It's funny, because for me it was easy getting goal on the meal replacements with very little required in the way of willpower. For me, abstinence was easier than moderation. That's exactly why the meal replacements worked and I could break the cycle and lose more weight than I'd managed by doing anything else. So many people i know don't even get that far and these people tended to be the first to knock what i was doing. I simply couldn't have done it on conventional healthy eating plans (I'd been trying all my adult life) and that's what prompted my doctor to point me in the direction of Lighterlife that first time.
Of course where it all fell apart for me was in not realising that finding abstinence so easy was another sign that I needed to find a way towards moderation. I thought that being able to be abstinent was having control over my eating, it wasn't. Because if that I didn't do all the steps up as I thought I had beaten my demons and didn't need to. Being able to lose the weight made me feel capable of anything!
I know that public opinion is against a VLCD but luckily there are people, my doctor included, who recognise that they can be very useful to stop the rot.
Yes, this is my third time of losing more than 6 stone and my first 2 times I was the worst ambassador for the VLCD as I thought I was cured! I did exactly as you predicted everterbabe and quickly regained my weight.
Just because I regained my weight those first 2 times doesn't mean it wasn't worth trying again or that the VLCD was to blame. It was simply that I didn't do the bit that the general public isn't that aware of which is the gradually stepped process of reintroducing conventional food. I got carried away with the feeling of control that abstinence gave me and thought I was cured.
My successes now are based on the foundations of my previous 2 times of losing and then regaining my weight. I needed to learn the lessons from my failures to get to where I am now. Its only to be expected in a way, it took me a good few goes to give up smoking years ago but if I'd taken that as a sign to stop trying then I wouldn't have stopped! I gave up eventually by doing it exactly the same way as I had each time before as I knew I could, I just hadn't managed it.
The journey I needed to go on to learn enough to keep my weight off had been a very personal one. I know many people who have lost and regained, or lost and kept off weight following any number of different ideas on how to do it. Those successful on weightwatchers will push weightwatchers, Rosemary Conley will promote that. Ive failed at these and numerous other ways but i can appreciate that there are those who lost and kept their weight off because of them. The difference between a conventional healthy eating plan and a complete conventional food replacement plan was that i never managed to lose even 2 stone, let alone 6+ stone! Ive never doubted that i could get to goal on a VLCD, i felt in control by being able to cut out all conventional food. I've never had that high with anything else I've done to control my weight and it was very empowering.
I've continually had to justify my choices but tried to encourage others to identify their particular strengths and weaknesses, keeping a food and food thought diary is great for this. From there its possible to try and work through them in a structured way and sometimes a 'diet' isn't needed, others may like the structure of a 'diet'. I don't presume to know best for everyone else and just wish others would do me, and others like me who chose food replacement diets, the same courtesy.
I've tried to explain why a VLCD has worked to get me to goal, something ive not managed on conventional healthy eating plans and something so many other people don't manage to do eitger so even getting to the stage where I could be in a position to regain all my weight is a step beyond what many can attain because at least I've got to goal 3 times. That's why I find it strange that so many see the fact that i regained my weight as a bigger failure than not even getting to goal at all!
I've tried to explain why the VLCD was just the start of my journey this time, but the majority of my time was spent on the higher plans to rehabilitate myself. Hopefully by being honest about my problems has helped others not to make the same mistakes I did. I know it has on the site where I keep my detailed maintenance diary so its been worth taking the time out to share where I've gone wrong and how I've got it right.
I would never tell anyone that their way is wrong and my way is right and it bugs the crap out of me when others do. All my wrong decisions have all had their lessons to impart and are not something I'm ashamed of, or regret. I just hope everyone else finds the right way for them to work through their challenges too so that they change enough to make it possible to get to their goal too...and stay there! I don't care how, just that they do because its amazing when it finally starts to click into place.