PLZ READ! and learn from my mistake!

Oh, ack, horrible.

It's so hard to know who's a knowledgeable professional. When you need a service that you haven't used before, or you need to change (moving to a new location, previous specialist retiring or moving, etc) and you have to call on someone new...there's just no way to know if they're any good.

All I know to do is go by other people's recommendations (vets typically do not make recommendations for insurance reasons). Sadly, other people aren't the best judges of a professional--most owners just don't know enough to know whether the person is doing a good job or not.

I'm so sorry about Cheque. Is he feeling all right?
 
That is terrible. It's especially awful as you let the person treat your horse because you trusted the pony club to choose the rtight person. It's terrible that that had to happen, and I can only imagine how awful it must have been both for you and your horse.
 
Oh that sounds horrible. To be honest I didn't get suspicious while reading your story either. I, too, would have thought I was dealing with a qualified equine dentist.
I didn't start to think twice about it until the subject of antibiotics came up. I would have assumed the dentist would have put him on antibiotics right away.

I am very sorry this has happened to the both of you.

What was your pony clubs response to this?
 
God how horrible! I really feel for you. I would have taken the oppportunity just as you have.

I would have thought the pony club could be trusted, I would in no way think you had let an "amatuer mess with your horse". You should complain to them and then follow that up by complaining to the dentist with your vets back up. The dentist was really in the wrong.
 
Hi

What an awful thing to happen. Please don't blame yourself though, how were you to know?

I would definitely pursue this both through the pony club and to his professional body.

DON'T, however, think that all dentists are bad. We have a great dentist who trained in the US who is great to the horses, he avoids taking teeth out if at all possible (except problematic wolf teeth) and will refer anything that he can't deal with to the vet (but he's not awfully happy about *some* vets doing dentistry!). He is happy to let us observe and will explain what he is doing as he is going along.

I hope that Cheque is ok, please let us know how he's getting along :)
 
I find that appalling that your Pony Club handled it that way. If they knew of his repuation and didn't tell any of you I would hold them responsible. The fact that no one is interested does not give a very good impression of your branch, it sounds to me as they don't care of the members, your horse has been injured, is off work and off his food and it could have endangered him a lot if it was more serious. The fact they gave it the brush off is awful, Im sure if it had been one of the commitee's horses it would have been a much different story.
 
GIMME THAT GUYS NUMBER!!! I'll re-educate him as best I can down the phone!! GRRRRRRRR! And while I'm in the mood for angry rants, gimme the name & number of your pony club's president!! That's so rude! They have an obligation to educate and care for it's riders and horses - and if this guy has a history of cruelty to animals, he should not be let anywhere near a Pony Club!! OOH! I'm so MAD!!

How is Cheque doing? Give him a slurp of molasses for me (carrots are gonna be abit hard, atm).

ps: I think you should contact the PC state coordinator & say this guy is not acceptable (send a copy of your vets letter).
 
What a horrifying experience, thank goodness no lasting damage has been done. Dentistry in particular is one discipline where we have to take the practitioners word for it.

Not long before I moved my current yard they had a husband and wife team (vet and dentist) come to treat the horses. From the sound of it they recommended power tool work and sedation for most of the horses and charged an absolute fortune, hundreds of pounds. In contrast I have an EDT with a good word of mouth reputation who comes every six months and charges £25 plus travel if it's just a rasp that's needed.
 
Ah...you may be hesitant to send the bill to the pony club, but they're only indirectly responsible (if that) for the vet visit.

The dentist is *directly* responsible for the vet visit. His incompetence made the vet visit necessary. Sending the vet bill to the dentist is perfectly reasonable.

I've had a somewhat similar kind of encounter; the people who built our fence completely neglected to nail in two of the boards. My dogs pushed the boards out and got loose. One of them came home with an injury--looked like maybe a rabbit or squirrel bite, all the way down to the bone in her foreleg.

I had a couple of exchanges with receptionist type people at the fence company, in which they tried to tell me that it wasn't negligence because they didn't do it intentionally. Well, duh! That's what negligence IS; it's failing to do something properly when you do in fact know how to do it right. I eventually sent a letter addressed directly to the president of the company, explaining that 1) I was VERY unhappy with the work that they had done, since it was faulty--I inspected it board by board and found several other boards that were not nailed on properly, 2) their faulty work had been responsible for injury to my dog, 3) the vet bill for that injury was in fact cheap, compared to the other possible injuries to two dogs running loose, and 4) if they reimbursed me for the vet bill, I was not planning to take the matter any further.

Implied in 4, but not specifically mentioned, is that there is a further to go, if they do not respond appropriately. If I'd had to sue them I'd have also sued for such things as emotional damage, a partial refund on the fence, not to mention court costs. (I didn't want to go through the effort of filing against them, so if I did, I was going to make it worth my time.)

I did recieve reimbursement for the vet bills (along with a long letter explaining that they would pay the vet bills but did not accept legal responsibility for the injury in the first place--which was fine, although if the injury had run into complications--infection, surgery, etc--they'd have been hearing from me again). Incidentally, the response that I received was courteous, and their politeness and willingness to reimburse me for my vet bill restored my good opinion of them.

Had I not received a response from that first letter, I was prepared to send one more. That one would outright state that if I did not receive satisfaction for my very reasonable request, then I *would* file suit, and suit would include much more than the vet bill. The next step after that would have been to actually file suit. I also would have called the local newspaper and TV news stations, to tell them about this company which did a shoddy job and negligently caused harm to my dogs.

I've been going on & on about this because a lot of times people don't realize that you CAN make someone step up and take financial responsibilty for damages they have caused you. Sometimes all it takes is a clearly written letter stating why you think they are at fault, and listing the charges you have incurred in the way of damages. You don't have to threaten, you don't have to be hysterical; being calm and rational will gain you much more. Sometimes it takes more--but a letter is very easy to send.

In your case, if you did have to take it to court, there's a lot more you could tack onto the suit. Loss of use of the horse while he recovers; emotional damage to you AND to everyone else who was there due to the incident; emotional damage to you while your horse is in recovery and isn't "himself"; loss of faith in the professionals that you need to perform work on your horse; damage to your horse in weight loss; damage in muscle loss...I mean, you can go on and on. If you can find a reasonable monetary value for soemthing, you can add it on. I am NOT saying that I condone frivolous lawsuits--but if you're in a position of trying to recover legitimate damages, and you are not getting success without a lawsuit, well...it may help to point out how much more expensive the lawsuit would be.

When it really is someone else's responsibility, you shouldn't have to be the one taking financial responsibility.
 
Although I totally agree with you, Gal, Aussie's just don't work that way. ;) If it were me, I'd do it 'cause I'm strong & stubborn, but most aussie's would just let it go.

But Kylie, I deffinately think, armed with that letter from your vet, you could easily get the bills paid for without too much fuss. And spread the word about that 'dentist'. Make sure everyone knows what a bad guy he is.
 
So don't equine dentists have to be qualified and\or registered in the UK? or did I miss reading the bit where he said he was qualified.

If there's a registry board then your complaint should be directed to them - but you should contact the person involved initially and give them the ability to reply to your complaint. If possible ask the vet who has had to provide subsequent care (and sounds like he doesn't agree with treatment) to be present at the meeting. As Galadriel says - don't threaten or be overly emotional - make yourself a list of what your complaints are and what you want the person to do about them. Re-read a couple of times with a cool head to make sure you aren't being unreasonable.

Although its a bit gruesome the actual pulling of the tooth isn't a reason for complaint, unless the vet can prove beyond doubt that it was healthy. Nor is the queasiness of people in the surrounds - you, the client choose where treatment takes place and so that factor shouldn't be part of the complaint. Yes they bleed a bit but there's not much pain involved as the equine tooth doesn't have a nerve like ours.
 
newrider.com