Please help me out

Katrin

New Member
Mar 24, 2000
19
0
0
Redditch, UK
Visit site
Dear all,

I've got a problem I've been thinking about for a while now, and the more I think about it, the more confused I become.

So, here goes: I started to ride in Germany, and, in all the years of riding there, was never either allowed or required to carry a crop. When I started riding in England, I was strongly advised to carry a crop and use it (!) because otherwise "the horse would muck me about and take the mickey". I've been very reluctant about using it, and when I did, I only tapped it on the horse's back, but it didn't make any difference. I've tried leg aids, but I don't yet know enough about dressage/riding that I can get through to the horse like that. I find it awful to have to use a crop (quite hard, too) and I feel really mean and inadequate when doing it (my riding teacher insists I do). On the other hand, I only have to use it once or twice at the v beginning of the lesson, and then he goes fine. The instructor expressed her surprise that "he goes so well with you riding him, normally he won't go forward at all". He's been a riding school horse for most of his life, and he's now 19 years old and waiting for retirement.

Please help, as I don't really want to have to use a crop, I know it's possible without, but he doesn't seem to "wake up" before I do use it.
I must be doing something wrong, mustn't I?

Katrin
 
Hi there.

Your not necessarily doing anything wrong. It may just depend on the horse you are riding.

I carry a whip around with me when I am riding and I didn't like using one at first but horses can be very determind if they don't want to do something.

My horse on occasions has basically taken me for a ride and you have to be in charge.

I'm not saying you should use a whip on a horse for no reason, but sometimes they are required.

Altough I carry a whip I only use it when it is really needed, and I only need to use it once and my horse responds.

Make sure though that you only use your whip when it is needed and not all the time.

I'm sorry I have not answered your question on not using whips but I do agree with them only when they are needed.
 
Katrin,

As I live in Spain and nobody uses a crop here either, I was quite reluctant using a crop, but you can see my posting "carrying a whip" and you can see that i use now the crop hitting my boot and not the horse, my mare does not wake up until she knows that I am carrying it but once she knows I have it she does behave very well, try using the crop on your boot and see how the horse goes, I do not like either to use the crop on the horse and if I do I just brush the skin without actually hitting him/her.

Mavi
 
I agree that sometimes you have to use the crop, but I am also relunctant to do so and usually I just do a tap on the rump. However, I also ride school horses and many times, as you said, you just have to get them going at first and then they are fine. What I like to do when I first get on is proceed at the walk on a looser rein just pressing my leg on the horse's side every couple of strides. Do a few turns and halts and then move to trot on a loose rein. Old horses or those used a lot need to get their muscles moving before they can work. So just trot fast and as forward as possible on a loose rein around the outside of the arena. When he's loosened up, then try to bring him back and slow the trot but keep it going forward. Many times, the use of crop isn't necessary or a tap on the rump will give enough motivation. Good Luck!
 
Hi

The thing to remember with old riding school horses is that they've had many many bad riders who have kicked them, pulled them about in the mouth that they have learned to switch off to a certain degree. When you get on, who isn't going to do the above to them, you need to let them know. Also if you don't get them listening to you at the start and they ride round half asleep then they are more likley to trip up and have an acciedent.

Think of it this way, you don't have to hit them hard but do make sure they're listening to you!

Good Luck,
:) :) :) :)
 
Hello

I had a similar problem in that I'm too soft to use a whip/crop hard enough for the horse to feel it. I ride a horse who is very good but switches off a bit in the school and needs reminding to listen to the rider. What my instructor did was to get me off the horse and use the whip on me!! Sounds bizarre but basically when she used it on me with the same strength I was using it on the horse and I couldn't even feel it! She then hit me on the thigh with the sort of force I should be using on the horse and it didn't hurt me but was a firm tap. This gave me a good idea of how much strength to use and also reassured me that I wasn't hurting the horse (which was my main worry). It's taken me a while to get over my fear that I was being cruel but the horse I ride now goes very well for me with only a very occasional tap to remind him that he should be listening to me. With him and I suspect with most horses, once they know you mean business they take you seriously and listen to your aids.

HOpe this helps

JCB
 
Thanks to all who have taken the trouble replying to my question. It's helped me a lot, but I'm still unhappy if I have to use a crop. However, at least I know now that it's not necessarily me ;)

Thanks again
Katrin
 
newrider.com