- they dont need pats on the back to know they are doing something right.

a huge pinch of salt is needed on youtube (and the internet :p) usually the quiet modest people who you dont hear much about are the best, they are there to do something for the horse not their ego.
 
summercandy well done, perfect way to do it, take your time. If a horse wont even come to you in the field, what does that say about his state of mind with regards to people, already scared before you even start the chasing.

although we are all complaining about it, it is a sharp reminder of what not to do and probably benefited some people who may think this is the usual way. Glad summercandy showed a better way.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
that poor pony!! no wonder so was being so difficult! the join up at the start wasn't join up at all!! if it was the pony would be cantering instead of trotting around the arena. if that worked the pony would've let them put the tack on and let her mount and walk around if she was nevrous or not. my mate breaks in horses and she uses join up to break then in and she can do join up, then put the tack on, lunge them with the tack on and finally mount them. i helped her last year break a pony in (she usually does 15hh +).

that pony was clearly scared of them and it was forced to do something it didn't want to do, so she is an unwilling servant rather than a partner.

if she didn't use join up however she would lunge her untill she was settled around her, then put tack on her, lunge untill she was settled with the tack on, then start to ride her. also i think its harder to break them when they are older.
 
Last edited:
I couldn't watch all of that :mad: I was really beginning to hope that pony would kick the pair of them in the teeth and then go stomp on the camera man for good measure - and I'm not a violent person by nature.

That wasn't join up, the fit of the tack was dubious and don't get me started on the technique for 'laying across' - I couldn't watch any more, poor, poor pony :eek:
 
Rather then the girl jumping from a standstill she, should of used the mounting block if i was being, back and someone banged, onto me back while getting, on i would have done that! It should not be about showing ,off and even putting it on youtube it should be about, getting a horse backed the right way and taking, your time with it not just 5 seconds of doing join up and showing off!:mad:
 
poor poor pony :( it was the vaulting that got me? why on earth would you throw yourself on to a nervy pony gripping the back of the saddle hanging off the side?:confused: just about everything was wrong with that video!
As Kturner said, they were both showing off for the camera, and i think they were deliberately trying to provoke a reaction from the poor mare.
 
newrider.com