'Shivering' weight off

KP nut

I'd rather be riding.
Dec 22, 2008
6,539
5,379
113
Please don't think this is a rehash of another post - It really isn't! I am just curious about the thinking behind this advice.

I have (like many others) been advised in the past to reduce my horse's weight by 'shivering it off'. I didn't do it as if just didn't feel right but that's not a great reason to do/not do something, so I thought I would try and get my thinking on this a bit clearer, and see what others know or think about this strategy.

The theory behind it is simple enough: cold triggers a shivering reflex which involves rapid tensing and releasing of large muscle groups. This generates heat and uses up lots of calories. So it warms the horse up while burning up calories. Therefore the horse does not become too cold and does lose weight.

To get the heat generation - which is the thing that burns the calories - the horse has to be cold enough to trigger the shivering reflex. A horse who is out naked but feels warm to the touch and is not shivering is not 'shivering it off'! For this reason to get a horse cold enough it normally has to be clipped and unrugged, otherwise its excellent natural protection will kick into play and it will be a fluffy warm horse not a shivering one!

The next assertion made to me by the vet who recommended it is 'it won't do her any harm'. And 'horses don't feel the cold the way we do'. To the first part of that: Not causing harm is not the same as not causing discomfort/distress. To the second part: how does anyone know?

Looking at it from a Biological/Evolutionary perspective: if cold does not cause horses harm why does the horse go to all the trouble of growing a fluffy coat? There must be a selective advantage to coat growing. So I am not sure being cold enough to shiver does no harm.

Also energy conservation is important to horses, so they can survive tough winters with little intake, so it makes sense to me that as shivering burns up lots of energy, horse's must experience shivering as aversive. If the horse was un-bothered by shivering the horse would have no motivation for seeking shelter or huddling with the herd. It simply makes no evolutionary sense that a horse is burning through vast energy reserves via shivering without at the same time having some biological mechanism that makes that experience highly aversive.

Also, although I don't want to be anthropomorphic about this, humans have exactly the same reflex that has exactly the same function. We shiver to stay warm. But equally, we experience shivering as highly, highly aversive. Presumably so we are motivated to find shelter and warmth to conserve energy. So if shivering does the same job in the same way for people as for horses why should we assume that the 'aversive' energy conservation part of process is absent in horses?

Finally I think there is an error in logic being used when people say a fat horse can cope better than a thin horse with shivering. See for example the Blue Cross Guide to Weight-Loss:

" An overweight horse has plenty of fat to keep warm, and the fat is fuel for when it is cold. Shivering is a sign that the fat is being burned up by the horse to keep warm, exactly as it should be.In a fat horse this is good news..."

This ignores the fact that in our evolutionary past, obesity did not exist so there are no biological mechanisms for preventing it or reversing it, the way there are for preventing or reversing being underweight. From a biological point of view a fat horse does not realise it is fat! So fat horses are as biologically driven to conserve energy as thin ones. And therefore to experience shivering as aversive.

So while it is true that a fat horse is better insulated so less likely to shiver in the first place, there is no reason to believe a shivering fat horse is any less miserable than a shivering thin one.

Thoughts???
 
On this subject, I don't personally see the difference between sticking a fat person naked in the rain to shiver the weight off, and a clipped horse. Neither has any of the protection Nature designed for them against the elements, other than an insulating layer of fat. I don't want this to kick off again, it just wouldn't be my weight loss method of choice - human or equine!
 
I'm certainly not trying to start an argument!!! I just think the science behind the 'horses don't experience shivering as uncomfortable' makes no sense. But I'm no vet, so perhaps someone can enlighten me!
 
Incdientally, as far as I know no-one on NR has done or intends to do this - ie let horse be cold enough to shiver. So this is NOT a dig at anyone. But I know someone on my yard who did and was adamant the horse was fine with it. Horse did lose the weight though.
 
Don't feed them in winter and they will use the fat up keeping warm, but not shivering it off.

I won't feed ours until January, if they need it, if they just need to move to a park with a bit mroe grass that's what will happen. Modern horse keeping these days seesm that folk feel the need to feed the horse no matter what or they are falling short of good horse care.

Good horse care means treating each horse appropriately, and a "handfull of happy hoof and such and such" is too much and totally unnecessary and then they wonder why they have a fat horse.

We have fat horses in June, July, August going into September. (Fatter than really fit) Come spring we will have them on the lean side, not thin.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sjp1
I have often in the past said that I would let one of my good doers 'shiver' some weight off coming into winter. This is not a term I have ever used or meant in the literal sense.

To me letting a overweight horse shiver some weight off, generally means either a trace or chaser type clip - that is leaving the withers, back and loins well covered with their natural protection (i.e their hair!) and NOT putting a rug on them to compensate for this partial clipping. Without fail it has always helped them to shift the unwanted late summer weight, never seen one of them actually shiver, and any rain still runs naturally of the gulleys of the puffed up winter coat hair on their backs.

Fat pads will still burn off a horse, without it actually visibly shivering and shaking, to allow them to go that far with their attempt to remain warm is cruel and unnecessary IMO.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CMP
I don't clip Ziggy or rug him. I have only seen him shiver once, at the end of May when he was just in his full summer coat and we had a highly unseasonal and very, very cold hailstorm. He was soaked, bruised on his withers from the hailstorm, and shivering from nose to tail. I whipped him into the shelter and fed him hay and after half an hour or so he stopped shivering.

I have no doubt that he was in great discomfort while the shivering was happening and I certainly wouldn't want him to shiver regularly. However, like Wally, I won't be feeding him masses of hard feed over the winter - I want to be able to see the shape of ribs and hip bones come March, and although he's quite trim for him at this time of year we have a long way to go!
 
I think we are all slightly missing the point. Yes a horse who is shivering may well find it uncomfortable, maybe being ridden is a tad uncomfortable for them and nature certainly didn't make them evolve to carry a predator upon their backs, maybe being confined to a stable for 12 hours a day or more is uncomfortable, maybe being kept in a single paddock without access to wander over vast areas/different terrain is uncomfortable for them too, we do an awful lot with our horses that nature hasn't really designed them for but it doesn't stop us doing it. I'm not saying we should all make our tubbies shiver off the fat but you kind of get my drift?
 
I do sometimes wonder how literal vets are being when they say that! As lots of people I think use the phrase non-literally, like Cortrasna. But some people really do mean SHIVER! And also inexperienced owners may well take a vet literally even if they vet just meant 'under-rug a bit'.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chrisnscully
I think we are all slightly missing the point. Yes a horse who is shivering may well find it uncomfortable, maybe being ridden is a tad uncomfortable for them and nature certainly didn't make them evolve to carry a predator upon their backs, maybe being confined to a stable for 12 hours a day or more is uncomfortable, maybe being kept in a single paddock without access to wander over vast areas/different terrain is uncomfortable for them too, we do an awful lot with our horses that nature hasn't really designed them for but it doesn't stop us doing it. I'm not saying we should all make our tubbies shiver off the fat but you kind of get my drift?

No, I agree - horses are basically our slaves! But you know a fat person would catch a chill if you stuck them outside in the cold and rain, so I would worry about that, not the biological effects of shivering so much as rain, hail, wind and snow against bare, non-waterproof skin. I should think it you left the top waterproof layer of hair on your horse it would probably be OK but sending it out completely stripped of protection in harsh weather seems a bit of a risky strategy.

To me it's quite simple really - if you want your horse to lose weight, keep them away from the all-you-can-eat buffet!
 
See my post on the other thread about how horses keep warm!

Over minus 9 (allowing for wet and wind chill) the horse doesn't even think it is cold.

Shivering is a short term method they use to regain heat - not a method of weight loss.

The term is, I think, used loosely to mean keeping a horse under rugged so that over a period of time it uses up its reserves of fat.

Burning fat and laying down muscle is something entirely different and the term overweight is also used loosely because muscle weighs heavier than fat and a fit horse can weigh MORE than an unfit horse with no excess fat!
 
Well my feelings in it are,clip,trace,bib etc and leave without rugs fine I get the logic behind it but I wouldn't take clipping any further. reduce calorie intake and/or up the exercise,much better way imo and experience and a far safer way to do it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chrisnscully
I always wonder how people can know just what a horse is thinking or feeling ! thats why I agree with what you have said OP "The next assertion made to me by the vet who recommended it is 'it won't do her any harm'. And 'horses don't feel the cold the way we do'. To the first part of that: Not causing harm is not the same as not causing discomfort/distress. To the second part: how does anyone know?"

we cannot know, therefore I would rather not put my horse into that situation in the first Place. There is just no need when I could simply up the exercise or do target exercises.
 
Yup. Till at least the mid 1980's. And even my new-born son had repeated bloods taken by an incompetent student who couldn;t find a vein. It took AGES of repeatedly sticking a needle in him. When I eventually protested I was told 'it's okay he won;t remember'....

From Wikipdedia: Do Babies Feel Pain
Late 19th Century[edit]

In the late nineteenth, and first half of the twentieth century, doctors were taught that babies did not experience pain, and were treating their young patients accordingly. From needle sticks to tonsillectomies to heart operations were done with no anaesthesia oranalgesia, other than muscle relaxation for the surgery.[citation needed] The belief was that in babies the expression of pain was reflexive and, owing to the immaturity of the infant brain, the pain could not really matter.[34]

Cope[32] considers it probable that the belief arose from misinterpretation of discoveries made in the new science of embryology. Dr Paul Flechsig equated the non-myelinisation of much of a baby’s nervous system with an inability to function.[citation needed]

It was generally believed that babies would not remember any pain that they happened to feel, and that lack of conscious memory meant lack of long-term harm. Scientific studies on animals with various brain lesions were interpreted as supporting the idea that the responses seen in babies were merely spinal reflexes. Furthermore, the whole effort of relieving pain was considered futile since it was thought to be impossible to measure the child's pain.[35]

This, coupled with a concern that use of opiates would lead to addiction, and the time and effort needed to provide adequate analgesia to the newborn, contributed to the medical profession's continued practice of not providing pain relief for babies.[36]

Mid 1980s[edit]
In the United States, a major change in practice was brought about by events surrounding one operation. Infant Jeffrey Lawson underwent open heart surgery in 1985. His mother, Jill R. Lawson, subsequently discovered that he had been operated on without any anaesthesia, other than a muscle relaxant. She started a vigorous awareness campaign[37] which created such a public, and medical, reaction that by 1987[38] medical opinion had come full circle.

A number of studies on the measurement of pain in young children, and on ways of reducing the injury response began,[which?] and publications on the hormonal and metabolic responses of babies to pain stimuli began to appear, confirming that the provision of adequate anaesthesia and analgesia was better medicine on both humanitarian and physiological grounds.[citation needed]

It is now accepted that the neonate responds more extensively to pain than the adult does, and that exposure to severe pain, without adequate treatment, can have long-term consequences. Despite the difficulty of assessing how much pain a baby is experiencing, and the practical problem of prescribing the correct dosage or technique for treatment, modern medicine is firmly committed to improving the quality of pain relief for the very young.[34]
 
Well, I would either not clip and leave unrugged or clip and rug if I had a fat horse.

I think it unreasonable to clip and leave unrugged and out in all weathers - I would far rather find rougher grazing or a track system yard where they don't have the quality of grazing turnout. I am however a great advocate of turn out, and the other day a fellow livery said to me at 6.30am 'do you think we should turn them out' It was raining and windy, but I do rug because the natural shelter is not great and Tobes grows a fine coat - he is an appaloosa, therefore bred for high plains, rather than the mud pits of a claysoil!

Our vets (equine) do not advocate clipping and turning out, and the partner I use is certainly not a fuss pot.
I think there was also a study done on girls who wore cropped tops and low jeans - I believe they actually gained inches/fat in those areas because they were cold, and nature compensated!!! Clearly not a good look!
 
I think it's like cortrasna says, we use the phrase, but we don't mean it literally.
And I acknowledge what kite rider is saying about us generally keeping horses in a manner which is against how nature intended, but I have some personal limits which I won't go past, and I try to keep my boy in as natural a manner as I can.
I believe in trying to mimic as much, the natural weight change a horse experiences throughout the year. He eats more in summer and I expect him to put on, within reason, and then I cut it down in winter so he loses the excess and uses his fat stores to keep warm. This works fine for us. I wouldn't want him shivering, and I don't feel that I need to go to that length.
 
  • Like
Reactions: newforest and Gimp
newrider.com