I have a semi private lesson every week, which I've found are the best. In a private lesson, it's alot more intense. The instructor is always watching you and nudging you on (which can be frustrating) and can really tire you out.
My semi-private lesson is with one other girl who is less advanced than I am, but on a school master horse, while I'm on a green one. This way we're at approximately the same level ridingwise.my instructor watches me like a hawk for awhile working on a movement and tells me what she wants me to do for the next few minutes, then she focuses on the other girl and switches back and forth. I love the chance of being able to take a break, or work on something that was troubling me earlier while she's focusing on the other rider.
If for any reason you have difficulties in the group environment, my instructor is also willing to split the lesson in two and give each of the riders a half hour private lesson rather than an hour long semi-private.
It's only a little more expensive than a group lesson, and you get alot more instruction without the sheer intensity of a full hour long private lesson. My riding has improved tons.