Straw, what's it all about?

Jane&Ziggy

Jane&Sid these days!
Apr 30, 2010
22,074
10,564
113
66
Surrey Hills
Chaff is made (I believe) of chopped straw, and so are loads of other bagged and block forages.

So why did my friend Suzi get all stressy when we put a bale of straw in the shelter this evening, and all 3 horses dashed straight in to nom it?

It can't have been very palatable, because they only nommed little bits and hurried out when we got them a slice of hay, but they were giving it their best shot up until then.

What is the problem with eating straw?
 
Oh they USED to say that straw would cause colic because it can be too much fibre.... but they've changed their tune in recent years
 
Good quality oat straw is softer and more digestible but the heavy fibrous stuff increases the chance of impaction colic, or so I believe.
 
In Portugal most people fed straw rather than hay because hay was difficult to get hold of and very expensive! Good quality straw is a perfectly adequate foodstuff if you need to feed it, so I wouldn't worry about them having a little nibble, small amounts aren't going to do them any harm. I have known horses bedded on straw to try and eat it at first, but they tend to give up on that pretty quickly when they realise that their hay is much tastier!
 
Ours always eat a bit of their straw beds. I would rather that than the bill we had for a cob who ate a whole paper bed, vets operating anteroom was covered in paper mache by the time we had resolved the resulting choke, (she then tried to eat the vets cardboard bedding!)
 
They did used to say straw caused impaction colic but my vet told me it would be okay to buy oat straw to mix with Storm's hay to bulk it out and provide fibre. However, around here you cannot get oat straw. Our everyday straw bedding is excellent quality but I read an alarming report in Your Horse saying they should NEVER be allowed to eat it as its full of pesticide and chemicals. Good job Storm does not eat her bed then!!!
 
I would not want my horse eating straw suddenly without factoring it in slowly. It can be a cause of impaction colic as I have seen first hand especially if they gorge on it quickly. I suppose so can hay but straw is rougher and compacts differently.

The fact the the straw is processed and chopped small in chaff is why I have feed it, although I don't feed the standard processed chaff now, I have moved to simple systems for a cleaner less processed feed, including only chopped hay in the chaff.
 
I hate to disagree but the only impaction colic I have seen based on straw bedding was on a processed chopped straw bedding. I have however seen more impaction colics on horses with a high level of chaff feeds which is why we only feed soaked feeds now.
 
Rosie once had colic from eating a vast amount of her straw bed.....but little nibbles at it never caused any problems...she was bored, finished her net and decided to eat almost her entire bed as me and Moet were late back from a competition!
 
It depends on the chaff - some like halleys and simple systems dont use straw.

The reasons are as above, unfortunatley Madam will often choose her bed over the ahy :redcarded: she loves straw.
 
As soon as Cracker has finished his hay he starts nibbling on his straw bed. It doesnt seemed to have harmed him, and it stops him being bored.

But we deep litter so there isnt much new straw to eat. Even the gutbucket wont eat it if its mucky.

As a native I would have thought he was able to cope with fairly rough stuff, and I have noticed that he nibbles it most delicately, almost one strand at a time, so at that rate would that reduce the risk of impaction? I'm worried now.
 
We have a bale of straw in our field for them to munch on between hay feeds at breakfast and dinner. Dick vet was more than happy with this solution, no problems but they only nibble at it as last resort to keep the furnace burning until next meal and I think they only do that when they come up to the gate just before feeding time. So far the bale has lasted a month and only has a couple of head sized holes in it. If it snows its just a bit of an ease to know they are nibbling away.
 
Well, I like to hear that. I did notice that all 3 boys took little nibbles of/strands of the straw, rather than tearing out huge mouthfuls as they do with the hay.

I would actually be pleased to have something for them to nibble on, because although they are all maintaining their weight really well (even Tommy the TB) there is very very little to eat in their field, and when Mattie doesn't have anything to eat he windsucks. If the straw keeps him occupied that's a big plus in my book :happy:
 
When Rosie was stabled I mixed her hay with straw 50/50 so she had more to pick at for longer without pigging out. Last winter I used barley straw instead of hay as it still keeps them warm and full up while not adding so many calories. She only just made target weight by spring! They eat what they want/need rather than because its tasty. An f plan diet :) I know several people who advocate straw over hay. Its also masses cheaper too :)
 
Large amounts of anything can cause impaction colic... Straw is not the only culprit!

I talked to our vet in Portugal about this as I did wonder if straw was as bad as the tale goes, and she said that most of the impaction colic she dealt with was caused not by any type of forage but by hard feed constantly being fed too dry.
 
Ok... Now I'm panicking:/!!! Straw CAN cause impaction colic- I'm feeding kitty on topchop lite there is alot of oat straw in this....has anyone ever know this feed to cause a problem?? Sorry if I'm panicking for no reason, but it has worried my silly little brain:/!!!!
 
Belle gets fed straw on vets advice - mixed with her hay ration to fill her up for less calories. She has one net of just hay and one mixed 50/50 I call it her 'desperation net!' We have bales of straw along one side of our indoor school and all the horses try to grab a mouthful as they pass given the chance.
 
The vet told me to keep Ben off straw because it had too many calories in it and he is supposed to be losing weight. As we soak his hay (and he hardly gets any anyway) I guess that the straw would be more calorific than hay.

He has been stabled overnight due to his foot abscess and he was eating his straw like there was no tomorrow. I think that it was because it was a very fresh, new bed. It does worry be because I have always thought that straw was bad to eat.
 
newrider.com