The ongoing hay issue at yard - WWYD?

squidsin

Well-Known Member
Feb 16, 2013
5,134
2,126
113
One of the liveries told me that the horses are no longer getting a haynet at 8.30pm, just the one when they come in at 4ish. And bearing in mind that there's currently just 2 hay bales in the hay barn, and 14 horses on the yard, they're only getting a wisp in their one net, until they're turned out at 8am. I've bought a load of hay blocks - Roxy has two tonight - but it's not really good enough is it? She is on part-livery, hay is included, and I've seen her eating her bed because she doesn't have any hay - not just her, they're all at it. My husband says I should say something to the YO but I know that a) it would fall on deaf ears and b) it would make things awkward for me until I leave next month. And c) my main concern is that Roxy would bear the brunt of it. I am tempted to move her to the new yard sooner as I don't want her getting colic/developing vices but I am obliged to pay for the next month and can't afford 2 lots of livery next month. WWYD? Or am I over-reacting and it's not that big a deal for horses to go all night without hay?
 
Personally, if it were me, I would find the money somewhere for 2 livery fee's and move to the new one now.

I feel that where there is one mistreatment or poor management, there are others, and I wouldn't be happy leaving my horse in the care of a yard like that.

It depends on you and your horse really, you need to decide if you are prepared to wait it out or not depending on the importance of having hay to eat when in, its a personal choice.
 
Hmm in all honesty for a month I'd be inclined to put an extra hay net in myself at 8:30 (I don't know much about hay blocks) but my suggestion relies on you being able to get up there and having the space at home to store a bale or two.

I wouldn't be happy with my horse not having hay all night. What is she bedded on ? Straw ?
 
Hmm in all honesty for a month I'd be inclined to put an extra hay net in myself at 8:30 (I don't know much about hay blocks) but my suggestion relies on you being able to get up there and having the space at home to store a bale or two.

I wouldn't be happy with my horse not having hay all night. What is she bedded on ? Straw ?
Yes she's on straw.

Nat - I think I probably will move her sooner, but finances are REALLY tight next month as on top of my usual bills and livery and childcare, I have to pay the vet's bill for her going lame last month, then the extras for her being walked in hand etc while I was on holiday. GAH!
 
I am afraid that the one thing I will not have is lack of forage. Lack of forage causes ulcers and all sorts of other issues.

I have said before, if it was me and you are happy apart from everything else on the yard that I would buy my own hay.

I just would not tolerate a horse in a stable with no hay. Horses are trickle feeders and need to eat constantly on fibre.

For me, it wouldn't worry me if they received no hard feed, but fibre would be no compromise for me. I absolutely would not put up with it.
 
I figured it might be quite tight, hence my suggestion to just pop a haynet of your own in there.

As she has a straw bed to pick at she won't starve but I'd still not be impressed at the lack of hay.

Sorry I sound all doom and gloom about it.
 
Do you have a contract at the yard? Saying hay is included and when she puts nets in etc?

It would be a good idea to drive up there an do it yourself if you can but like I said, I would worry about other stuff too, could she stay out over night for the remainder? That would solve the issue?
 
It used to worry me on the yard we were on, most folk put nets in at 5pm then went home and that was it until 8am next day. I used to leave at 9pm and the poor devils had all eaten up. I mentioned it to yard manager but it fell on deaf ears and I was politely told to mind my own business - which I didn't mind as I was poking my nose in! I was always glad we rode late on and that ours got their night net around 8.30 when I was ready to leave.
You will be so glad to move yards I'm sure - what a worry.
 
  • Like
Reactions: squidsin
Do you have a contract at the yard? Saying hay is included and when she puts nets in etc?

It would be a good idea to drive up there an do it yourself if you can but like I said, I would worry about other stuff too, could she stay out over night for the remainder? That would solve the issue?

She doesn't like being turned out as it is, so I couldn't keep her out overnight. Which is a shame! I will check my contract though, that's an excellent point.

Liveries aren't allowed to touch the hay in the barn! She goes mad when people help themselves. I don't understand it really as although I reckon the yard isn't in profit at the moment, they're obviously very well off.
 
Bud has 2 big nets up every night, so that he doesn't run out, mine all have huge nets and always have some left in the morning. We adjust it daily depending on how long they are out, quality of the grass etc but they always have something to chew on. Which is probably why they are not 'thin'. I would lob her another haynet before you go and argue the toss later.

I get through 1 big bale of haylage for 4 horses and 4 donkeys in 1 week or less.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers
It used to worry me on the yard we were on, most folk put nets in at 5pm then went home and that was it until 8am next day. I used to leave at 9pm and the poor devils had all eaten up. I mentioned it to yard manager but it fell on deaf ears and I was politely told to mind my own business - which I didn't mind as I was poking my nose in! I was always glad we rode late on and that ours got their night net around 8.30 when I was ready to leave.
You will be so glad to move yards I'm sure - what a worry.

I can't wait to move. Just hope the next one is actually trouble-free! I've had good references from 2 former liveries who both say good things about the place so fingers crossed.
 
Hardly surprising that she isn't keen on owners helping themselves as she obviously has an issue over hay.

Frankly, much as I hate confrontation, I would either move her immediately after having a conversation about the lack of hay and not pay for the rest of the month, or ensure she has adequate hay for the night.

As I have said before, any yard owner who believes that horses sleep all night and don't eat, are either stupid, or believe you are stupid enough to believe it.

If it were me, I would buy a few bales of hay and put sufficient in for the horse overnight and not worry about what she puts in. Alternatively you could move now and not pay for the rest of the month.
 
Hardly surprising that she isn't keen on owners helping themselves as she obviously has an issue over hay.

Frankly, much as I hate confrontation, I would either move her immediately after having a conversation about the lack of hay and not pay for the rest of the month, or ensure she has adequate hay for the night.

As I have said before, any yard owner who believes that horses sleep all night and don't eat, are either stupid, or believe you are stupid enough to believe it.

If it were me, I would buy a few bales of hay and put sufficient in for the horse overnight and not worry about what she puts in. Alternatively you could move now and not pay for the rest of the month.

You are right - I hate confrontation too, but I will try and talk to her tomorrow in a calm and reasoned way. I'd like to move now and not pay for another month, but I know she's chased payments with legal action before, and that concerns me. Also, I like to do the right thing - but in this case, the right thing is not being done by Roxy and me.
 
Do you pay up front ?

If not I would leave without paying up and if she pursued you, claim she broke the contract first with the hay issue and chiffney use.

I was on a yard similar, although I was a DIY, I saw all the livery horse go hungry from 5pm.

The Yo had a cash flow problem and couldn't afford to buy hay and the farmers wouldn't supply as she didn't pay the bill. Horses kicked the doors where angry to handle in the morning and the liveries didn't know why the horse changed so much since moving onto the yard.

YO saw it as a way to save money
 
  • Like
Reactions: squidsin
Do you pay up front ?

If not I would leave without paying up and if she pursued you, claim she broke the contract first with the hay issue and chiffney use.

I was on a yard similar, although I was a DIY, I saw all the livery horse go hungry from 5pm.

The Yo had a cash flow problem and couldn't afford to buy hay and the farmers wouldn't supply as she didn't pay the bill. Horses kicked the doors where angry to handle in the morning and the liveries didn't know why the horse changed so much since moving onto the yard.

YO saw it as a way to save money

I do pay up front. I could just leave without paying, but it's all very villagey round here, everyone knows everyone else, and I don't want to make enemies.
I think that's what's going on here too - I very much doubt her own 4 horses are left all night without hay. There is none in though.
 
Do you pay up front ?

If not I would leave without paying up and if she pursued you, claim she broke the contract first with the hay issue and chiffney use.

I was on a yard similar, although I was a DIY, I saw all the livery horse go hungry from 5pm.

The Yo had a cash flow problem and couldn't afford to buy hay and the farmers wouldn't supply as she didn't pay the bill. Horses kicked the doors where angry to handle in the morning and the liveries didn't know why the horse changed so much since moving onto the yard.

YO saw it as a way to save money

Completely agree

I'd move asap and not pay as she certainly hasn't offered the service you are paying for

Hope your next yard is perfect for u both
 
I would talk to her, explain your dissatisfaction re the hay and that you have the option to go sooner but are not willing to pay the remaining livery if you do. If she's skint she may be glad of one less mouth to feed, if not she should remedy it and if she doesn't then I would think she would be in less of a position legally as you have addressed your concerns with her.
 
  • Like
Reactions: squidsin
As you are already going, I would stick it out until your notice period is up and not say anything about the hay issue. Your YO is not going to suddenly change her ways - in my opinion you are best keeping a low profile and not causing too much of a fuss. As you say, the horse world is close knit and you do not want to be labelled a trouble maker.

I would however, either sneak some hay, or buy a couple of bales yourself and go down at 8pm and put it in your stable yourself.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ruskii and squidsin
If you give notice over the hay issue, I don't think she'll make a fuss about you giving Roxy extra as you will be going. But some good points mentioned above reference breach of contract....
 
Oh I said I didn't like her. Tell her straight. She completes her side of the contract which includes hay twice a night and if not then leave early for break of contract.
I can be there in a shot
 
  • Like
Reactions: squidsin
newrider.com