The stupid hunt ....

  • Thread starter Thread starter Guest 2
  • Start date Start date
I wonder how it would go down if genuine country-loving/dwelling traditionalists went to live in the towns and cities and objected to the errant ways of the dwellers thereof.

They may object to the amount of drink consumed and the social downsides of that.

They may object to the amount of noise after a decent time of night when honest, hardworking people are trying to sleep.

They may object to the inhumane treatment of some by others.

They may be horrified by the lack of respect which seems to prevail in such places these days.

They may voice an opinion on the apparent gulf between the haves and the have-nots, and ask why the authorities are failing to help those people who need it most, or indeed why the people themselves do not move to right such wrongs.

They may lament the lack of community spirit and wonder why there is hate and violence.

The may show concern for the amount of non sustainable energy required to allow the city dwellers to pursue their vain, pointless, uncaring, self-centered little lives to the detriment of those who do care.

Would anyone listen?................I doubt it.

Would it make a jot of difference on a global scale?.........no.

Would there be uproar and public unrest or disorder sparked by the temerity of some group dictating to them how they should live their lives, when that group had no real knowledge of what living in the city entailed, never having experienced it?.............I hope so.

Isn't it sad, then, that so many city dwellers have come to live in the country and been allowed to ride rough shod over those who seek to live their lives the way they have always done, without interference from those who would bring their non-values to bear on them whilst expecting to go unchallenged?
 
I wonder how it would go down if genuine country-loving/dwelling traditionalists went to live in the towns and cities and objected to the errant ways of the dwellers thereof.

They may object to the amount of drink consumed and the social downsides of that.

They may object to the amount of noise after a decent time of night when honest, hardworking people are trying to sleep.

They may object to the inhumane treatment of some by others.

They may be horrified by the lack of respect which seems to prevail in such places these days.

They may voice an opinion on the apparent gulf between the haves and the have-nots, and ask why the authorities are failing to help those people who need it most, or indeed why the people themselves do not move to right such wrongs.

They may lament the lack of community spirit and wonder why there is hate and violence.

The may show concern for the amount of non sustainable energy required to allow the city dwellers to pursue their vain, pointless, uncaring, self-centered little lives to the detriment of those who do care.

Would anyone listen?................I doubt it.

The situations you have listed are things that normal hard working, law abiding town citizens complain about on a regular basis. So someone from the country coming along and complaining would only be adding their voice to the large number of people who already voice their opinion regarding these matters. I know that I personally have a problem with all of the points you raise and I have never lived in the country in my life.:D

Isn't it sad, then, that so many city dwellers have come to live in the country and been allowed to ride rough shod over those who seek to live their lives the way they have always done, without interference from those who would bring their non-values to bear on them whilst expecting to go unchallenged?

Yes it's ridiculous that someone would relocate to the country from the city and expect things in the country to fit round them rather than the other way around. I would love to live in the country - smells and tractors, cows and all. I would not then go on to complain about the smell of said cows, the noise of the tractors and expect cockarels to suddenly crow at the more acceptable hour of 8am - this would be absolutely absurd.
 
Last edited:
Hillbilly, I think your rose tinted and simplistic town v country argument has already been taken apart in the last few pages should you care to read them :)

genuine country-loving/dwelling traditionalists

Does that make a country person who doesn't agree with fox hunting (which there are clearly plenty of) non genuine then?
 
Yes it's ridiculous that someone would relocate to the country from the city and expect things in the country to fit round them rather than the other way around. I would love to live in the country - smells and tractors, cows and all. I would not then go on to complain about the smell of said cows, the noise of the tractors and expect cockarels to suddenly crow at the more acceptable hour of 8am - this would be absolutely absurd.

I wish I had you as a neighbour, not my current 'townies' :D:D
 
Actually, the Hunting Act 2004 has done nothing to protect foxes from those who seek to reduce their numbers.

I doubt if the fox population has increased since the ban, and i would bet that it has in fact decreased given the amount of fox killers, other than hunts, which actively keep fox numbers down.

Where they were once hunted, foxes are now trapped, snared, poisoned, lamped with lurchers/rifle/shotgun, worked below ground with terriers and dug out, and fired upon with all manner of weapons in all conditions and regardless of whether a clean kill is possible or not.

It used to be that foxes were preserved, at least at certain times of the year so that there would be foxes there for the hunt during the season.

Now foxes are fair game for anyone with stock to protect and the fox, which may have been healthy and fit enough to beat the hounds and live to pass his genes on to the next generation, now dies a horrible death by any means available to those who would seek his demise.

The foxes most likely to live long and fruitful lives are those mange-ridden, bin-raking urban-dwellers who will be the biggest threat to British livestock, pets, and wildlife, should rabies ever take a hold here.

Rabid foxes will and do bite, or otherwise infect, humans as well as fellow animals, and those foxes which live in urban areas will be the very devil to control in the face of notifiable diseases.

The Hunting Act 2004 will pale into insignificance against legislation to control the spread of rabies.

What will the fluffies do then, I wonder?
 
Does that make a country person who doesn't agree with fox hunting (which there are clearly plenty of) non genuine then?

Good point yann,we are obviously all townies in disguise;)
On a more serious note I have sat and had a thought about this,and I have to say I do not know a single person,apart from horsey people and farmers (and not even all of those I might add) that support hunting.Bearing in mind that most people I know are 'countryside folk' whose lives and often jobs are fairly rural and in some cases agricultural based.The only ones I know who support it are horse people and 'some' farming types whose lives and work it directly affects.
It's not just sentiment either,many people (myself included) have no issues with farmers etc dealing with foxes if they cause a direct threat to stock,it's more the fact of it being considered a sport that I think most people have an issue with.It is rather outdated and barbaric to hunt something to it's death just for the thrill of it,and I think your 'average' person just doesn't see the need for it in today's society.Surely we have moved on from such primitive way's of behaving??

this could go on forever ....

I quite think it might at this rate lol,wonder if it's a record for longest thread yet??
 
Good point yann,we are obviously all townies in disguise

Well, I am a townie not in disguise, but you clearly aren't;)

Now foxes are fair game for anyone with stock to protect

They always have been haven't they?

It used to be that foxes were preserved, at least at certain times of the year so that there would be foxes there for the hunt during the season.

Glad you are able to confirm once again that the pest control argument often used to justify hunting is complete twaddle.

this could go on forever ....

It could, but nobody is forcing anyone to read or participate in it ;)
 
Actually, the Hunting Act 2004 has done nothing to protect foxes from those who seek to reduce their numbers.

I doubt if the fox population has increased since the ban, and i would bet that it has in fact decreased given the amount of fox killers, other than hunts, which actively keep fox numbers down.

Where they were once hunted, foxes are now trapped, snared, poisoned, lamped with lurchers/rifle/shotgun, worked below ground with terriers and dug out, and fired upon with all manner of weapons in all conditions and regardless of whether a clean kill is possible or not.

It used to be that foxes were preserved, at least at certain times of the year so that there would be foxes there for the hunt during the season.

Now foxes are fair game for anyone with stock to protect and the fox, which may have been healthy and fit enough to beat the hounds and live to pass his genes on to the next generation, now dies a horrible death by any means available to those who would seek his demise.

The foxes most likely to live long and fruitful lives are those mange-ridden, bin-raking urban-dwellers who will be the biggest threat to British livestock, pets, and wildlife, should rabies ever take a hold here.

Rabid foxes will and do bite, or otherwise infect, humans as well as fellow animals, and those foxes which live in urban areas will be the very devil to control in the face of notifiable diseases.

The Hunting Act 2004 will pale into insignificance against legislation to control the spread of rabies.

What will the fluffies do then, I wonder?

I'm sure in your mind you have a lot of valid points,if a little dramatic.There are many spiecies that would be far more likely to spread and carry rabies,are you suggesting we form hunt groups for them all??

In response to your last comment (and being a member of said 'fluffy' group I feel qualified to respond;))I am sure the 'fluffies' will do the most sensible thing and wait until there actually IS a problem with rabid foxes taking over the countryside before worrying about it:rolleyes:
 
Hillbilly, I think your rose tinted and simplistic town v country argument has already been taken apart in the last few pages should you care to read them :)

Does that make a country person who doesn't agree with fox hunting (which there are clearly plenty of) non genuine then?

I have read them, thanks, and that was my response.

The fact is that even only twenty years ago the amount of country dwelling individuals who objected to fox hunting, to the point where they would go out of their way to damage the livelihoods of their fellow rural neighbours, was very low.

For the sake of harmony and because each of them relied on the others for support and succour, being mainly involved in those true country pursuits of working on the land for their living, they mostly adopted a 'live and let live' attitude.

Now people can, and do, live in the coutry while being remote from any sense of reliance on anyone else around them, many being involved in such employment as IT and running businesses which aren't tied to the land.

As when they lived in the cities, they simply don't care about their neighbours, having probably never been affected by a caring attitude or a sense of respect from or to others to the extent that their lives would have been the more difficult without it.

Now there are so many non-country people scattered throughout those same communities that the balance has been tipped, due entirely to the uneducated (in rural terms), uncaring, and intolerant attitudes of those interlopers who have turned their backs on urban life but can't (or won't)acknowledge the rights of those whose lives they would interfere with.

It's a bit like social engineering, although this time the government were lucky to get the result without having to do the work, and took their reward in the form of votes from the hunting debate.

I don't think it's necessarily the fault of the individuals..........rather a symptom of the way the world is going, probably simply a biological reaction from a species under extreme duress due to overcrowding, and maybe even a downward evolutionary trend, which would make any discussion about it utterly pointless.
 
Last edited:
I'm sure in your mind you have a lot of valid points,if a little dramatic.There are many spiecies that would be far more likely to spread and carry rabies,are you suggesting we form hunt groups for them all??:

Rabies is fairly dramatic.

There would be have to be a drastic response to an epidemic here.

Methods of control are radical and involve the local destruction of many species which could act as spreaders.........crows, squirrels, rats, hedgehogs, and many more...........in Europe, rabies has had a drastic effect on agriculture with scenes similar to those seen with FMD, but on a wider scale.

Pets would suffer, as would the owners of those pets.

Humans can be infected and have to undergo painful treatment if they are to survive.

I don't think many people understand the full implications of rabies.


[QUOTE =devonlass;1915338]In response to your last comment (and being a member of said 'fluffy' group I feel qualified to respond;))I am sure the 'fluffies' will do the most sensible thing and wait until there actually IS a problem with rabid foxes taking over the countryside before worrying about it:rolleyes::[/QUOTE]

That's sensible alright. :eek:

The point is, though, thanks to the excellent fox control tactics of those true country people who are forward thinking enough to see the problems which can occur when fox numbers are allowed to get too high, the rabid foxes would take over the towns and cities long before they became a problem in the countryside.

Diseases find more difficulty spreading with fewer recipient hosts.

In the towns and cities there are any amount of stray cats and dogs, not to mention uncaring people. ;)

Remember too, it was fluffies who were responsible for the release of hundreds of mink, which quickly became thousands of mink when they discovered such delicasies as water voles, commercial and domestic poultry, waterfowl.........................:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I think that's a very very rose tinted viewpoint personally, it's all too convenient and I daresay inaccurate to blame everything on those pesky incomers.

I don't think that widespread opposition to fox hunting on moral grounds and the half hearted ban resulting from it constitutes the end of civilisation as we know it either, quite the opposite.
 
This is a good thread I have to say and I'm taking in all opinions as best I can.

I just want to point out that hunts don't set out to kill all the foxes that exist in their territory because to some extent they are trying to maintain a Status Quo. Foxes normally only prey on livestock because its easier, and when they have exhausted their normal wild prey.

By controlling their numbers hunts are trying to protect livestock with out wiping out a species. Unlike Wolves foxes do not control their own numbers according to the availability of prey, and every female in a pack will breed as many times as she can get pregnant.
 
By controlling their numbers hunts are trying to protect livestock with out wiping out a species. Unlike Wolves foxes do not control their own numbers according to the availability of prey, and every female in a pack will breed as many times as she can get pregnant.

But they are not controlling their numbers by hunting them. There was "no measurable impact" to the number of foxes during the one year ban on fox hunting in 2001 during the FMD outbreak. The International Weekly Journal of Science derived from this that there would be no change to the fox population if fox hunting was banned completely.
 
Fair point Morganna maybe I should have said "trying to..".

Was that study (or any research) carried out on any other methods of maintenence?
 
I just want to point out that hunts don't set out to kill all the foxes that exist in their territory because to some extent they are trying to maintain a Status Quo

Simply so there's something to chase next time they go out surely? Would be very boring if they got too good at it and wiped all the pests out wouldn't it :D

Unlike Wolves foxes do not control their own numbers according to the availability of prey

But the availability of prey or otherwise will surely determine what level of population can naturally be supported, so it's still self regulating even if they don't stop breeding.
 
You missed the point again Yann.

They fact that foxes were preserved during the breeding season means that it wasn't all about their destruction, and at those times at least they had someone looking out for them.

I doubt very much if those anti hunters among us have the slightest inkling of the workings of fox hunting, particularly in relation to the activities outwith the hunting season.

I've always found it impossible to discuss it beyond the point where I say I'm in favour, as hysteria usually takes over my fellow debaters and the whole thing collapses into vitriol against me.

Divide and rule is the key here...............the government were quite happy to stir up anti hunt feelings without ever airing a full and complete discussion about it which would have allowed a lot of people to base their decisions on sound knowledge, rather than some class based hysteria.

In all my experience, I've never once known of any hunt sabs being given their just desserts for their abuse (vocal and physical) of other persons, as well as horses and hounds.

What other society allows balaclava clad hooligans and scumbags to intimidate law-abiding people going about their business, while the police look on?

Then when the masses vote for a change in the law, based on their half truths gleaned from what the authorities allow us to see, those who feel hard done by protest and experience physical abuse from that same police force who failed to protect them before.

Does this mean that, if I get enough support, I can don a balaclava and come down to your place and intimidate you without redress?

I doubt it.

So what was it all about then?
 
Simply so there's something to chase next time they go out surely? Would be very boring if they got too good at it and wiped all the pests out wouldn't it :D



But the availability of prey or otherwise will surely determine what level of population can naturally be supported, so it's still self regulating even if they don't stop breeding.


As I said....when foxes natural prey runs out they go after livestock hence why we try and control numbers by hunting them wether it be by hound, snare or gun.
 
No offence, but I really think its daft to say that hunting is done to 'control the fox population' and 'aid the local farmers'. No isn't. You hunt because you enjoy it, and that's what seems a little cruel to people like me who are against hunting.
 
newrider.com