Pedal Bone Rotation & Barefoot

Bay Mare

www.maggieslaw.co.uk
Jun 21, 2004
9,972
0
0
In my jods!
www.geocities.com
My friends' horse has been diagnosed with a 5 degree pedal bone rotation. He has been intermittently lame for some time now and is now on box rest with a view to shoeing him in heart bar shoes when the vet is happy for him to start working again. I am assuming (though partly sceptical) that this is a correct diagnosis.

Can anyone on here tell me how a barefoot EP would approach this? I haven't seen him (though am hoping to go and have a look when I get some time) so can't comment myself and am not really experienced enough anyway to make a proper judgement.

Has anyone gone through this with their horse?

I've recommended barefoot to her but don't know enough myself to explain things to her. She's naturally more inclined to follow the vet's advice but I'm trying to get as much info and advice as I can for her. I've already posted on EE. I'm worried (a little knowledge is a dangerous thing :) ) that she's going to end up either with a field ornament or without a horse at all if she keeps on following conventional advice. Thankfully she's insured as she's had so many vets out and investigations done, he even went away to be checked out and nothing concrete ever came of it and now they've come up with this!

Ta x
 
I'm not an EP, just a total hoof anorak who spends far too much time reading, so could be talking rubbish but here's a few random things I can remember.

Pedal bone isn't really rotated as it's still at the end of the leg where it should be, it's the hoof capsule that has rotated relative to the pedal bone, caused by the attachment at the laminae being destroyed. Some farriers apparently try to leave the heels high to try to re-align the pedal bone, totally cr*p idea which doesn't work, new connection has to grow in from the top and leaving the heels high just causes more pressure at the tip of the pedal bone against the sole.

I think an EP would just do the usual trim, live sole plane etc, though some of the markers they trim to can be a bit more difficult in laminitis cases so some stuff comes down to experience. Pretty sure the toes get rolled more than usual to stop the old damage pulling on the new growth, there's a laminar wedge with healthy inner wall growing behind it so can take much more off the toe after the new healthy inner wall has had some time to grow in than you'd be able to take off a normal foot.

Very likely to need to use sole mate pads, think in some cases it's better to cut an area out of them around the end of the pedal bone so that they support the rest of the foot without putting pressure there. Can be left on for up to 72 hours at a time in bad cases.

Diet needs dealing with, get rid of all sugary stuff, molassed feed, carrots, rich grass etc.

If there's a digital pulse then keep the horse still (box rest), and for 3 days after the pulse is gone. After that movement is good, possibly with sole mates on, but don't force them to move, should be moving around without any bute as they may do more damage if they can't feel pain and know it's a good idea not to do too much.

Usually the new hoof will grow down properly attached to the laminae so effectively cure the rotation. Won't see concavity until the 'new' hoof has grown down quite far. There are some pics of horse with more rotation than 5 degrees that have been de-rotated at www.hoofrehab.com.
 
Last edited:
I think Melanie has said it all really, and given the best possible weblink to find good info.

My pony had quite bad laminitis a couple of years ago and was brought back to soundness with good hoof care and trimming. You need lots of patience as the new hoof grows down! The pony grows a good looking hoof then the next year grows an even better tighter one. My vet was rather unsure but is coming round to the barefoot view and even talking about taking the shoes off her little driving pony this winter.

Heartbars? I'm inclined to think that the hooves will never really heal if these go on. The pony might seem sound but the problem will not go away long term. Then I am no expert.
 
Gill said:
Heartbars? I'm inclined to think that the hooves will never really heal if these go on. The pony might seem sound but the problem will not go away long term. Then I am no expert.

Yes, that's what I was thinking and why I'm worried for her.

Oh, and, sorry, forgot to say that he isn't laminitic and hasn't had laminitis if that makes a difference to the treatment!
 
A friend of mine has a cob mare whose pedal bone rotated as a result of laminitis. Heartbars did make a huge difference to her; but she had over 12 degrees of rotation, and thin soles, so the shoes were used to relieve pressure on the sole which was causing a lot of discomfort. Leaving her barefoot made her very uncomfortable.

Her recovery was fairly slow; she had the shoes on until she stayed sound without, and then she went back to being barefoot again. Once barefoot she made faster progress.
 
All of the above :D but another way to explain the comparison is: if you look at the foot, the bearing/contact area is almost just the same to a heart bar shoe (round the wall and down the frog), so barefoot and heart bar will have similar effects BUT when you put a shoe on, using nails you put weak points into the hoof wall and open it to minor infections etc, where as barefoot, gives the nec. bearing area to encourage good growth without encouraging any other problems.

That is in very simple terms but it might help your friend understand enough to want to learn more ;) :D (and I'm not saying that anyone needs it explained in simple terms its just that sometimes we get all to technical about these things and can loose the point if we are not all up to speed on the goble-di-gook terms :p )

J x
 
my Bonnie has 5-7 degrees pedal bone rotation and NO way ON EARTH would i allow her to go barefoot. she's my second laminitic pony, and neither of them could bare to walk without shoes on. if your friend really does want to go barefoot then the kindest way to do things would be to put on heart bars until fully recovered then take it from there as chev's friend did. might be worth contacting the laminitis clinic about this aswell as they are the experts and can advise much better than most vets can.

Heartbars? I'm inclined to think that the hooves will never really heal if these go on. The pony might seem sound but the problem will not go away long term. Then I am no expert.
Come and visit my pony then :) . she has been on heart bars for about 9 months now (and barefoot behind), 100% sound, pedal bone realigned and she's enjoying life and getting back into work. it was difficult when we were coping with the poor growth produced during her laminitis attack but to cope with that my farrier was coming every 2 weeks at one point to re-shoe her and take off that little bit more growth. within 6 months we had 'grown out' the poor laminitic hoof and she's now back to good, solid hoof wall and her feet are looking better than ever. leaving them barefoot when growing out this damaged hoof would be a major concern to me as it just falls off. bonnie would lose nearly half her hoof if she lost a shoe as the foot just crumbled. i will admit that i was hesitant to put her on heart bars but they aren't long term, just til she's 100% back to work and then we can experiment with other things :) we were recomended to try Imprint shoes (plastic ones that glue on) but they do not work and i wouldn't recomend anyone waste their money on them. cost us £250 for 2 front heart bars and they fell off within 3 weeks :mad:

I'm worried (a little knowledge is a dangerous thing ) that she's going to end up either with a field ornament or without a horse at all if she keeps on following conventional advice.
can i just ask what's wrong with 'conventional' advice? it saved my pony's life and i have 100% faith in it. if your friend is at all concerned about what her vets are saying then get in touch with robert eustace (www.laminitis.org). they even have an x-ray referal service for rotation/fonder and he will recomend a treatment plan.
EDIT: just read this thread again. can i just say IF a digital pulse is present then the horse must be box rested with frog supports (buy them from equilife or i can tell you how to make some yourself ;) ). medication is bute, ACP and asprin. ACP and asprin help restore blood flow to the feet. its not wise to leave a horse unmedicated as the pain can stress them and (a) make them very depressed and (b) make the laminitis a million times worse. once horse is sound and off frog supports and meds they then need a further 30 days box resting and only then can you think about turn out. during the 30 days box rest, they are generally left barefoot and just lightly trimmed.
 
Last edited:
Many laminitic horses do recover barefoot, and very well. There's a lot more to it than just taking the shoes off, the trim has to be right and if they aren't comfortable even on soft ground then you need to use pads, and it's a good idea to use them even if comfortable on soft ground. Even many farriers and vets think the right thing to do for a laminitic is to take the shoes off and use frog supports (Sole mates with the pedal bone tip area cut out can be used as an alternative).

Heartbars can help as long as they are done right, trim must be balanced and no leaving the heels high, the frog support part must actually do something, reapplied regularly and with a plan to go back to normal shoes/no shoes eventually. Bar shoes aren't great for the overall health of the feet so wouldn't want them as a long term solution. Heartbars done badly are pretty useless so need to make sure the farrier is a remedial farrier who really knows what he's doing.

The traditional approach keeps them in for 30 days to try to not cause further damage to the laminae from movement. The barefoot approach lets them out sooner after the digital pulse is gone because movement encourages the feet to grow and recover more quickly. It's important that they don't have bute when let out as then they won't hooley around and do damage as they can feel how much is too much. It's a judgement call when to let out and when to bute (but turned out on bute too soon could never be a good thing) and not everyone agrees on the best way. Barefoot approach wouldn't withhold bute while there's active lami (pulse etc) the horse is in so not moving around and the pain is bad.

I'd prefer the barefoot and faffing about with solemate pads approach as the hoof wall grows so much faster barefoot, especially with pads, so time taken to grow in a 'new' foot and recover is much quicker. Plus you aren't nailing into an already damaged hoof with a white line that's open to infection.

A bad attack of laminitis will leave a laminitic wedge, with new healthy inner wall growing in behind it. Once that inner wall has had some time to develop (not sure that it would do very well with shoes on, inner wall is generally thin in shod horses) then it's not too much of a problem if the old damaged wall lower down chips off.

Barefoot and heart bars aren't similar. Heartbars do at least give frog pressure if done right but a bar shoe imobilises the foot more than a normal shoe which isn't good, and the pressures on the hoof wall aren't the same, weight is carried on the outer wall, not inner wall when when shod.

Rotation without laminitis sounds a bit suspicious. Either there has been some non-dietary form of laminitis, or there's something wrong with the trimming causing the pedal bone to appear rotated, either a lot of flaring, very high heels or both. A good vet should be able to tell the difference between that kind of thing and true rotation but conversations with some vets around here make me suspicious that some don't have a clue about feet.

If it's some form of mechanical laminitis then advice should be pretty much the same, but might get away with being a little less strict with the diet eventually. If it's just high heels/flaring/bad trimming then getting an EP to have a look would be the best thing, or at least change farrier.
 
MelanieD said:
Many laminitic horses do recover barefoot, and very well. There's a lot more to it than just taking the shoes off, the trim has to be right and if they aren't comfortable even on soft ground then you need to use pads, and it's a good idea to use them even if comfortable on soft ground.

Thank you Melanie, you put it a lot better than I could :) Having seen Saff through her 'pasture' trim and her 'HP' trim I can say that there is a world of a difference between the two. Even though she had her backs off (pasture trim) for many months before I took her 'properly' barefoot, there weren't half the changes in her feet that have occurred since she's been having a HPT.

eventerbabe said:
can i just ask what's wrong with 'conventional' advice? it saved my pony's life and i have 100% faith in it.

I am glad that you were happy with conventional advice and I am glad that it worked for your pony but I have worked in (human) healthcare long enough to know that you can't blindly accept something just because it's conventional. Although the Laminitis Trust is a very worthy organisation they aren't, as yet, open to the barefoot philosophy. I firmly believe that they should research barefoot more thoroughly (they've obviously gone :eek: at Strasser and I can't help but feel that they're lumping all barefoot into one box) even if they find out that it isn't the way to go in the long run. The more I learn about barefoot (I'm not including Strasser which I don't agree with) the more I believe that conventional 'wisdom' needs to be challenged.

Apart from the fact that I believe that shoes and farriers aren't the ONLY (or necessarily the best) way to go, the fact is that the vets and farriers have been messing her and her horse around for far too long. I only want to give her ALL of the options to do with what she feels best. I know that if he were my horse I would have an EP out to have a look and give their verdict.

Thank you for your replies, I'd love to hear more especially if you've got experience in barefoot and 'pedal bone rotation' :)
 
MelanieD said:
Rotation without laminitis sounds a bit suspicious. Either there has been some non-dietary form of laminitis, or there's something wrong with the trimming causing the pedal bone to appear rotated, either a lot of flaring, very high heels or both. A good vet should be able to tell the difference between that kind of thing and true rotation but conversations with some vets around here make me suspicious that some don't have a clue about feet.

Mmmm .... I was wondering about that. I'm meeting up with her next week so will try and find out more. I never thought to ask who her farrier is (duh) ... must do that!
 
All I can say is that my OH has come across a number of cases where people with laminitic horses and ponies which have been seen to by an EP and he was so absolutly disgusted by the work done and the mentally some of these practitioners have. If you have pedal bone rotation from my OH's own experience barefoot is not always the kindest way for your horse.

Yu may end up with a sound horse but when the foot crumbles they will be in a lot more pain as they already have the laminitus to cope with you also have to take into account that most shod horses are lame after having shoes pulled when there is nothing wrong with them, how is it right to add more pain to a horses life, personally I would go 100% with the vet, mine is a very open minded vet and has suggested a lot of homeopathic and non conventional treatments for us so if he told me something was best for my horse I would do it.

I cannot see why easing the horses pain by putting the shoes on while in recovery and then exploring barefoot options when he is sound is such a bad idea, I honestly feel it would be kinder on the horse due to the extra pain not shoeing him would cause
 
most shod horses are lame after having shoes pulled

I'm no hoof anorak, but that's simply not true, not in my experience anyway. They might find rough surfaces more difficult, but their action can actually improve with the shoes off.

Why will the foot crumble? The only sure way to improve the health of a poor foot, if the horse or its circumstances can manage it, is to take the shoes off and allow it to function fully without the restriction imposed by the shoe. I've seen this happen myself with more than one horse, and any farrier worth their salt with tell you the same thing. As far as I can see the main thing with a laminitic is to minimise the risk of recurrence by tackling dietary issues, and then encouraging the new attached hoof wall to grow down and stay attached by tackling any infection and the shear forces caused by the flaring hoof wall at the toe. If this can comfortably be acheived with the shoes off then it's likely to happen more quickly. The extra stimulation will improve the blood flow in the foot and encourage the sole to thicken and provide more support to the pedal bone. But the comfort of the horse should be the paramount consideration.
 
In my OH's experience which is a huge amount, the majority of horses that have their shoes pulled are footsy and may be lame for a week at least if they have more severe feet problems then longer.

The earlier comment of farriers leaving heels long on laminitics is incorrect, it is actually the farriers aim to bring the heels a bit lower and bring the toe in.

The majority of horses have their feet crumble up to the nail holes at least, in a laminitic because you already have hoof damage you risk more breaking than with a healthy foot being left barefoot.

"if the horse or its circumstances can manage it, is to take the shoes off and allow it to function fully without the restriction imposed by the shoe."
I never said I disagreed with this just that I felt it was in the horses bect interests to be pain free before this was attempted as it could make him more uncomfortable than he is already.

"and any farrier worth their salt with tell you the same thing"
If thats a dig then it missed as I said I don't have a problem with barefoot but feel the horse should be pain free in the feet for it not to be cruel to attempt it!

I have no peoblem in horses being barefoot I wish mine could be, I just feel that the welfare of a horse should come first and I honestly believe just in case barefoot doesn't work out for the horse, and shock horror some can't go barefoot, then it would be adding to his pain if it didn't work for him and the owner may miss the pain he feels for being the laminitus, also simple things like the vet needing a trot up to assess lameness may come back inaccurate until the feet have hardened to cope with concrete and this could all affect the horses wellbeing :(
 
But the comfort of the horse should be the paramount consideration.

Read my lips! :)

If thats a dig

Absolutely not.

My observations were based on having seen 5 different working horses at our yard have their front shoes off including my own, none went lame and at least one was certainly sounder as the shoeing job was way too short at the toe and had gone into the white line.

I'd be interested to know more about the 'disgusting' jobs by EP's on the laminitics you describe - in what way was that the case? Well trained as they might be many EP's haven't been at it that long and I'm not sure how much of the current training is actually focussed on dealing with seriously diseased feet.

Incidentally our farrier keeps Gem's heels down and trims the flare at the toe aggressively and she's 100% sound and happy.
 
I will find out the exact details for you, the sketchy bits I remember was that they only did a tny bit of rasping and left the foot completly unbalanced, long in the toe and basically they were a state when the farrier came to look at them as the foot had collapsed. The worse bit though was that even though the animal was grossly overweight and the vet had diagnosed food related laminitus, the EP tried to say it didn't have laminitus it was just sore from poor shoeing and the horrors of putting a shoe on, they convinced the lady to take it off medication and it was not put on a diet.

Only when the laminitus became more severe did she contact her vet not knowing why - she hadn't consulted him - and he immediatly got my oh's boss out who is very well respected in veterinary farriery.

Strasser trimmers are also guilty of the same practice from what I have learned of them.

I know why people don't like shoeing horses and I don't disagree with that but I feel the training at the moment is nowhere near enough that they should be honestly allowed near a foot, farriers train for four years and have blocks at university, any mistakes and they are out, also the barefoot groups are not overseen by a regulative body, I just really wouldn't trust someone having heard too many horror stories and knowing the little amount fo training they undergo. Barefoot is better (and cheaper) if your horse can cope unfortunatly mine do too much roadwork, and Bramble has a problem with the growth that happened when her feet were forming which makes her lame on hard ground without shoes, I wish this wasn't the case.
 
shandy84 said:
I feel the training at the moment is nowhere near enough that they should be honestly allowed near a foot, farriers train for four years and have blocks at university, any mistakes and they are out, also the barefoot groups are not overseen by a regulative body, I just really wouldn't trust someone having heard too many horror stories and knowing the little amount fo training they undergo.

How can you say that? Do you know what the training fully consists of? Have you spoken to an EP about their training and knowledge?? As my OH is undergoing the training at the moment I personally know the amount of work he having to do to become a KC La Pierre qualified EP and I think you would be very surprised. I would rather have an EP look at my horses feet than any farrier in the area.

Currently there is not a regulative body for EP's (I think there has been talk about it, but not sure what's happening a the moment) but if you or anyone hear any "horror stories" about an EP or someone acting as an EP then it can be reported to the UK Administrator justine@cwmllwchwr.eclipse.co.uk this e-mail is available on KC's website (www.equinepodiatry.net), along with KC's e-mail address.

shandy84 said:
Barefoot is better (and cheaper) if your horse can cope unfortunatly mine do too much roadwork, and Bramble has a problem with the growth that happened when her feet were forming which makes her lame on hard ground without shoes, I wish this wasn't the case.

Barefoot by a farrier is cheaper than having shoes. Barefoot by an EP is more expensive. Its £40 for the visit / trim, which to begin with is every 4 weeks, then if conditioning is done effectively by the owner and the horse does not encounter any problems in time length between visits can be extended, the end result is to get the horse to self trim and to be checked every couple of months by an EP to make sure everything is ok, then it could be said that barefoot by an EP is cheaper than shoes. The hardest part for most people is to commit to the conditioning in the first couple of weeks / month (depending on the horse). I had to walk one of mine in solemates for 20 mins a day, doesn't sound too bad but when you have to strap the pads on walk for 20 mins then take the pads off its more like an hour's time and some people just don't have the time, which is why in some cases keeping the shoes on a horse is better.

As for barefoot horses not being able to do much roadwork, mine can do 2 hours a day easily, in fact its really good for them, it trims their hooves & stimulates them to grow at the same time, I just wish I had more time to walk them out!

How about getting a qualified EP out to see if they can do anything with Brambles feet? there's a list on the website.

As for the laminitic case, I would get a EP out who is experienced with a case like this (Richard, Alun, Karin or Trevor).
 
Rose had laminitis from April 2004 till back in work December 2004. she was box rested for 6 weeks then turned out on sand but xrays in August showed further rotation, so back to box rest, then turn out on sand. she was x rayed in December, shoes on, back in work, she now works for 2-3 hours at walk.

She was unable to go barefoot before laminitis as she feels the stones and we are very stony hard ground here. I wouldn't even consider letting her go barefoot again unless we lived somewhere else. We tried her all four, then shoeing front only but she was too sore.

She was shod this week and her feet are perfect, no rings, good and strong growth, look like new, nothing to show she has had laminitis. She has been lucky. Best advice I got was from one vet, laminitis website and my farrier who trimmed her radically (having seen the x rays) and suggested packing her feet with shavings while she was on deep litter to give more support and never to pick the feet out while she was on box rest. Did the trick. He always kept saying, no another six weeks, she is still tender, no shoes yet just wait a bit longer.
 
Most shod horses aren't lame after having their shoes pulled. Any horse with healthy feet is likely to at worst be a bit ouchy on stones for a while. My horse has serious problems with her feet and was pogoing around the field sound and acting like a total idiot within a week :D If your OH is pulling shoes and trimming and then seeing every one of those horses being footy maybe he needs to modifiy the way he's trimming them? It is actually quite common for farrier trimmed horses to be footy after a trim, depends on the individual farrier of course.

Bits of foot that break off that easily aren't really up to supporting the weight of a horse anyway. I'd agree totally with lami horses needing shoes if the alternative was to take the shoes off and kick them out to hobble around in pain. With correct use of boots and sole mate pads they aren't in any pain and recover more quickly (6 months to grow a 'new' foot is typical) than if shod.

If you think farrier training and registration is so excellent explain how there are so many bl**dy awful ones around in the UK? There are some good ones, and I'd assume your OH would be one of them, but there are many rubbish ones as well. That bit I mentioned about leaving the heels high would be one of the examples of a bad farrier :rolleyes:

The work strasser trimmers and what EPs do is very very different (the only thing they have in common is lack of shoes), about as different as a farrier and a strasser trimmer. If you have the name of the EP you OH has seen several mistakes from then please report them, address in Alibi's post. Either someone is calling themselves an EP when they shouldn't or there's an EP in your area which is not behaving very well, either way needs something done about it.
 
My pony's feet did not 'crumble without shoes'. They were trimmed by my lovely, qualified farrier every couple of weeks until they could go longer between trims.

He currently has 150 barefoot horses in his care and is very straightforward and sensible, though thinks a lot about what he is doing.

Everyone must do the best for their animal, as they see it. I cannot see it as kind to nail shoes onto an already damaged foot, and my choice has been correct for us.
 
Gill said:
Everyone must do the best for their animal, as they see it.

Exactly. A bad farrier will do far more damage than a good EP, and vice versa. What you do depends not just on the most suitable method, but also on whether or not you can find someone qualified to do that.

I try to listen to as many points of view as possible; but choices will always be limited by circumstance as well as other factors. What works for one horse in one area is not neccessarily the answer for another living elsewhere.

All of mine are barefoot and mostly manage fine; but if any of them reached a point where they managed better shod than barefoot, then I'd shoe them.
 
newrider.com