Successional pics to help analyze the problem

Tootsie4U

New Member
Aug 19, 2002
5,654
0
0
PA, USA
Visit site
Background onthe problem can be found here : http://www.newrider.com/forum/showthread.php?t=85760&highlight=tootsie

Warming up - nice and relaxed
July2006_20060715_0023.jpg


Here you can see one of my biggest flaws. I raise and move my leg when asking for more energy.
July2006_20060715_0049.jpg


And from here on out things start to fall apart. The pictures tell the story.
July2006_20060715_0050.jpg

July2006_20060715_0059.jpg

July2006_20060715_0064.jpg

(He starts to dive right -really motorbiking! Maybe not at this instant in the photo, but I am really trying to think about my inside shoulder and weighting outside leg)

...and then things get really ugly.
July2006_20060715_0063.jpg



Its a good thing Im a humble person because these photos are really incriminating and truly dont show any highlights of my ridden career :o

I think I may see something but what do you all think?
 
First I'll pick on you:D Nice & sitting tall but a bit on the crotch & the leg is too far back. Is this a regular position for you? Or were you trying too hard to get him going? If the leg is too far back, it will affect his balance & compound his own issues. That's all that's really noticable. Other than: cool t-shirt! (I saw some over here like yours a while back, think I'm going to pick one up)

Now for your lovely horse:
He does seem very tense. Is there someting going on with his shoulder or a vertebrae or hock?

Has he been seen by a specialist to assess his skeletal frame? (Can't think of a better word) Someone like a chiro, physio, masseuse, reiki...

The diving sounds like he can't support himself, so he needs to get out of it quick. When you're stiff & a joint hurts, balance is compromised.

Have you tried him on the lunge to see how he goes? Have you tried massage & limbering exercises/stretches done on the ground?

These are just thoughts. I had a QH that was retired from barrel racing when we bought him. They used to run him hard until he could no longer perform. He was so stiff & would rush & duck.

I spent many in hand sessions massaging & TTEAM stretches & excercises as well as lungeing. He eventually progressed but also by the age of 24 his hoscks were degenerating, DMSO helped along with full retirement from riding & lungeing. I continued to do the TTEAM work.

We had a good 14yrs together though.
 
Last edited:
Wow - those pics are great - they tell a great story - good job for posting (very brave - I'm sure no-body's going to lay into you for it :) )

I wish I could have got some pics of joePony over the last few weeks - they'd tell the same story - I'll see if he will do it again this weekend for me but I think he might be cured now. joe's story was that his saddle had caused him pain in the past, so now every time I ask for canter, suppose I'm on bend to the left asking for canter, then he throws his head hard right(outside), his nose is in the sky, and he disappears out the left shoulder (inside) galloping hard and needless to say I'm all over the place, he's saying it's gonna hurt, and I'm flumping about on his back and he's darn right it does hurt !

I can see similar things happening here .... a downward spiral starting with his tension and resistance, so you have no chance of being relaxed and able to follow his movement at all ... so he tenses up even more ... See that last pic - that's EXACTLY how joe was feeling to me - of course I was on his back and couldn't see it but there's no dobt about it - same tense expression, same head thrown high, same tight back ... same rushing off to the inside

For me the solution was to stop ! Avoid the issue altogether. I know - sounds like such a cop-out. Thing is, you're in a similar position - you can't be entirely sure he's fixed and no longer in pain - or is he still in a bit of pain ? or is he thinking it's going to hurt and so he's tensing up and then it is causing pain ?

Who knows ? For me, the solution was to go back to lower, slower, quieter work for far far longer than you could possibly believe it would take. I knew he had a problem with canter, so we went and stuck just to walk for 3 weeks before even trotting again. I wanted to make absolutley sure that not only the original pain was gone, but also that I built up the required muscles up and yup and up - by riding him actively - like you are doing at a walk up there - so that by the time we trotted that he was actually desperate to trot and had more than enough of the right muscles to do it well. Then we stayed at trot another couple of weeks, but really working hard at walk still - I mean literally working up a huge sweat in walk - before beginning to think about our own particular bug-bear - the canter.

I might be completely off-base here, but it looks to me like you have absolutely no problem at all as a rider, you're far and away good enough - I just don't think it's realistically possible to follow the movement when this tension cycle starts.

ETA - you see your expression in the big pic... the fifth one ... yep - that's what I look like when I'm working hard and it's not getting any better too :D
 
Last edited:
Thanks to all the ideas!

My riding position has been better. Im struggling to get it back after a long break from riding. I tend to have my legs too far forward and think I may be over compensating for it now, since I know I have position issues.

What I was actually thinking was that in these photos and some that I didnt post (there are 67 in all) I am really braced forward and noticably dropping my inside shoulder and hip even while we travel straight. This of course is going to throw him OTF and that coupled with me dropping my inside makes him drop his as well. But, that doesnt explain why he does it to the right if we're going left. Does it?

The saddle could very well be a big issue. It hasnt been fitted this year and I have it done every year without fail. Since I dont ride regularly (read hardly at all) I just didnt prioritize it. I know a little bit about saddle fit and I personally dont see anything obviously wrong. He's very barrel shaped and its an extra wide tree. Its flocked to his back - albeit a more muscled back from last year. Its balanced well and has no protruding nails or screws. Its worth investigating.

But the big part of this equation is that this has happened before, very early on in his training. It was an evasive behavior to work (you have to know my horse to understand). It also happens very regularly in canter but that is 100% rider error and once I lift my inside and weight my outside, he fixes himself in response. Thats not workign this time and its also happening in trot.

Im just not sure whats going on here. I think I'll give him two weeks off and then try again. I'll probably request an appointment with my saddler too while we wait.

BTW LMS, There are about a dozen pics of us lunging just prior to these ridden photos. Nothing shows up there except obvoius breaks in concentration (where his head goes up). There may be an ever so slight limp but its so sublte I really cant say its a hock. So, that tells me this is either rider induced or saddle problem.
 
Last edited:
Hmmm you say that when lunging there is a very slight limp?
I wouldn't disregard this because... think about it: if you say a lot of it is rider error; put these 2 together & it exagerates what the horse feels.

I'll use myself as an example: when my hip hurts a little & I'm carrying my briefcase: it hurts more.

The same is probably happening to your horse. When you are on him, it makes it more apparent as there is more stress put on the affected area.

Just a thought
 
Last edited:
1st pic - he does look relaxed, you look good, although hard to say much from that angle.

2nd - you've started to tip forward - your leg has moved back, yes, but what is more important is that your upper body has gone forward in response. your hands have turned over (it looks like) which brings your elbows out and youer shoulders forward. sitting here on the sofa i'm holding my arms in riding position, and putting my hands correctly with thumbs on top and then turning them over.my elbows come out, my shoulderblades come out fro mmy body and i want to go forward. so think thumbs on top, elbows by the side.

which leads on to pic 3 - your outside hand (nearest camera - i assume you were on a clockwise circle and photo was taken from the outside of it?) has gone forward, and your outside rein is drooping. this creates a space he can dive that outside shoulder into. he has tilted his head, his nose is pointing in and his ears and eyes are saying 'aha!'.

pic 4 - can't see much, but i'd want more contact on the reins - they're still bagging.

pic 5 - he is not balancing well here - you can see he is motorbiking round the corner. almost identical pic of petal - http://historicalfact.com/~es/pony pictures/dressage3.jpg and you can see she is more 'upright', and taking equal weight on the outside hind and inside fore - bon is all on that inside fore, look at how much more flexed that fetlock is than the outside hind. so think inside leg on (it's not touching him in that pic), slow, inside shoulder up and back, your weight on the outside.

pic 6 is the same thing. i would, at this stage, slow right down, regain corect bend, regain attention, and start again.
remember to always think of aids on the side he is runnign off to - so in pic 6, right leg on firmly and right hand to maintain the bend. control his shoulders - he has to go where they point, and here, that right shoulder is off and running.
keep everything slow and steady, work on his balance, work on getting him back off his forehand and give yourself time ot think, he he shoots off, stop and regroup, start again.
 
Mehitabel, you've met this horse and have followed our saga from day 1 - is there anything in this story now that makes you think pain? Or knowing what you know about Bon, would you say this is a typical evasion?
 
i wouldn't necessarily say pain - i would probably go with 'i've had a while off, it's more difficult than it used to be, i've forgotten i used to quite enjoy it, so why on earth would i make life any easier for mum who isn't at the top of her game'.

i'd never discount pain over the internet - i'd have to watch in person, poke about a bit, all the usual. but it's not screaming 'this is a horse who is in pain' to me, as some threads with descriptions of evasions do. he is probably stiff from time off and not having to work properly for a while, which might account for the slight unlevelness on the lunge.
 
Mehitabel said:
i'd have to watch in person, poke about a bit,

Uh huh.. although Im not discounting the saddle (it should be checked), I dont see any signs of pain when I poke around. The uneven walk I did notice on the lunge is extremely slight - so much that Im hesitant to even explain it away to unsoundness.

I just want to be sure before I pull up my sleeves and ride it out of him. It doesn't surprise me that he's just taking advantage - he's done it before. A smart one this is... very.
 
Last edited:
Just a suggestion.... it may be pants... I'm not that knowledgeable but rather than trying to do circle work... why not do squares and put say 3 cones in an 'L' shape on the corners so you have to turn more sharply than being able to motorbike. The only reason I mention this is my lumbering cob tends to fall in and motorbike corners but one evening in the school someone had left just one cone in each corner and she really came up more upright and turned more precisely.... I was really surprised by her reaction.
 
I would agree with needing more contact on the reins, you may find it will give the horse more security aswell as a more clear instruction.

I would defo try and sit up staighter and bring your legs underneath you more, I think in the last pic he aswell as evading you he looks really quite unsure of what exactly he is meant to be doing.. ( aswell as giving the cameraman '' evos'' !! :D )
 
Thanks all. :)

For what its worth - the washing line reins were what I was aiming for. The horse likes to lean. I see though, that for now I may need to take them back to fix this problem first.
 
my horse leans if i don't watch it

i have to ride with my legs into a contact which is light and mobile to prevent the dastardly sneak from leaning, but he's good at catching me out and before i know it he's leaning!

lateral work helps keep me and him aware that he is not supposed to lean
 
I do not know your horse, or any of the previous situations, but after checking saddle and that there is no pain.
I would go back to basics and just work in walk for a week or so. The slower the pace, the slower you have to react and the more likely you are to notice the subtle signals that it is about to happen, and so you can prevent it from happening. It is a case of thinking ahead of him, knowing what he is going to do before he does. Also you may notice a trigger that sets him off and so you may find the cause for his new habit. If you can break the habit he will forget this party trick. Once he is soft and accepting in walk just ask for half circles of trot then back to walk and slowly build it up. It will take a long time but he knows better so will eventually return to the horse you know.
Doing lots of walk work will also allow you to become molre confident in your riding again and so feel more able to ride him through it.
Good luck, and he is a very nice horse.
 
Try riding from the inside leg into teh outside rein a little more. Give him a contact on that outside rein so he has somewhere to go when you push him on; it also means you can use that rein to check and balance him. He looks like he's running through teh outside rein and fallin right in because there is nowhere for him to work into. That, coupled with the fact that you are tipping forwards, moving your weight off your seatbones and in effect dropping your weight and his onto the forehand, makes evasion very easy for him.

The first picture is lovely. And it's going to be tough getting you both back into this, so don't be too hard on yourself either :) .
 
Mystery Solved

Believe it or not, but I do know how to ride. :o I knew these photos were incriminating :p

Thanks for the tips and pointers. They really helped. A special thanks to Mehitabel for giving me the confidence to stop doubting myself.

With a little pep talk to remind myself to keep my inside up - outside rein supportive- and to *use* my weight aids - we accomplished LOVELY, controlled, slow ;) 20m circles tonight :)

He tried it on me within four strides after mounting - and then again about every 6 strides. After about five minutes of correcting him, he gave up and continued through the ride like the trained horse he can be.

Thanks to all for helping me through this one...

BTW Domane, that was a great suggestion!
 
This must be so frustrating for you :( Not many things worse than that gut feeling that all's not quite right and trying to pin down the cause! You mention in the previous post that you were not sure that maybe there was more damage to his hind legs. Now just a thought (and probably totally wrong) sparked off by your mention of a slight limp on the lunge. My horse had a bizarre array of behavioral issues end of last year - reluctant to go off the leg, very hollowed which got worse at faster paces, spinning and ducking.... we all thought it was just chestnut mare syndrome and tried all the harder to get her working properly. Then she stopped taking right lead canter. We put her on the lunge, and she was lame - only on the lunge and only when lunging in a circle to the right. It turned out she had a suspensory ligament injury to a fore leg - all fixed now after box rest and a period of controlled exercise, walking for 6 weeks gradually increasing length of time and then building in trot for a further 6 weeks and finally up to canter.
I'm probably miles off track, but if you are experiencing similar things (which it sounds like you are) it may well be worth investigating.
Hope it all gets sorted soon - I'm sure it will :)
 
Tootsie4U said:
Thanks all. :)

For what its worth - the washing line reins were what I was aiming for. The horse likes to lean. I see though, that for now I may need to take them back to fix this problem first.

Tootsie

some psychology for you... why is the solution to "he leans" to give him more rein ? Does that stop him leaning on the rein or does it just remove the rein from the situation ?

I *know* its never that simple. You may be aiming to help him develop self-carriage so he doesn't lean. But I also know you are a thoughtful and educated rider who will think that through and decide if you are achieving what you want or just avoiding the issue ?

I know I went through a phase of asking Fi for more and then rewarding when she gave it... by giving back everything she'd just given in my release :rolleyes:

I'm also curious how long this sequence went over ? I can't see you correcting once it starts to fall apart - we can see it clearly in the photos but did it feel like that as well ?

I had it pointed out to me - by two different instructors - that if I didn't want Fi to spook then she needed to be between hand and leg - all the time. And it makes a big difference. My temptation is to want to start on a long outline - but if she won't soften and relax in that outline then we have to start somewhere else and work back to that. Especially now she has been diagnosed with DJD in the hock. She needs to work properly and in balance so she doesn't over stress the joints by moving badly.
 
newrider.com