Parelli!!! UPDATED

I like Mark Rashid's approach, aspects of maybe Monty Roberts, can't recall who else but as I have said I do what works for the horse and myself at that time.
My mare listens to my voice, but she had knowledge of Clinton Anderson prior to me, I know nothing about him.

What summed up that my instructor needed showing the door was a lesson in which I left her with my horse unattended without me for maybe five minutes. I felt very worried about what she would do while my back was turned, when I heard the gate crack I got handed her on my return! My horse though was the one with the problems-in her eyes.
I had four years of lessons so I am looking at it from the been there, tried it, taken what's useful, ditched the rest.
 
  • Like
Reactions: horseandgoatmom
You can lead a horse owner to knowledge, but you cannot make them think.

WELL SAID!!.

The thing that bothers me most is basicly saying you need to use only "MY TOOS/TACK - MY METHOD".

I saw a 2 day demo here a few years ago and Linda was with a horse that she could not do anything with and Pat had to step in.
That did not go over well with Linda AT ALL, they claimed oh after hrs they would give the horse more work and fast fwd to next day
wondering how the hose would look. WELL the story was oh the owner took the horse home. I hope she was smart enough to say
ENOUGH!! but somehow I do suspect she was told to take it home-- It did not make them look good so It did not come back.

The same year Clinton Anderson was in this area too - I was not there but I guess he pushed a horse way way over the edge .
and it got ugly.

I guess he did say after he did push the horse too far.

Neither one has been back in the area since for their demos
The only thing they have done is the brief demos at EQUINE Affair.

My husband is not horsey but does go with me to EQ Affair sometimes since its not really in my comfort range to drive.
I float around the place and he sits in the very top of the arena with his Wall St Jounal but does LOL get to see a lot of the CLINICAINS.
Being non horsey it is interesting to hear his comments--- and how you could see a change in the horse etc. AND SOME GUY NAMED XXX
HE SEEMED TO KNOW HIS STUFF ETC.
He did feel parelli was a bit more of a "SHOW"

I think no matter who the person is you can pick something up even if it's I AM NEVER GOING TO DO THAT!.
NO one has the magic bullet or pc of tack that you have to buy their stuff only.

I get RFD tv and quite a few have shows which is great because you can get a good look at a lot of different people.

NONE of them are perfect all the time either I watch Julie Goodnite on RFD tv and saw her in prerson at EQ AFFAIR.
it was AWFUL she spent most ot the time touting how great she was and what she has done no meat to the demo at all .
She left the 4 or 5 people that paid big money to be in her demo to get help just hanging around in the arena on their horses
while she went on and on and ON - One poor girl was having problems with her horse Julie did not even have a clue at all
the girl broke out in tears and left the arena!!!
Then Julie is finally done with the 'IM SO GREAT speel and then FINALLY give a look to the participants and where is the other person one is missing!!
I am sure I was not alone thinking wow I am glad I did not pay big money to be in that clinic.
Yet on her show she looked FABULOUS and I could not wait to see HER IN PERSON!!

I do Like the CLINICIANS who up front say ALL HORSES ARE DIFFERENT AND ONE THING MAY NOT WORK FOR ALL HORSES
You have to adapt to what works for each horse.
 
Cortrasna, you have a reputation for being impartial on NR, generally you say it as it is.

Your description does not surprise me at all, having watched a lot of his videos. I am saddened that so many folk do not see through him,

Was it the same one I saw, with swivel cheek liverpools on plain cheek in a pair and the poor poor horses screaming in pain and him yanking on the reins wondering why the horse kept fighting the pain?

Pat Parelli cares for two things, neither are the horse and his well being, one is his bank
balance and the other is his ego.


That sounded dreadful. Poor horses.
 
What I loved about the Rashid clinic was that he did not promote himself, didn't sell anything, didn't sell a 'method'. So he approached each horse with a fresh mind and did something completely different with each one. Which was good and frustrating at the same time because you couldn't just learn how to 'do it'. But of course that's what makes him good!

I was really worried that seeing him live would be a let down after reading his books but he was as good as I'd hoped.

Other demos sound like they are festivals of merchandise and self promotion more than lessons on horsemanship :-(
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ruskii
I have seen him and the person I went with took a Tenn Walker and he did taylor what he did to the specific horse.
I was impressed with him a lot! Sadly she did not follow what he said - she thought she knew better.

Other demos sound like they are festivals of merchandise and self promotion more than lessons on horsemanship :-(

I think that is very true but some are MUCH WORSE THAN OTHERS.

I think John Lyons is one of the very few that really never pushed "his" stuff. His magazine "Perfect horse" in the beginning was black and white and did not have any ads in it
Then sadly it went color and had ads then one day there was a letter from the publisher the magazine is all done and subscription being converted to "trail rider magazine"
that was the pitts.
 
I like Monty Roberts approach. I have read his books and they make logical sense. I also think that I like Richard Maxwell approach, but I did see a demo of his at Your Horse live where he got a difficult horse to load. He was using the pressure/release method using a rope halter and I couldn't help but wonder how much pain the horse was in before he gave in and the pressure was released. I know that the horse wasn't being hit with a whip, but there are other ways of causing the horse pain which are just as bad.
 
From the little I know about any of these practitioners, I also favoured Monty Roberts. I am now wondering though, if I ever go to see a demo of his that I might be equally uneasy. I have done a bit of googling today and at face value, his methods do look different in some major areas from Parelli, but a couple of video clips I came across of him in action, also had me on red alert.

Perhaps I might get the chance one day to see him for myself, I really hope so. After yesterday I am now convinced that most of the information you see and read online only gives a small picture of the their methods, and you have to view for yourself to really make a reasonably informed opinion.

Someone has kindly lent me a dually headcollar to try on Dolly, just to get an idea of how she might ride without a bit - I shall have to do a bit of research before I use it, to make sure she is used to it and happy before I actually ride in it. I do hope nobody sees me practising in the field for fear they think I may have turned in an NH groupie! ;)
 
I don't like join-up personally. I also think the whole concept of being the alpha is a bit suspect. But I have never seen Roberts in action and I do like Kelly Marks' book.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ruskii
I don't like join-up personally. I also think the whole concept of being the alpha is a bit suspect. But I have never seen Roberts in action and I do like Kelly Marks' book.

Out of interest KP what is it about join up that you don't like? And not wanting to defend or endorse any particular type of training, but surely any method we choose to use to train a horse to allow us to use them to ride on and drive our carriages etc. has to be based on being alpha over the horse surely? I have no problem with misleading and duping my horse or my donkeys into believing I am alpha over them, I lie about that little fact all day long to all of them. Long may they believe that illusion.

The day they realise tis all smoke and mirrors and they assume the alpha role with me will be the death knell for them and for me I suspect. I do have issues with how some trainers/practitioners, whatever you want to call them, try to enforce their dominance on a horse, rather than craftily fooling them into believing we are the all powerful one in the relationship. But I really don't have a problem at all with playing the alpha role.:)
 
I am another that is dubious about join up having met a few horses who it really screwed up. Generally however they had been 'trained' by non expert owners. General symptoms are difficulty in catching, yes they come to you but raise an arm to put on a headcollar and they run away as trained, or try to put on a rug without sending them away!!

Strangely our 'not trained' horse and ponies stand where you put them until asked to move, thow themselfs into head collars if any one approaches then in field, stand to be rugged/unrugged without holding in a field, open mouths to accept a bit etc etc.

We do not take an alpha approach but a cooperation philosophy!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ruskii
Out of interest KP what is it about join up that youthose tlike? And not wantiwe trydefedepennndorse any particular type of training, but surely any method we choose to use to train a horse to allow us to use them to ride on and drive our carriages etc. has to be based on ver the horse surely? I have no problem with misleading and duping my horse or my donkeys into believing I am alpha over them, I lie about that little fact all dg to all of Long may they believe that illusiion.

The day they realise tis all smoke and mirrors and they assume the alpha role with me will be the death knell for them and for me I suspect. I do have issues with hidea butw some trainers/practitioners, whatever you want to call them, try to enforce their dominance on a horse, rather than craftily fooling them into believing we are the all powerful one in the relationship. But I really don't have a problem at all with playing the alpha role.:)

I don't have a problem with the concept of being the alpha, I just am not sure horses think of it in that way no matter how much we try to mimic alpha behaviour. Over time I moved away from being the alpha to "Making the wrong thing hard and the right thing easy". But then over time I started thinking that if a horse was (or appeared to be) 'choosing' the hard way it was probably because I had failed to commumicate the easy way clearly enough. I guess I believe that unless a horse has learnt to become resentful of us, they generally want a trouble free life and will cooperate with us. So I see no need to be adversarial with them most of the time.

As for join up. I read the book and liked the idea but I did not have access to a round pen so never tried it. Then one day I had a bolshy disrespectful 3 yo on loan. I was putting out a salt lick in the field and he charged me. I used very assertive body language and swung the leadrope at him to drive him away. He circled me bucking and making threatening gestures and I kept him away from me. After a while I noticed he had dropped his head and was doing the classic submissive gestures. So I dropped my assertive stance and invited him in. He then did the classic following me about. So I just thought 'great I'm now his herd leader, join up is fab!' So I set up a round pen for Charlie and decided to join up with him too. But his reaction was totally different. He seemed fearful and bewildered. Why was I sending him away? What had he done wrong? I soon realised he had no desire to join up at all. He was very keen to get as far from me as possible! And who could blame him? It took me a while to repair the damage to his trust. So I decided join up may have a place in horsemanship but I was not experienced enough to know when to use it and when to leave well alone.

But then I read Joanna Days book The Fearless Horse and she talks about 'drawing in' body language that invites a horse to you. In playing around with that I discovered that many horses will do the following about, shadowing every move behaviour without being driven away first or without me showing any 'alpha' behaviours . Cally does it with me which is ironic as no one else can even catch her! Why horses do it I don't know. I'd love to understand it better. But if you can get join-up (or what looks very like it) without any alpha behaviours or herd banishment then the whole explanation in Roberts book seems suspect.

Sorry. Long answer. But this sort of stuff fascinates me!
 
Sorry. Long answer. But this sort of stuff fascinates me!

Please don't apologise it does me too (especially after yesterday!:eek:) - that is why I ask you for more explanation of your statements. :)


We do not take an alpha approach but a cooperation philosophy!!

I think that was what I was trying to sort of say, I don't set out to go in a all guns blazing alpha approach, but I like them to co-operate with me and I truly believe they only give us that co-operation if they (a) like us and enjoy being with us -and (b) by reinforcing that connection with everyday work with them they do seem to think and accept that we are alpha. That works for me and my lot. :)
 
I dont see myself as Alpha, I see myself as a human and she a horse. She knows more about being a horse than I can attempt to think I know.
I think this Alpha is individual from mare to gelding and its changeable anyway.
 
  • Like
Reactions: em_123 and Em 1
I've been on a livery yard where loads of middle-aged women chose to 'do' Parelli with their horses because they were far too scared to ride them so it made them feel good to say 'Look at this amazing bond I have with my horse, I can make it go backwards into its stable'.(while the rest of us went off hacking and came back and led out horses into their stables head first!)

My farrier at the time said he couldn't bear to work with Parelli-trained horses as every time he approached their rear end to do their hinds they'd move away...o_O

I kind of dispute the 'natural horsemanship' thing anyway. I mean, if we're going to go natural we'd surely turn our horses loose and let them live how they want? I like to consider 'horsemanship' as in working with the individual horse to meet its needs so that human and horse have a good bond.

Oh, and why does Parelli sell a left-handed lead rope?? Have never figured that one out....
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna
Sounds like you just reaffirmed what i already knew.

I don't and have never used a method at all. Call me ignorant but i knew nothing about nh or other methods when i got chanter. I had only had loans/share before. What i can say is i treat my horses as living breathing things.

Yes they move when i rug them they don't move away just don't stand like a statue. I don't yell i just move with them. When i think they have done or about to do something that can put me or someone in danger they get yelled at to get their attention if need be i will hit then if they bite for example or kick (they don't do either of these).

I never taught then to back up as such. I just kept asking when i needed it.

Sorry nothing helpful it just all seams like common sense. I need them to do xyz i will keep asking in different ways until they get it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ruskii and em_123
All NH is and should be is common sense. All any horsemanship should be is common sense. If you haven't got common sense you have no business being around a horse IMO.

My respect also goes to anyone who says what works for one may not for another because every single horse is different. You can pull little bits from every method.

KP Nut, I like your comments on join up. This is a classic what works for one.

The Bolshy horse needed to be taught those manners at that point. You had to assert yourself.

I have this issue with lady. In the field she does seriously try and dominate anything in her field, man, equine or canine. Once I've got hold of her she doesn't tend to be an issue until it comes to lunging which has massively improved! I have to send her away if she gets in my space in the field and there's a good chance join up may be effective with her should she become more persistent. At the moment just sending her away from me twice is enough to bore her from her interest in me lol!

You're other horse clearly felt comfortable with you and how you worked together and I suspect this altered things from a working together as you had been partnership, to you suddenly to him, wanting to boss him about and that wasn't what he was used to or liked about your partnership.

What people must also remember is the programmes or demos people are seeing are of horses that have a problem of some kind, not horses that already work perfectly well with the human counterpart. So whether it's join up or any other method, there's a need there for the horse to be shown the way. Some horses are followers others are leaders. A leader is fine provided they're not Bolshy with it and this is where I suspect join up is of great help. With a natural follower I don't suspect join up would do much more than frighten them into doing what they already naturally want to do anyway and as such a different calmer approach is necessary.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KP nut
I have been to three or four Monty Roberts clinics and watched join up and the use of a Dually halter. I did learn from watching but
So I set up a round pen for Charlie and decided to join up with him too. But his reaction was totally different. He seemed fearful and bewildered. Why was I sending him away? What had he done wrong?
Couldnt agree more, as would never drive away any of the horses I have known and ridden. Moreover that exercise has been replicated using a toy remote controlled car instead of a human trainer.
However, I do regularly lead, halt, back up etc as shown by Peace, Rashid and many others. I did it only yesterday when Maisie threw a strop. When one does this one moves the feet of the horse (obliges it to move its feet) out of one's own space. Later someone on the yard said to me that the horse really loved me. She doesnt love me, but she does follow. So, on a much reduced scale, any of us controlling or correcting horses do use these techniques.
The reason so called NH when applied to riding and ground work made such a difference to me was that I had no experience of horses and plenty of bringing up children. I had a friend, an academic, who was one of those who applied behaviourism in UK - to family life, to psychology, to social work etc. So Kelly Marks' applied to horses, things I already knew well.
And, it appeared that the horses knew it too.
So my feelings about myself in relation to horses completely shifted. I moved from being a total helpless, bullied, inadequate wreck to someone who could work out how to ask horses to do what I wanted - and the horses complied just as my children had.
I also found that tho I was a total dunce in riding lessons, my unconscious caught onto the body language I watched in demos. I take no credit for this. But it is worth considering the theory put forward in Miller's history of "natural horsemanship" that the use of psychology developed as a response to the shift of gender - women owners (amateurs) taking over from professional male grooms in the training of horses. Women do teach, and mimic and communicate. Brain took over from brawn.

So much of what went on in the horse world was cruel either to me or to horses that NH seemed neither better nor worse than BHS or Dressage practice. I expect most people telling other people what to do with their horses to be intent on showing themselves superior to others, and offering reassurance and congratulations to many of their usually female clients.

There is another tendency I notice here - to discuss the work of NH trainers as if one is dealing with a static body of information. Most of the trainers adjust and adapt their practices as time goes by. John Lyons went bitless and then returned to using a bit and explains why. Rashid has abandonned the method he taught me of how to train a horse to stand still at the block to be mounted. I dont feel inclined to change myself as the previous method worked well for me, and my share when coached this way even stood for me to remount from a pile of timber when I was alone out on a hack.

Like horses, we humans do what works for us. I instinctively mimicked behaviour I had seen from NH trainers, whether in real life or on a video, it is possible that it worked only because of my naive trust that it would be effective. Belief is everything. When a difficulty arises with a horse, it is useless for me to suggest NH style remedies to a person who believes that it is the horse that is at fault. The NH trainers (and the competition riders influenced by them) presented horses more as canvases on which we could work. A horse that does not respond to a miniscule cue can be taught to do so.

Those of you who already learned that as children or teenagers just by being around yards had other role models. You knew it all already. You are not the intended market for this NH stuff. But Harry Hobbes and others on this board were totally right to want to educate me in NH. And no I have never watched Parelli. I am not a great person for joining organisations and structured tests and levbels - I am anti authority and dont want to be assessed and judged. But there are horse owners out there who do constitute this market and I dont think on the whole that Parelli is any better or worse than e.g. competitive dressage. With its levels and marks sheets and rollkur and restricting tack. Or riding cross country where riders and horses get killed.
 
There is with various horsemanship methods the idea to have the horse out of your space. My thinking on join up is if the horse is uncomfortable being with you, you send it away so its scared and vulnerable and its suddenly picks you as a pal. Before people dismiss join up, isn't lunging similar? You get the same responses if you lunge without gadgets the horse will drop its head etc etc. The difference one hopes is the horse is comfortable with you, but you still send it away, change direction and finish the session.

You are encouraged to have the horse follow behind you, I can't remember when you alter that into all areas and driving from behind -long reining. I know we have had chats about whether the horse behind is following or dominant. I can fill in that blank for my cob because she is an opinionated little madam, but, comes over as the quiet calm placid type. Mark rashid called it something about the Alpha that the horses follow without the horse doing anything (that's going to bug me so someone answer that:))
For her she has always been slightly behind, I have tried to work on it and at best I can get her head level. Its pretty impossible to get her trotting inhand without her biting! She is dominating and being behind her teeth do slip on the odd occasion.
Answer if your horse follows you its not always joined up, it might be dominating and pushing.
 
newrider.com