This HAS to be dangerous!

Elvengirl

Know jumps, know glory!
May 17, 2004
452
0
0
44
Alberta, Canada
www.picturetrail.com
I had a disturbing encounter with a girl at my barn the other day and it is bugging me to no end, so I thought I'd ask what everyone else thinks.

I walked into one of our barns the other day to find a girl sitting on her 3 year old horse for the first time. She had a helmet on but he was tied in his 10 foot by 10 foot stall with the door closed. She was also completely alone as I was the only other person around and wasn't even going to go into the barn but saw that the light was on. She was very surprised to see me and told me not to tell anyone that she was backing her horse in his stall. She said it was safer for him in the stall because it was a safe place for him (even though he doesn't have a stall, he lives outside and she was borrowing someone else's) and that he might bolt if she backed him in the arena.

Now I know nothing about bringing on a young horse, but the images in my head of what that horse could do to her in that stall as opposed to in our HUGE arena with people in it seemed far worse and it made me shiver!

Is this dangerous and stupid? She argued with me about it forever and got really mean and I feel like I'm the silly one because I do know nothing about starting horses. Is this one way to get on a horse for the first time? What do you guys think? Should I say anything to anyone about this or just let her do what she wants? Has anyone ever done this before?
 
If the horse reared, he could slam her into the ceiling. If he bucked and panicked, she might end up under his feet. A horse in a new experience should have room to feel comfortable; a horse who feels enclosed is much more likely to panic.

I can't imagine backing a horse when he's tied, much less in a stall.
 
What a tard..:D

That was a stupid thing to do. If the horse did freak out, how would she have gotten out? That was a disaster waiting to happen. I'd tell someone.
 
At least she had a helmet on, although I fear that would offer little protection if the horse went beserk. Silly girl - can you leave a book or something near her stuff to kind of hint that this is not the right way to go about things? Or tell the YO?
 
Oh my God, that girl clearly has no sense to even be trying to back a pony!

if you confine a youngster they are more likely to panic and bolt,rear,buck etc.

I have only sat on one horse in the stable and that was with extremely high ceilings and with a number of people there in case something bad happened it was also my instructors choie to do it.

If it were me I would have to mention she'd been using someone elses stall to back it so that they know where to look when she tries again and possibly injures herself
 
that is crazy and very dangerous i think! i am not a fan of horses in little enclosed spaces anyway, and don't lock myself into stables with horses if i can possibly avoid it because there is nowhere for you to go if the horse freaks or anything.

julia
x
 
I guess she probably thought that it was a good idea, because her horse wouldn't be able to run away.........as everyone else has pointed out though it was in fact one of the dumbest ideas ever :rolleyes:

BUT hindsight is a wonderful thing isn't it!

I did actually back (as in get on her for first time) Safi on my own, but I had been doing the preparation work for weeks (well about a year & half really if you think about it) , so as I was leaning over her from above giving her a brush I swung my leg over and got on with no drama or fuss (and yes she was tied up outside our stable block at the time) it wasn't planned, just felt right at the time. After ten seconds or so I just stepped back off onto my crate and carried on brushing - done.
 
Originally posted by Elvengirl
.....She was very surprised to see me and told me not to tell anyone that she was backing her horse in his stall.

doesn't this say it all ? If she really thought it was the "right" thing to do she wouldn't worry about anyone else being aware.


Should I say anything to anyone about this or just let her do what she wants?

Ok - what if it all goes horribly wrong and you haven't said anything ? How would you feel about it ?

Is there anyone you can have a "quiet word" with - who could then "happen by" when this girl is by herself again ?
 
Thanks for all the replies, and it seems I was right in thinking this was completely mental. Unfortunatly I fell victim to the "you're a novice and know nothing" mentality, so I was feeling insecure about telling someone. I will definatly be letting YO know because I think this would not be good not only for the girl and horse but legally as well for the YO. I've talked to a couple trainers at my barn about it and they are going to keep a quiet eye on her so that she doesn't get herself killed. The girls always been a little off kilter anyways but I was literally beside myself when I saw her doing this! Thanks for the support, now I feel more confident telling her she is an idiot and taking a completely unnecessary risk.
 
I also like horses to have areas they know the boundaries and rules in , stables are places to chill out in, relax and eat and rest (if your horse will be stabled) Manéges, schooling paddocks etc are places of work and other things are expected there. Fields are a no go place for people, they are places for the horse to be a horse, not to be ridden in, not to work in, for the horse to truly chill in.

To get on his back in a stable, to my mind, is abusing his time out space.
 
See, this is why i love y'all!!! :D

On another board I post to (which isn't as horse-friendly as this one!), there was a big discussion re: backing a horse in it's stall. Surprisingly, there were a lot of people who DO back their horses in their stalls -- for the exact same reasons the girl gave you. I am unsure how many were tied (hopefully none!), but I do know that NO ONE did it without someone else there in case something goes wrong. And if I recall correctly, only about 1/3-1/2 actually wore helmets during the fiasco.
 
Originally posted by Elvengirl
I had a disturbing encounter with a girl at my barn the other day and it is bugging me to no end, so I thought I'd ask what everyone else thinks.

I walked into one of our barns the other day to find a girl sitting on her 3 year old horse for the first time. She had a helmet on but he was tied in his 10 foot by 10 foot stall with the door closed. She was also completely alone as I was the only other person around and wasn't even going to go into the barn but saw that the light was on. She was very surprised to see me and told me not to tell anyone that she was backing her horse in his stall. She said it was safer for him in the stall because it was a safe place for him (even though he doesn't have a stall, he lives outside and she was borrowing someone else's) and that he might bolt if she backed him in the arena.

Now I know nothing about bringing on a young horse, but the images in my head of what that horse could do to her in that stall as opposed to in our HUGE arena with people in it seemed far worse and it made me shiver!

Is this dangerous and stupid? She argued with me about it forever and got really mean and I feel like I'm the silly one because I do know nothing about starting horses. Is this one way to get on a horse for the first time? What do you guys think? Should I say anything to anyone about this or just let her do what she wants? Has anyone ever done this before?
I agree that it can be very dangerous and a horse should, in my opinion, be backed under the supervision of another experienced person, else things might get sticky!
 
Dangerous, stupid, moronic, idiotic .....

I won't repeat what everyone else has said again but BOY what a fool. Every bit of what she did was wrong for safety reasons for both her and the horse, psychological reasons (as Wally said the stable is a chill out area NOT a work area) and for the feeling of the youngster being trapped and potentially panicking AND she was on her own!! What if something HAD happened, how long would she have laid there? She could have died for goodness sake. Pity the poor person who walked into THEIR stable to find her vital organs splattered all over THEIR horses stable.

She shouldn't be backing a youngster ANYWHERE never mind in a stable.

Rant ... rant ... rant .... rant ... rant ......
 
I agree with your decision to tell the YO. If you kept quiet and then found out that she had been hurt you would feel really terrible. Some people just don't have any common sense!!!
 
It's unbelievable the way some people carry on but I dont think I've heard of anything so utterly stupid as this. I too am not overly keen on handling horses in small spaces as there is no escape if they start arsing around. However, the first horse that I had was kept in a stall and she wouldn't have minded in the least if I'd sat on her in her stall. She was such a kind mare, she didn't have one evil or nasty thought for anyone. I've never known such a gentle horse. Unfortunately, someone didn't have the same thought for her!
 
......:( :( My lad sits on the cows in their stalls......does this count?

Mrs. Bradshaw (oldest cow) is not known for her rearing!;) ;) Then again she isn't a youngster! so it must be okay.
 
madness! she could end up squished!!
even i wouldn't get on my horse in the stable!
(mainly because i'd hit my head on the way out lol)

i'm even too worried about jumping on him bareback since my instructor told me of the time she got on her 20 year old dressage horse bareback and he just bucked her off because no one had ever done it on him before! bless him :) lol!
 
newrider.com