Safe - what does it mean to you?

carthorse

Super Moderator
Jan 6, 2006
13,806
8,553
113
After 15 months off Little Un is just coming back into work & boy is he on a roll, with that walk I must remember to put a proper sports bra on tomorrow! Anyway I passed a friend who hasn't seen him ridden before & she commented that she was surprised at how active & forward he was when I'd always said he was such a safe & easy ride. I fail to see the connection, I never said he was lazy, unresponsive or dull! He is totally safe - stops to a voice aid, light rein aid at worst, isn't spooky, never bucks, rears or naps, will go first or last & stands like a rock if another horse takes off (God knows Jim's tested that enough times). He's been ridden by tiny kids & total beginners, but put a rider on him & he'll strut his stuff & merrily whizz around. In short he's a welsh cob lol! Even when he prances & dances, stamps his feet & squeaks, if you're sat on him you feel completely safe & are probably at more risk of falling off from laughing than because he's done anything & if the behaviour is inappropriate a tap on the neck & firm "no" puts paid to it.

So do you think a safe pony has to be a quiet plod? Would you automatically assume that's what someone meant if they said a pony was safe? That if it was obedient but forward that it shouldn't be described as safe?

Obviously no pony is 100% safe, I do appreciate they're all living thinking beings.
 
I agree, safe doesn't necessarily have to mean a plod at all. It's perfectly possible to be forward going and 'bombproof' - just less common I suppose!
 
I've sometimes found that the very switched off types that people describe as safe are actually a nightmare if they do get lit up or scared. They stay switched off to the rider & it seems that because they've never really gone forwards no-one's ever taught them to stop or contain their energy!
 
No I don't equate safe with slow/ploddy/switched-off. For me a "safe" horse is one who is level-headed and whose behaviour is, by and large, fairly predictable. Of course no horse is truly predictable but you know what I mean, a horse who can usually be relied on to behave in a certain way. Though that's not to say they are always impeccably behaved!
 
I've sometimes found that the very switched off types that people describe as safe are actually a nightmare if they do get lit up or scared. They stay switched off to the rider & it seems that because they've never really gone forwards no-one's ever taught them to stop or contain their energy!
You are right - it's safer to have a responsive horse that listens to your commands and goes off your leg than one that plods along ignoring you, cos it's going to carry on ignoring you when the sh*t hits the fan!
 
Exactly what joosie said. Too me jess is totally safe I never feel worried on her but being very switched on I wouldn't say she is suitable for a novice either, tense your bum muscles and she's off!
 
I class my Storm as safe. She is wick and full of beans with me if I ask, eg, if we are doing some tiny jumps or a fast session with obstacles in the arena - personally I love her frisky full of beans mode!lol but, she is wonderful and kind if you aren't in the mood and as she's matured she is very in tune and knows what her job is on any particular day. OH rode her bareback yesterday and she was such a good lass. He only wanted a little plod (it was his birthday) and she behaved impeccably. Such a good calm girl. If you ask she will give, but equally she will be quiet if required. Years ago when I was on a yard folk used to think she only had wick silly mode and didn't realise it was because I was asking for it (granted not all the time mind!!!). I would certainly trust her to carry just about anyone safely. But that doesn't mean she's boring, dull or switched off.
 
I've sometimes found that the very switched off types that people describe as safe are actually a nightmare if they do get lit up or scared. They stay switched off to the rider & it seems that because they've never really gone forwards no-one's ever taught them to stop or contain their energy!

I think this too. I often wonder what would happen with Chloe if she was a rideable (she isn't) but, she's very calm, laid back and does not spook easily. But, I often wonder what she might be like if she did get spooked! Probably be like a tank......
 
Well there may be some link, I think.
Horses want to survive till tomorrow and 2 things are therefore important to all of them: getting away from things that might eat them, and conserving enough energy to be able to get away from things that might eat them. How important each of these instincts is seems to vary from horses to horse with some horses and breed types being 'hotter' - more worried about getting away; and some being 'colder' - more worried about energy conservation . So most 'laziness' is just self preservation: why expend energy you might need running away on doing something unimportant like trotting round in circles! Colder types are less reactive and therefore safer. And also therefore more likely to need persuading to work! Having said that, a well schooled horse of either type needs to overcome their natural instincts and so hot horses can learn to be calm, and cold ones learn to be responsive. Thyme was 'cold'. Charlie was 'hot'. Both were very light and responsive.
 
Last edited:
Mine is safe as houses....for me. Other folk, not so much. Because I know him, I know he's stoppable, I know his high head carriage is just him having a gander at whatever is passing by. I know him inside out. I thought he was becoming safer, but then my sister got on him a few weeks back and she chose to take ejector seat action. Safe to me, is just predictable. Whether that be predictable in always spooking at something, always wanting to nap home, or whatever. I like that. I like knowing what to expect, but I guess I always laugh when he does something uncharacteristic as that spices things up a bit!
 
No I definitely don't think a ploddy slow type is necessarily safe at all, often the very slow ploddy sorts have strong necks and are dead to the aids with not enough schooling, so if they do find something hugely scary and decide to tank off with you they will neither listen nor respond as they simply don't really know how to. Also if someone inexperienced rides them and finds them difficult to get going they do tend to think that means they are a safe ride. Sometimes it does but quite often it means no such thing.

I like something that will step out smartly when asked to and will respond immediately I ask for something. I would have said Dolly was OK for a novice until I did quite a bit of hacking XC with her this summer, now I am not so sure. She can be quite spirited and fast when she is really having fun and I am not sure a novice would feel too safe with that. But I felt safe on her as I know her so well now,and I do know she seems to have some good schooling under her belt and will usually do as I ask when first asked.

It is amazing though how some people make stereotypical judgements about a horse or pony when they have never even sat on it, isn't it?:p
 
I think its the chicken and the egg. What you feel is safe someone else wouldn't.
What you feel is spirited, someone would say normal. Forward isn't necessarily safe or unsafe, plod isn't necessarily safe either. A lot of it is the confidence of the rider.

Though you do see adverts that say quiet plod ideal nervous rider. If you talk to a nervous rider they usually feel they want a "kick along" and something forward and responsive would be too much horse.

To me a safe horse is one I can take anywhere and regardless of how forward they are or not, you have fun knowing nothing is going to phase them. A schoolmaster/mistress. My friends 16.1hh IDx was just that lady. I hunted her, I did xc, she gave me confidence. She nannied youngsters. Her type I believe is hens teeth.

I think mine is in the middle somewhere she isn't a total plod, is a little behind the leg but she is responsive to voice and seat. Though if she's not listening you are in trouble though and may as well be talking Spanish!
I don't want to be stereo typical but she is a cob with strong opinion's. If you are on board when she shares them, you either feel safe when she does it, or you would say not novice. I think because she is green and young I wouldn't say safe, but has potential. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna
newrider.com