yes, the saddle is a bit forward here...I was just lunging with the saddle loose and it settles back a bit (about 2 inches or so) and then I tighten it up to ride. That's how both trainers have shown me how to do it....they said I had it too far back. I had originally learned with an english saddle and was placing it that way, but western saddles do go more over the withers..but he has plenty of room to move his shoulder in the saddle and elbow with the girth. I do know that you are supposed to keep your saddle seat level, and there seems to be no way to do that on his round little body. I tried again today to see. I can say I don't have to cinch very tight for the saddle to stay on, and he can go really crazy fast and it still holds tight and doesn't really shift at all. That's a good sign isn't it? I have my eye set on the wintec all purpose pony saddle. I saw it in person and it was so soft and squishy it made me feel guilty going home and putting my hard ol' saddle on him.