Sugar in carrots?

I've heard that feeding a carrot is like giving a horse a handful of oats...this is from a IH person who went to a feed nutrianlists )can't spell) talk - hence why i dont feed carrots.
 
I was always led to believe apples had a higher sugar content than carrots.

Ah well, neither bother Red's temperament :D
 
I was told be my farrier that carrots are far higher in sugar than apples.

He also told me that at this time of year (after the first frost) they are higher in sugar than normal. I'm not sure if it's true, but he's a pretty good horseman so I tend to listen to what he says :)
 
Check out the carbohydrate count for the sugar load..........


Carrots = 9.58 / 100g

Apples = 13.81 / 100g

Taken from this website...... http://www.carb-counter.org/nutrition/09003

Carrots, raw
Nutrition Facts


Serving Size: 100g

Total Calories 41.000kcal

Total Fat 0.240g

Saturated Fatty Acids 0.032g

Monounsaturated Fatty Acids 0.012g

Polyunsaturated Fatty Acids 0.102g

Cholesterol 0.000mg

Sodium 69.000mg

Total Carbohydrates 9.580g

Dietary Fibre 3.000g

Sugars 4.540g

Protein

Water 88.290g

Vitamins

Vitamin C 5.900mg

Riboflavin 0.058mg

Niacin 0.983mg

Pantothenic Acid 0.273mg

Vitamin B6 0.138mg

Vitamin B12 0.000mcg

Folate 19.000mcg

Vitamin A 12036.000IU

Vitamin E 0.660mg

Vitamin D

Vitamin K 13.200mcg

Folic Acid 0.000mcg


Minerals

Calcium 33.000mg

Iron 0.300mg

Magnesium 12.000mg

Phosphorus 35.000mg

Potasium 320.000mg

Sodium 69.000mg

Zink 0.240mg

Copper 0.045mg

Manganese 0.143mg

Selenium 0.100mcg


Apples, raw, with skin
Nutrition Facts



Serving Size: 100g

Total Calories 52.000kcal

Total Fat 0.170g

Saturated Fatty Acids 0.028g

Monounsaturated Fatty Acids 0.007g

Polyunsaturated Fatty Acids 0.051g

Cholesterol 0.000mg

Sodium 1.000mg

Total Carbohydrates 13.810g

Dietary Fibre 2.400g

Sugars 10.390g

Protein

Water 85.560g

Vitamins

Vitamin C 4.600mg

Riboflavin 0.026mg

Niacin 0.091mg

Pantothenic Acid 0.061mg

Vitamin B6 0.041mg

Vitamin B12 0.000mcg

Folate 3.000mcg

Vitamin A 54.000IU

Vitamin E 0.180mg

Vitamin D

Vitamin K 2.200mcg

Folic Acid 0.000mcg


Minerals

Calcium 6.000mg

Iron 0.120mg

Magnesium 5.000mg

Phosphorus 11.000mg

Potasium 107.000mg

Sodium 1.000mg

Zink 0.040mg

Copper 0.027mg

Manganese 0.035mg

Selenium 0.000mcg
 
It will depend on the time of year, I suspect. Roots are storage organs, so will be higher in sugars over the winter (starch) and lower over the summer.

Apples are always going to be high in sugars, just like any other fruit.
 
Carrots make mine daft they only get once every so often, none in their feeds like one horse on my yard gets a few carrots sliced in his feed every night for a succulent.
 
same here, carrots have always given mine a problem,now apples on the other hand:cool: nelly is fine with good job really as he has 2 apple trees that over hang his field,he checks on them several times a day to see if any new ones have fallen.:D:D:D
 
my horses eat both and i've never had a problem. i save apples for just before/after i've ridden though ;) they get carrots in their feeds and apples hand fed (due to calorific value ;))
 
Thanks everyone - well that certainly suprised me! I would
get them ready whilst waiting for the trimmer and often
give them quite a few carrots to keep them happy and
occupied - no wonder they were such fidgets! - they
did love their carrots too! I'll have to find another
treat that doesn't make them tap-dance whilst there
being trimmed. Thanks again for your help everyone.:;)
 
My horse has an apple in both his feeds and lots of chopped carrots. They dont seem to make a bit of difference to him though :rolleyes:

But there is a couple of horses on my yard who cant have carrots because they go loopy! :p
 
newrider.com