Question about space.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Horses evolved as 'trickle feeders' - grazing animals who roamed vast acreages of land every day and night to eat for 18 hours every day. How do you expect a horse to do this in a poxy 1/4 of an acre of land? That's smaller than my back garden, and I wouldn't even entertain the thought of keeping a horse on that.

As has already been pointed out, why ask for advice when you are obviously going to ignore everyone who doesn't sit up and say "Now that's a good idea!". If a 1/4 of an acre was sufficient land to support a pony, every Tom, **** and Harry would have a little naglet roaming around their back garden. I keep my two small horses (15hh, only just horses!) on 8 acres which I rotate throughout the year and still it gets boggy and I have to supplement them with hay every day.

You need to be realistic here. If you cannot have the animals, not your, best interests at heart then you are obviously not cut out to be a horse owner.
 
oh i never thought about laws. we dont have one where we are but it doesnt matter much either because there is so much land everyone has their horses in large area's but i know of places that have 1 acre laws and horses can be taken away if they dont have adequate land.
obviously you really arn't taking any of our advice but i would advice you to make sure you dont have laws in your area about this. rescues really are way to full to take on another horse that shouldn't have been in a bad situation first off.

edited: have you thought about sharing? i know what its like to not have any barns near you. we have one now close to us, very backyardy but before them the closest place to keep a horse was over and hour from us, i had to go over an hour for my lessons. pain in the butt definatly. tahoe has gone through fences before when we tried to seperate him. he absolutly doesn't care about the electricity he just runs straight through or jumps anything to be with other horses he gets so stressed out.
 
Last edited:
Having a horse means you have to be prepared, with only one small plot of land, no stable/shelter and no livery yards near you - just what are you going to do when the unexpected happens? What if the new horse you get doesn't like being kept on its own, mauls itself on the fence trying to get out to other horses and needs box rest or to be kept in over night?

No matter how small the pony, even 1/2 an acre of land will eventually get poached. 1/4 acre is tiny for any size of horse. Where will you work with it? Any lunging or schooling will have to be done on that liittle plot I assume which will tear it up even more.

My horse was kept on her own for 2years, yes unfortunately she copes very well with living on her own now, I am sure however that this was not always the case and most of the issues she had when I bought her were related to this. It took two years to re-integrate her into a herd. She would be a danger to other horses if she didn't know them which means she can't be moved or stabled in new places without preparation.

You would possibly be buying a good horse and creating problems for it for the future. If you had land and funds enough to keep it forever fine, but with only a 1/4 acre, thats a very temporary situation.

Our starvation paddock at the yard is 1/4 acre, used for overweight, lame or sick horses that can't move around!
 
Its very selfish to buy a horse when you know full well you have no way of looking after it properly. Its fair enough being able to afford to buy a horse but the reality in affording to buy a horse includes providing it with a suitable home etc. This is the sort of thing that leads to an unhappy misbehaving horse, its just not fair on the poor animal!
 
Goodness me! I have to agree with the others here.

I would give it two months before you had a very bored, lonely pony standing in a quarter of an acre of mud. The abscesses, mud fever and lost shoes alone would make life incredibly difficult for the owner, never mind the poor animal.

Forgive me for saying this but you sound very young in the way that you don't seem to be listening to the advice in an adult manner, more like a child who is pestering for a pony against their parents judgements.

If I was selling a pony I would not allow it to come to your home and you have to remember that most sellers will want to see where their pony is going.

I'm sorry, it really does seem that you will have to accept that you are not able to provide a good home for a pony.
 
in my personal opinion (and experience) a horse does well, even if he isn't kept to textbook regulations.


Are you kidding me here? I'm not an idiot- if you have personal experience on keeping horses on tiny little scraps of land like a quarter acre,w hy would you ask if it can be done?

A horse needs land. This is NOT a textbook regulation. This is a right as a large animal- a RIGHT. If it were not natural, then why the heck would they be living in herd lands of over 100 acres in the wild? Hmm? What, because they feel it's fashionable to have land?

No.

Horses need land. They are an animal that needs almost perpetual motion if they are to digest their food, keep their hooves in order, and keep from getting insanely bored. They can't spin around on 1/4 acre and stay calm and fit. They will get unfit from a lack of movement, stir crazy from being confined, and don't even question how bored they would get. Some epople stable their horses for show purposes or safety purposes. But guess what? The rest of us like land.

If this is anything to compare yourself by, in the future I plan on owning over 100 acres- wild horses can travel over *150* acres per day in the wild. I intend to have the ones not being used in a 60 acre + area, and the other horses on the rest. Simply because having them on more would be problematic to catch, but I want them in a large, herd-like lifestyle. That's that. And it will be done, because if I can't get it, I'm not going to do the crap tiny parcel of land.




I will also of course try and rent a field, but if i can't, then the one i have will have to do. i've kept ponies on small plots before and they have thrived. not forgetting i MAY have a shelter built (depending on whether or not I can get planning permission) so more than likely the horse will be in at night.

If you can't get at least another 4 and 3/4 acres of land and two horses, you are not meant to have horses on that land.

The land you have is NOT going to do- at all! :mad:

Stop asking for opinions if you aren't going to listen to them. Why did you ask if you are going to do it anyway- even after being told by *EVERYONE* in this thread it is not going to be a good thing for this pony? And what the heck is the purpose of a shelter if it's going to take up a furtherly large portion of the land? Keeping the horse in a backyard sized piece of land and then locking it up into a box at night is even worse.


Neglecting to heed 100% agreement in advice, when contemplating doing something very stupid and unkind, is basically a very aware form of neglect. You are neglecting the fact that a horse needs space, movement, and an environment to mirror nature. Horses are not meant to be kept alone- they will lose herd knowledge and horse temperment.



I can garantee that even in a term of 6-12 months you will ruin whatever equine you decide to buy if you keep it cramped and alone. Heck, you might ruin a horse/pony in a MONTH, depending on the mental state of the animal.


What's more is that you are ignoring everything we say and are trying to quip with ways to get around the issue without facing the facts that you were hoping wouldn't be there- you are acting like a preteenage brat who won't settle for the facts that the land you have and the knowledge of that area is not enough. Regardless of your age, it's time to start absorbing information instead of only listening to what you want to hear. On this note, go re-read this whole thread, and pay attention to how you sound in your posts. Jesus, insert a simple "Oh, and there might be times where I'm going away for school trips, and my parents aren't horse people, so, you know, I'll just load up a manger full of grain and a tub of water, the pony will be fine when I get back." and you've got neglect bordering on abuse. (In my opinion, others may not see it that way)

This is an extreme act of selfishness. You don't just take something you want to have even if you aren't prepared to take care of it. That's greed and a lack of feeling and understanding towards the creature.


Mods- I know I sounded like a very large obscene cow. But this kind of thing is not one I can play nice about.
 
Last edited:
uk law is also strict about where and how you can keep horses. If you have any neighbours next door to you whatsoever then you have to obtain their written permission plus also the muck has to be removed so as you do not keep manure there. You are not allowed to burn it so you have to pay to have it removed which is very expensive. Another thing you mention is that you have gravel.This is not suitable for horses feet and has been known to cause lameness.
 
Esther.D said:
The poster referring to a 'backyard' is from the US, over there their backyards are not like our backyards (ie a small concreted yard like we have behind terraced houses) they are referring to small plots of land.

Yes, do not take offence at the term backyard. I keep my horses in what we call our backyard- 8 acres of it, as we live in what we call the country- no neighbors within at least a quarter mile. Here in the US, a backyard can be a strip of concrete, or it can be many acres. It just has to be in back of the house to qualify as a back yard, and generally is fenced in. Unfenced 'yards' with a lot of property are referred to as "the back forty", or "our acreage" :)
 
IrishDQ, why have you bothered to ask the question if you are going to argue with the kind people who take time to answer? I'm not ranting but you should take peoples advice, this sounds like no way for a horse to live.
 
Yes, here in the land of.. land, backyards can be huge- a farmer with over 500 acres can call that land his back yard if it's behind his house.
 
Im agreeing with the others, your asking for trouble if you put a horse on that much land. My horses (i have 2) are on 3 acres, they live out all year round. They have company yet i can easily take a pic of our field. My horses in places are knee deep in mud. Its not going to recover this summer its that bad. From this experience im quick to shout out that 3 acres isnt enough for 2 horses to live out all year round. Were feeding haylage everyday too.

Its horrible, the state of our field. Yours will be 12 times worse than ours after 6 months of a horse living on it. Plus it will possibly be even worse, one of my horses broke her pedal bone and we tried to put her in a small paddock - 20 x 40m grass paddock. She paced and paced because she was on her own. Her friends were only the other side of the electric fencing too, so just imagine how your horse would feel with no equine contact at all. Being stripped from all he knows, no sleep because he'll feel its not safe too.
On holiday i 'adopted' a little pony, along with the help from punkrockpony on here. While we were there, he went and laid down and had a sleep. He was that tired from not having any equine contact to protect him while he slept he was happy to use strangers to look out for him. Now i cant say what PRP thought because i dont know, but that poor pony really would love another pony. He would feel a hell lot safer.

Think my neighbours garden is about 1/4 of an acre. Their daughter craves a pony but they wont buy one and keep it on their back garden because they know about horses, they understand horses need companions and they also understand it would be cruelty to the horse and the RSPCA would be called. - So their daughter will not get a pony.

I think, until you can get somewhere with at least 3 acres of land, or be horse-enough to put a horse in livery, you should hold off getting one. Weve paid up to £90ish per WEEK just to make sure my horse is well cared for.

You would buy a nice, well mannered, no viced horse and most likely end up selling it as a mad nutter with tonnes of vices. Sorry, but the poor horse would have gone totally crazy from the lack of equine contact. I dont care how you YOU will spend with it, YOU are not an equine. Horses prefer horses to humans. They can interact, groom each other, watch over each other while they sleep. Do you have 4 hooves, a tail and go neigh? If not, your not a suitable companion! :p
 
i tend to agree with just.jump on that subject, u may as well just throw your horse in a stable and leave it there day in day out if u just gonna leave it in 1/4 acre of land all the time!
 
GO JUST.JUMP!!! WOOT WOOT!:D

Oh, just a tiny weeny conformation, i don't fall into the pre-teenage brat catagory do I??? I would never even dream of owning a horse if i was as ignorant as IrishDQ or had that much land.

To be honest i don't know why you want to keep a horse IrishDQ, if you are this ignorant before you buy then i can't imagine what will happen 6 weeks down the line when you say to yourself, 'oh this is boring, i know! I'll try golf instead'.
 
Thank you, Enthusiast- I let some of my snarl out in that one. And no, your good to go in the mature division of NR members.

I agree- at this point, IrishDQ, you aren't ready to contemplate owning a horse.

To sound like a priss, you know your mentally ready for a horse when your willing to wait a very long time just to get the right conditions. For example, I myself am willing to wait the possible ten years that it will take (if I get on of my chosen careers- 8 years of uni or possibly more, making it a 12 or more year wait) to get money for a horse- in my grad degree I will probably not be working, therefor I will have no constant income to fund a horse, and most of my savings will be going to university so I don't have to live at home.

Oh, and that brings up another example: I don't want to live at home for university. Why? Because I don't want the inconvenience of being cramped into a bedroom for my privacy and quiet. I need the SPACE of libraries and halls should I require it. I need the SPACE to get away from any distractions or noisy people. Meaning that I cannot be cramped into my bedroom with my moms tv program blaring down in the living room. (quite obviously I won't be sharing a double room). Crap analogy, but one none the less.

and Rianne, I'm liking you more and more =P
 
Well Just.Jump, your showing all us up with your snarl! ;) Must say, your point was flown over the atlantic pretty well! Must say, IrishDQ has brightened up my evening considerably, has given me abit of a laugh ... thinking someone could seriously keep a horse on that amount of land and not expect the land to get chewed up beyond repair and the horse being normal with no equine contact!
Sorry IrishDQ, but if you seriously have kept ponies on that sized land before then its worrying. Surely if you knew horses you'd understand they need equine contact and space to let off steam. How many horses do you think would be happy galloping in a vegetable patch? - Thats what id say 1/4 of an acre is useful for. Grow vegetables, use it for good, dont ruin a horses life just to make yourself look selfish.
 
Glad it got across- lets hope it doesn't fly over IDQ's head this time. (I must say, you've got a lovely set of horses there- what are PAddy and Bertha's breeds?)
 
Paddys an Irish cob and Berthas just a cob. Shes an extraheavy weight version too!! May only be 15.1hh, but her saddle was specially made to fit a Suffolk Punch! :eek:
 
Wow, I got the impression that they were both quite tall- they look great =D I love Irish Draughts.. great substance in a very pleasing package. I'll always admire the draght breeds and crosses :)
 
Long reply

Please everyone be mature & diplomatic alright?

I agree with pretty much what everyone has replied on this thread. One must be sensible when deciding to take on a living being.

On three seperate occasions I've had a horse living on its own but that was only for a few months until I could find it a pasture mate (horse). During those times, these lone horses were very lonely and everytime they'd hear my voice, they would whinny & wait expectantly as close to the source of the voice hoping that I would go & interact with them. One of these horses would pace the fence line constantly.

Mind you, some horses do adapt to living alone but it's not natural & it's not fair.

1/4 acre, unless it's a long strip (instead of a square) is not adequate for a horse to fully spread out at a gallop, trot around or just have a good romp. (Horses like to do that)

My 2 mares have access to 3 acres and I've devided them in 3 long strips so that they can move in a straight line instead of several short distances. And even then, it really isn't long enough.

The turnout paddock they are in right now is 84' X 194' and it's done! It needs leveling & reseeding and at least a season to recuperate. And as of last summer, I now have access to another 3 acres down 1/2km, at a neighbour's place. This summer we may be dividing it into 3 - 1 acre plots so we can rotate but they really enjoy galloping around the full 3 acres.

Horses can live without grazing per se, so adequate amounts of good quality hay is fine but where will this hay be stored? When it's really muddy the hay will get worked into the ground unfortunatly. Feeding off hay nets all the time is not natural as many here have mentioned. And there are a few more reasons why a horse needs to have its head down that I wontgo into right now.

Here in Canada it is the law that a horse must have a shelter that conforms to it's climate/weather. Example: a bush or tree wall for my area is not acceptable because we get lots of prevailing winds, scorching heat & sun as well as a lot of rain/ice rain. Therefore my area's law dictates that I must have at least a three sided shelter with a roof.

It also states that a horse cannot be kept in a backyard of one acre because the well, septic and water runoffs (ditch) will get contaminated & probably damaged. There is also a law about the amount of square footage allowed per animal regarding the dung.

You will have to pick out the horses dung daily & have it removed off the property quite frequently.

I don't know anything about the laws in your country but I would certainly look into it before making a decision.

Excercise: where will this horse/pony be excercised? Unless there is access to trails, doing this in its little 1/4 plot is going to be mentally taxing on it because it gets the same scenery day in/day out.

Many horses get sour from being excercised in a manège 20m X 40m (66' X 132'). As well many vices occur when a horse is confined to a small area such as pacing & weaving or self mutilation (biting itself).

All I can say is: unless the horse is a mini (Falabella); the living conditions that are being offered to this horse/pony are not in it's best interest.

You asked a question seeking the opinions of horse people from all over the globe, who are all at different stages in their experience with horses and you've recieved a unanimous answer. Honestly: one cannot say that the world is wrong and one person is right?

Good luck & I hope you make the right decision.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
newrider.com