So many boots, so many choices!

whirlybird

New Member
Sep 5, 2012
74
0
0
Renfrewshire, Scotland
Not sure if this is the right place to ask (Mods, please feel free to move if not!), but can anyone give me some advice about what type of boots to buy?

I'm just returning to riding after a 10 year gap and am also about to start volunteering for RDA in Glasgow - so excited, I'm like a child all over again! Although I kept my riding hat (ok for current legislation apparently), jodhpurs, gloves, etc, I stupidly gave my old riding boots away a few years ago, so now need to invest in a new pair. But.... I'm completely confused by all the new types of boots out there! When I used to ride, the choice was long, short, or wellies for in the yard, but now there's a world of options and I've no idea what to get.

I suffer from cold feet all year round, so want warmth.
I'm fundamentally lazy, so want a boot that's suitable for yard/field work, but also for riding in and comfy to walk about in for hours at a time- I can't be beggered with changing boots for every task!
I have "dog walkers" calf muscles, so probably want a short boot.
I have a weak left ankle (leftover from a broken bone a couple of years ago) so probably want a bit of support in that area
I'm terrified of slipping on wet/icy ground, so want a sole that is grippy, without being dangerous in the stirrup!
budget - don't have a lot of spare cash, but would rather buy one good pair that will do me for a few years rather than buying cheap (and probably less comfy) boots.

Obviously it's going to come down to personal choice, but any pointers on type/material/make or good/bad experiences would be a great starting point!
 
I like Ariat Grassmere's for yard/riding boots. I think they come in wide so might work with the 'dog walkers' calves :giggle:, they have ties to tighten them down the leg and ankle, so nice and supportive, comfy as anything and keep your feet toasty (I have terrible circulation so that is a big issue for me!).

Unfortunately I didn't get my Grassmere's until I had already started using my Ariat Windermere's for yard work/riding, they are great boots but have now dropped so that I can't wear them riding without them catching on the saddle. I know have to spend an extra 2 minutes changing boots into proper riding ones.....I am not impressed by this! :giggle:
 
I have recently purchased my first pair of ariat grasmeres, and I LOVE them!!! They are like a second skin, really comfy to both ride, walk and do all my yard tasks in. The only downside is that they are not cheap. They cost £249.99 which is a stupid amount of money, but I’m hoping that they will last me for years and years.

I also have mountain horse short boots. I love these as well – they are great to ride and I wear them whenever I go walking etc. The only problem is that as they are leather they do get wet if I walk through wet grass etc. These probably cost about £70ish, so are much more reasonable in price.
 
I have recently purchased my first pair of ariat grasmeres, and I LOVE them!!! They are like a second skin, really comfy to both ride, walk and do all my yard tasks in. The only downside is that they are not cheap. They cost £249.99 which is a stupid amount of money, but I’m hoping that they will last me for years and years.

I also have mountain horse short boots. I love these as well – they are great to ride and I wear them whenever I go walking etc. The only problem is that as they are leather they do get wet if I walk through wet grass etc. These probably cost about £70ish, so are much more reasonable in price.
 
If you're going out when its icy weather and you're going to ride, I'd actually use these
http://www.amazon.co.uk/s/ref=nb_sb...words=ice+shoe+grips&sprefix=ice+shoe,aps,116
but the stables should have grit to use anyway as they wouldn't want their disabled clients falling over.
I had to buy a pair of childs size 4 saxon jodhpur boots as the adult ones were too big and creating blisters. For carriage driving and general yard work, I wear my leather walking boots.
 
Check out the ranges of short boots by Mountain Horse and Ariat. I have used both of those in the past and been really happy - and mine get a LOT of usage as I'm on the yard all day every day and ride an average of 20 hours a week! I currently have a pair of Ariat Terrain boots which are super. I find that the walking-type styles tend to be more robust and long-lasting than jodhpur boots - although there are a few jodhpur-type styles that are really sturdy, like the Dublin Venturer boots and the Mark Todd Kiwi Work Boot (I have both of these and am very impressed, plus they are roomy enough for extra pairs of socks!)

ETA - get the best boots you can afford. The cheaper ones may seem good for the first 6 months or so but they are usually cheap for a reason and it really can be a case of false economy!

ETA again, sorry! - like you I have cold feet all the time (Reynaud's Disease, great!) and the Ariat Terrain and Dublin Venturer boots are both lovely and warm! Don't get flimsy thin jodhpur boots as they don't keep your feet warm at all! - and go for something with a thick sole to stop you losing warmth there.
 
Last edited:
I have muck boots / mudruckers for cold feet - not posh but amazingly warm :)

Also to note on the hat - the padding deteriorates over time so I would probably be considering a new one as they should be replaced regularily eg very two/three years web if youve had no bumps :)
 
^ Ditto PFB I bought some last year and they are THE MOST warmest things I've ever put on my feet. In winter they're pure luxury & worth every single penny.
 
Thanks so much for all the lovely replies and suggestions:happy: I would LOVE the Ariat grassmeres, but there is no way on earth that I can afford them............ yet! I've been having a good hunt around today and have a couple of the Mountain Horse ones on my radar, but I also found these http://www.equestrianclearance.com/ekkia/equi-theme-mountain-boots/index.html

Not a brand I've heard of, but they do look pretty rugged, with sheepskin inside. Toasty toes! has anyone got any experience of Equi-Theme stuff and if so is it generally any good?

@wiz201, I've actually already got a pair of those, but for some reason hadn't made the mental link that I could use them on my new riding boots as well as my wellies!!! Doh!
 
I have the same Mountain Horse - but dont wear them for walking except when snow on the ground. You should get a new hat by the way - standards and materials have changed and the foam deteriorates. A hat may have a shelf life of only 4 or 5 years.
 
I have muck boot tyne's ... have had them for well over a year now and they are the only boot I have ever had that has lasted this well ( Im a serial boot wrecker!) I wear them for all yard chores and for riding and they have to be the best boots for every job - obviously I wouldn't ride in a show in them but seeing as I only hack and don't 'show' I don't care. I love them because they are sooooo warm, they have lasted brilliantly well and I can go from mucking out to riding with just a quick rinse under the tap. Also they don't get overly warm in the summer and they do stretch on the calf area because of the neoprene.
I do have a lovely pair of mountain horse riding boots but they have never been on my feet since I got my muck boots and you can pick a pair up for about £68.
 
Can't make any recommendations really, having a thin budget and fat calves, but Equestrian Clearance are the dogs! Delivery within 48 hours normally.

I bought a pair of Sherwood Forest seconds from them last year for £40 (saw the same boots at YHL for £130) and so far they're lasting well. Better, in fact than a woman on our yard's who hasn't had hers nearly as long as me and hers are looking a bit sorry for themselves.
 
The Equi-Theme ones you've linked look nice - but if you do get anything that is waxed leather make sure you take VERY good care of them, they will last a long time if you do but if you don't they will start to crack on the areas that get the most stress (esp. the toes)
 
Having problems with my left ankle too (have had a fusion, it requires lots of support and can be weak) the only boots I have found to be suitable were the Mountain Horse peak: http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Mountain-...ds_Athletic_Shoes_ET&var=&hash=item2ec113b19f . They arent cheap but Ive had mine a year and they still look like brand new so worth the money. They are extremely supportive but dont restrict like long boots would (I wear mine with half chaps). I struggle to bend my ankle to get in most shoes as its screwed into position (literally) and with them being lace up they have enough room to get them on easily even when I'm quite sore or my ankle is extra swollen. I've done everything in them from hacking, jumping, walking the dog and yard work and they are sooo comfy, only boots that havent blistered me and I wear them all through the year. I have arthritis so I have a need to keep my joints warm and these have been fine. They are basically walking boots/trainers with a riding sole. Think I paid about £85 ish. (best money I ever spent on footwear tbh! my old saxon ones were ruined within less than a year).
 
Thanks Guys! You've made some really good points and it's great to find out how these boots are from people who use them. I'm going to go and have a look at the various Mountain Horse boots you've recommended as well as the Muck boots - hopefully I'll have new boots before too long!
 
I have Mountain Horse High Rider 2's as they are the only boot that offer good grip, good foot position and great for yard work AND come in a size 4 short and wide!lol. I love love mine. BUT, for yard work and dirty dirty muddy fields I do have some Muck boots and also some Sherwood Dalton country boots - both have good grip and you can treat them shabbily and get away with it!!!

I also have some Ariat Windermere's but I wear those more for out and about and maybe just the odd visit to kiss noses last thing at night! Though you can ride in them too and I have to say they are fab in the saddle too.
 
newrider.com