Parelli!!! UPDATED

Learning to be more assertive, was one of the hardest things for me.

I'm not a natural leader & usually by the time I'd got to the stage of having to be assertive, it was difficult to do it without emotion. Not helped of course, by years of riding instructors going 'get cross/angry with them as they aren't doing it' - I didn't want to angry at my own horse, so of course it put me off being 'assertive'.

Having a very pushy, dominant horse - I had to learn to be a better leader, before I could get softness, connection & the communication I wanted. Well, actually - at first it was just about staying safe :D

It's only through learning & being shown how to be assertive, without emotional, that I learnt to become a better leader. But, for me - that was a very personal & emotional thing to have to come to grips with.

It's also been one of the most positive life lessons I've learnt - I've been promoted twice since learning it !


I think that's good that it has helped you in other life areas:)
 
I should have added - Cortrasna have a lovely time and report back here.
Brannaman is coming near here and I am toying with the idea of watching tho I didnt take to his film.
Funny how people on NR expect one to become a devotee of any trainer whom you watch. Women of a certain age are not natural born followers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hormonalmare
I do what I do if it works, if it doesn't I do something else.

I think with nh people get sucked in a bit like a dyson. You don't see the same with classical or traditional. I don't have certain socks or equipment to say I do xyz, they may say Joules though :rolleyes: I do get oh you use a bit have you given up nh, and oh your bitless have you started it again.
What I think now and what I thought at the time has changed. I have been there watched the demos, watched the clinics, organised and run my own demos, helped teach, done the levels, got the string :p
Do I wiggle my rope to back up, no, do I do any games, no. Do I regret having done it, no. I learnt what I needed to at the time with that pony. Forget it with this one!
 
To me all any NH is just common sense. It's about learning to read your horses and learning to understand their language. For the most part they all understand the same cues. There are variations of understanding between individual horses and ways that they understand and it's our job to find out what that is.

I do so by having them out in a herd and by learning how they interact with each other. Then tailoring my way of working with them to try and as closely as possible coincide with how they're taught by my herd leader. It's an ongoing thing, the way they start to understand things from him changes all the time and I must keep up with that.

This approach has served me well and besides giving them a kick back like my herd leader would lol! I've been as close to "speaking" to them as he would as I can be.

It's about setting the horse up to succeed. I don't really go in for these different methods. What works for one doesn't work for another.

I have very different horses in my care at the moment. Some need me to be much more assertive and some need me to be a little less so. Some may need more stimulation with work than others and so the parelli games may well suit them if it came down to it.

As yet I haven't needed to look into parelli as a method. It's not that I wouldn't but just have managed to teach them without so.

The problem with NH is people don't understand it's as much about disciplining the horses as being nice to them. So many people completely miss the point of it is to have a mutual respect and understanding and this is when those horses that are spoilt by NH come about.

I've recently sold a horse who had been predominantly dealt with in NH by an owner who really didn't understand how to work with her horse correctly and the horse became dangerous.

She's now in a lovely home doing fantastically and all with common sense approach rather than her old owners fluffy bunny approach. These are the people who really need a shake lol! She was lucky not to get hurt by the horse in the end.
 
I watched one of his videos on the horse and country channel - carriage driving... I actually was gobsmacked... ( in a bad way)
 
Well! Gobsmacked, almost lost for words, angry, all preconceptions and more confirmed - and that was just my OH. I fear writing my own thoughts will rattle the cage of the deluded followers, but I will in as restrained manner as I can.

His own horse was a trick circus pony in my opinion, no more, no less. Que much 'ooh'ing' and 'aaaah'ing' from the Parelli'ites and muttering that they so wished their horses could do all those tricks. (Why??? For what purpose???))To be expected of course at an event geared at followers and those most likely to become followers and throw money into the ever open and grasping coffers. But oddly, I would guarantee that a good 75 per cent of those watching and sighing with awe and wonder, would shun a circus with trained and performing animals gyrating and twirling in completely unatural and grotesque movement. Most likely proclaiming how cruel and un-nuatural to enforce that degree of compliance and submission and humiliation (OK I apologise for antropomorphism with the use of that latter word, but you get my drift?)

And believe me it was submission to the furthest degree I have ever seen in a horse this side of the lower end sales and the horrors of Ballinasloe horse fair. His horse was completely and utterly shut down, the little mare's eyes are dead, not a spark of character and personality to be seen, I question the behind the scenes training it took to arrive at that degree of compliance and total loss of spirit and character.

So - that was our impression of the first half hour or so of Mr. P and his performing monkey (God help the poor little horse :( ) Then we spent the next two hours of himself helping a young woman with her horse who apparently is very good it most ways, (ISH, 14 years old she has owned him for a year) but had little or no brakes when approaching a jump at canter, a problem I would think best resolved with the help of a good jump instructor and some basic re -schooling in faster paces. But No - she brought him along to meet Mr. P. Why would you???:eek:

Well I can't say I saw anything that would have helped improve this horses way off going into a jump, we were told he MUST learn to back up on command or she would never resolve the problem?? So then ensued a lot of work on the ground, shaking that fecking rope at the poor horse, then when that didn't work he took over himself and a few sharp hard raps under the chin with the clip end of the rope had the horse flaring his nostrils and showing the whites of his eyes as he rapidly backed away from the pain of the metal crack on his jaw - and yes it was such a rap that it was clearly audible to hear the metal hitting bone. So huge rounds of applause as the horse did exactly what you would expect, he backed rapidly away from pain.......natural horsemanship? Well yes in a way, surely isn't it the most natural thing in the world for a horse to remove itself rapidly backwards and away from pain coming directly at it?

Then at some point we moved on to the man himself taking control of the situation yet again, this time trying to get the horse to move sideways along the side of the arena........not very good at that (slow learner this unfortunate horse, you think by now it would have learned you don't mess with Mr.P) At this point he chose to use the thicker handle end of his very long stick( 10 feet maybe) to poke the horse in the face and slap it around his head to 'encourage' it to move in the direction he requested. At this point the horse was clearly terrified and made several attempts to find a way either through or over the (thankfully!!) very high and sturdy wall of the arena, at one point right in front of myself and Mr. Cortrasna, I could have wept for the terror in his eyes and the rapidly dilating flared nostrils. A horses greatest nightmare, a flight animal, completely trapped and unable to get away from it's predator, who was intent on poking its head sharply with the 'natural training stick'.

At this point, had it been Dolly or any horse I have ever owned, I would have taken Mr. P's natural implement of fear from him snapped it into several pieces and shoved it where the sun doesn't shine and removed my horse from his tawdry side show and spent the rest of my days apologising to my horse for being such a gullible and deluded owner that I thought this fiasco of mans ego over the complete submission of the equine, thinly disguised as horse training (naturally of course, lets not forget how natural and kind this method is???:mad:) would be in my horse's best interest and mine.

I have often read and heard that some trainers have received horses in for retraining and effectively complete rehab, following intensive Parelli training, and in their opinion most of those horses they see are completely b****xed and some cannot actually be helped to relearn how to become a horse and live comfortably alongside man. I thought they might be exaggerating somewhat, sadly after today I fear they do not exaggerate at all. My first thoughts were, this man would ruin my horse within an hour and a lot of people here are going to go home and try and use his methods on their horses - can you imagine how many ruined and confused horses that equates to?

And no, it is not that they are going home and doing what Parelli has shown them incorrectly, watching the man himself must surely show us how it is to be done, right.....and believe me that will ultimately completely screw your horse up.......if you carry it through to the last degree, you too might have a little horse like his own little mare, that will perform all these tricks. But your horse will be as good as dead to the world, its spirit destroyed and its personality completely eroded and suffocated. And your ego will soar and your friends will 'ooh' and aaah' as they watch your trick pony perform for you. And when you look in your hose's eyes you will see nothing, no secrets, no special bond, no knowledge of what makes your horse tick, nothing - just blank submission.;)

Ok - over to his supporters. Incidentally I have asked OH to read this and would he confirm I am not exagerrating what we witnessed today and does he think that he saw the same things I saw ......he isn't a yes man by any means, he feels I have been quite restrained. :rolleyes:
 
Having done some parelli in with my other stuff with my previous pony I can answer, as I'm sure others can re the backing up. And about the phases and the clip. Not saying we don't back up, in dressage you get asked for rein back.

I have seen at first hand the stick being used in "zone one" the delicate face area to encourage the horse to move away, yield. Why do people think pnh is fluffy! Its not, its just sold to people in another box.
My ex instructor gave the cob back to me after she couldn't "make her" back up through a gateway. I just led her through the bloody thing!

@Cortrasna now do you know why I dislike sideways so much, you have seen how its taught if the horse doesn't get it which was what happened to previous pony. Now current lass can do it really easily and its more western.

I am not anti as some aspects of it have helped, as with any trainer I can take what works for my animal. But I am not a supporter either.
I had a 1* instructor out who wouldn't teach me unless I was a member and followed the programme. My thinking isn't that rigid.
 
Last edited:
My ex instructor gave the cob back to me after she couldn't "make her" back up through a gateway. I just led her through the bloody thing!

Newforest how wonderfully refreshing to read such a commonsense statement and it says it all really - the above really had me spluttering tea over my keyboard! :p

Yes, Dolly and every horse I have ever owned can back up as far as you might want on the ground or under saddle, and not a single poke in the face, slap around the head or whack under the chin was involved in that training module. :rolleyes:
 
  • Like
Reactions: OwnedbyChanter
Blimey - that sounds dreadful :( That poor horse - I would have intervened if my animal was showing distress like that, (off topic but at one gun dog lesson I went to, my flat coat was a dreadful one to 'run in' on another dogs retrieve, the trainer got hold of him - I thought he was just going to whip the dummy away to stop him getting it - but he grabbed my dog by the scruff and swung him round ! :mad: I bellowed LET HIM GO ! So loudly that people at the other end of the 10 acre paddock in the advanced group turned to look my voice was so loud o_O

I'm not by any stretch of the imagination a small person and I crossed that field in good time to get to the trainer - fully intent of 'taking him by the scruff' but he released the dog and backed off hurriedly as he could see I wasn't impressed. The bad bit is he was well respected trainer - not to parelli fame though internationally, but certainly very highly thought of and regarded in the working gun dog world, having released a few training books and judging high standard field trials. I couldn't give a brass wotsit who he was, he hurt my dog and I was about to hurt him :mad: fortunately by the time I was within distance of him, I cooled down just enough to give him a verbal pasting. End of the day I don't care who you are - you hurt my animal then I WILL intervene to stop it, so many people are so 'Oooh and Aaaaah' and get sucked in with the propaganda of these idiots that all reason flies out the window.

Wonder what the reaction would have been like if you had tsked loudly ?
 
Wonder what the reaction would have been like if you had tsked loudly ?

OH and I asked ourselves exactly that on the way home, slightly ashamed we didn't have the courage or the foresight to stand up there and then, say our piece and walk out. I suspect we might have been on the 6 o'clock news with a report on our public hanging and flogging at the wretched pantomime! :rolleyes:
 
OH and I asked ourselves exactly that on the way home, slightly ashamed we didn't have the courage or the foresight to stand up there and then, say our piece and walk out. I suspect we might have been on the 6 o'clock news with a report on our public hanging and flogging at the wretched pantomime! :rolleyes:


Wow was the audience that much in love with Mr P ?
 
Wow was the audience that much in love with Mr P ?

Sadly yes I think most were, definitely had the feeling he was preaching to the converted.....I did have a brief chat with one young couple in the car park, who made a quick exit when we did, equally appalled. They had also come our of curiosity to judge for themselves, the young woman remarked she just wanted to take P's little mare home with her and turn her away for a year to re kindle the spark in her. :(
 
Thankyou you have said everything I think about his demos,I did hint it wasn't worth a lunch. I had a pupil attend the infamous Stoneleigh demo with the owener of a loan horse of hers when she was only 10 and even then she was distressed for the horse . It is like a meeting of a religious cult, not a horse training seminar.
 
It's really interesting to read your review. I know very little about parelli but have been invited to take Ben to a few 'intro to parelli' sessions which I have declined as I have never really seen the point in the games they play. My friends horse can walk backwards when she shakes her rope, but I just have to say 'back' to Ben and back he goes. I don't understand why I would want to teach Ben a 'different' way of doing our groundwork when our current methods work very well.
 
Thankyou for this! It has confirmed what i suspected when seeing a small demo somewhere a good few years ago. That poor horse.

Interestingly, lady who I'm working with at the moment it has come to light that she has been worked with by some "horse whisperer" in our area. What you said about them not being able to work alongside man and be a horse. Rings very very true with her.

It would seem this bloke couldn't get her to submit to him so he grabbed her by the forelock and held on. She reared and lifted him up and he ended up ripping her forelock out which has resulted in it growing back a huge frizzy mess so obviously nerve damage.

Since this yard is where the girls problems with the pony have started I suspect when the girl wasn't around lady was perhaps subjected to far tougher handling with her training.

She just goes in all guns blazing with both horses and humans. It's taking Time but she's slowly coming around although I'm not sure we will ever get past her attitude completely.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna
I've never looked in to pnh mainly because I dislike the fact that 'parelli' means 'method of horse training' not 'chap who trains horses' as this strikes me as breathtakingly arrogant and I hate all the gimmicky crap. Plus the rigidity.

But I really do like other 'natural horsemanship' trainers, by which I mean those who see things from the horses point of view and work with the horses instincts and communication skills to develop a willing trusting partnership. As opposed to the 'show him who's boss/get after him' attitude I grew up with. People like Michael Peace, Joanna & Roger Day, Mark Rashid.

I don't know who he was referring to but Rashid has some pretty damning things to say about a natural horsemanship demo he went to in which all the horses were robotic and resigned and looked defeated.

From what you have described, parelli is as far removed from horse centred partnership working as it's possible to get! And is far closer to ego driven dominance approaches that it's meant to be the kinder alternative to.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna
Cortrasna, you have a reputation for being impartial on NR, generally you say it as it is.

Your description does not surprise me at all, having watched a lot of his videos. I am saddened that so many folk do not see through him,
I watched one of his videos on the horse and country channel - carriage driving... I actually was gobsmacked... ( in a bad way)
Was it the same one I saw, with swivel cheek liverpools on plain cheek in a pair and the poor poor horses screaming in pain and him yanking on the reins wondering why the horse kept fighting the pain?

Pat Parelli cares for two things, neither are the horse and his well being, one is his bank
balance and the other is his ego.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gimp and Cortrasna
newrider.com