[Sorry Wally I was writing my reply as you were posting yours.]
I may be way off line here but Jaz you say you were riding a horse belonging to your school. Is the horse used to going out alone? Horses are naturally gregarious and some school ponies will not hack out alone for love nor money. Their very lack of independent thought is what makes them good hackers for novice riders. The same horse can behave impeccably in a school where it is in an enviroment it knows. I used to ride a pony who was a stinker to get going on his own. Does she nap with all her riders or is she testing you out? School horses are very good psychologists. Mike Peace makes a point which I think is a good one. Getting off and leading a horse is never an admission that it has won. My own pony has been known to be difficult if we need to go past his every day field, not very frequent, or even the field where he has his summer holidays. However I know him and just play it by ear. If encouragement followed by two sharp taps behind the leg do not get cooperation I hop off and lead him in a very determined fashion. He has learnt that he will have to go where required so now has virtually stopped arguing. The aim is to get him where you want to go when you want to be there, not to spend time and, in your case, money stood still having an argument which you will never win by brute force.
As for your problem Mivs I sympathise. Perceived wisdom says do not take a horse up the road and back down if you can possibly avoid it. It is far better if you can to do a circular route. The reason being that horses learn that they are going there and back again and say to themselves "Why on earth should I?" Most horses will go better when headed toward home, even if home is 6 miles away or more. They have a better instinct than homing pigeons!
Unfortunately many schools will not allow unaccomapanied hacking, due to insurance problems and litigation risks, as well as concern for the welfare of the horses, so school horses who are good independent hackers are becoming something of a rarity.
Sorry if I am not being very helpful but even though I would discuss the whole situation, riding styles, routes etc, with your instructors, the problem may not stem from your riding techniques.
Good luck
[Edited by Mossy on 22nd Oct 2000 at 11:12 PM]