More weight in one stirrup
One thing I have noticed is that I'm very one sided and while I sit as straight as possible; I can definitely tell that I have more weight in one stirrup then the other. I know I'm doing it but I don't know how to correct it, any thoughts or anyone suffer something similar?
I have not followed this whole RS thread, but I am myself a very one sided crooked RS rider. Here are some observations - some of which come from my current RI. This will be a long post.
First -she says that every rider and every horse is to some extent crooked. I even have a Pippa Funnel DVD on which she explains her own tendency on a particular horse. Riding is great for your health but it isn't a magic wand that can give us perfect bodies, and being one sided shouldn't be an obstacle to enjoying yourself riding. So first rule is not to worry.
Next, a lot depends on the horse - if you are riding a RS horse that is too wide for you or has a broad flat back, you will naturally tend to sit on it with one of your knees farther forward than the other. Think of it like this - it is easier to take a long stride forwards than to take a long step sideways, so our bodies get comfy on "too wide" horses by setting one leg farther forward. This will affect the weight you have down one leg.
Next a lot depends on the RI. My first RI shouted at me and blamed me which was useless as it was not my fault. I then came to my present RI who is used to helping RDA, knowledgeable about Pilates and Alexander technique and Sally Swift's method, Centred Riding. She told me that if one's crookedness was too bad to remedy, the answer was to ride with one stirrup longer than another - this hasn't proved necessary, but for some people it is a solution.
With me, I make sure I have matching stirrup leathers and both stirrups in the same hole. I look very crooked to start with (to RIs who don't know me) but my body seems to straighten out as we ride.
If this problem worries you and you cant sort it out on your own, I would suggest getting a specialist lunge lesson with a teacher who can help you knowledgeably as my RI did. We are able to ride bareback too on the lunge - which reveals exactly how crooked you are and helps you centre yourself - otherwise you would fall off.
Now we come to you the rider. The first thing is to forget your feet and legs and to concentrate on your seat in the saddle. Are you sitting central on the horse? I am usually not. I am usually sitting slightly to the right hand side.
But the real question is why? In my case we discovered that my left hip tends to hurt, so my body naturally adjusts to put more weight on my right seat bone and on my right leg when I rise in trot. It is useless a new RI telling me to rise with more weight on the left foot, since I was in pain and next day was agony. So try to find out why you are crooked and be careful what solutions you adopt -You cant ride well if you are in constant pain.
Things that do work for me -
1. Feeling the horse's movement equally through both of my seat bones. I have learned to ride concentrating on the footfall of the horse, feeling through my seat where the horse moves its hind legs, counting the paces, breathing and relaxing. I am notorious for riding with my girth too loose - my balance on the saddle now comes from my seat - helped by riding bareback.
2. That still leaves the problems of corners and circles when it is hard for the horse to go to the left if my weight is to the right. You don't say which of your feet is heavier in the stirrup? But if your left foot is lighter, my best solution is to distance the left knee from the right shoulder. Imagine an elastic between them and stretch it.
Another exercise we do when doing lateral work (bends) to the weak side, is to take the lighter foot out of the stirrup. That increases the weight on your weak side without stiffening the leg.
Just holding that shoulder back and keeping your head central on the horse, may help with the weight in the stirrups problem. What ever you so, do not push down on the stirrup - your feet and ankles need to be soft . Don't try to press your heels down either. Because (unless you have an injury leaving one leg lighter or longer than the other) the problem is likely to originate higher up.
Experiment to find the cause of your problem and then a solution. Keep an eye on your saddle as you ride and if you accidentally push it off centre, straighten it by rising in the stirrups and pushing down with one foot - or as your RI did by tightening the girth. Riding Western particularly one needs to keep an eye on the saddle and it isn't the end of the world.
And don't forget the solution that works for you, or a combination of them. You need to remember and have the confidence to explain to new RIs. I know it is easy, after years of riding to let it slip my mind and I forget to distance my shoulder from my knee. Worse probably than I was nine years ago - because we don't get any younger.
But the problem is manageable, and shouldn't make you miserable. Many of us have dealt with the same thing.