Parelli!!! UPDATED

Cortrasna

Grumpy old nag
Aug 5, 2009
9,950
3,481
113
Ireland
:eek::eek: I am actually going to see a live demo from himself this Saturday. Anyone who knows me from over the years on here will understand I am not a huge fan of the new wave of various NH practitioners. Although, if I had to choose and follow just one, based purely on what I have seen and read second hand, Monty would be my 'go to' man.

Main reasons for going - the tickets are free, OH is going to buy me a nice lunch on the way down, there is a draw for lots of Horseware Ireland goodies and I am a huge fan of all their stuff........plus I have to admit a certain curiosity and wonder can he convert me to a follower. Quite happy to sit and soak up the demo and his words of wisdom with a reasonably open mind.

Will I come home clutching my new carrot stick and wippy woppy (or is that the other guy?) and chanting robotic-ally as I shake my lead rope at Dolly as she backs away from me in sheer terror and total bewilderment? What do have your money on? ;):p
 
I hope you have a good time :-)

I saw them on Saturday at Addington & loved it - but I already study & use PNH, so I'm biased! X
 
I went to a Demo at the NEC as the tickets were free, met a woman in the toilets that was crying as it was such a beautiful relationship between Linda and the horse, although it was quite clear to see that the horses owner was winding the horse up before getting on by doing the games incorrectly.
I'm not a follower, although I do like a more NH approach to my horses :D
 
There may or may not be some sound horsemanship in there but I'm afraid all the negative publicity surrounding the Parellis and the video footage we've seen showing them essentially abusing the horses they're handling will prevent me from ever being open to listening to what they have to say :rolleyes: If a normal, non-abusiveg horse owner could show me how they put Parelli stuff into practise with their own horses then maybe I would be able to listen to them.
 
I cringe at how I see a lot of people doing NH games etc. as they totally miss the point of it, a lot of the "founders" (for want of a better word) are nice to watch and have good understanding. I wouldn't rule out watching a demo, I mean its just common sense horsemanship isn't it really, but I am generally very wary when looking at horses etc. if people say they have been doing NH with them as too many I have seen have been too softly, softly and the horses have no respect and take the P (not all, those who do it well are great)
 
Years ago I was on a course with a horse trainer who I very much respect. He uses all manner of techniques taken from NH to traditional /classical methods to horse psychology and physiology.. He studied in the USA and Iceland and in Germany and Portugal. He brings a lot from all places together.

He was teaching folk to round pen and get the horse to listen to body language. Bit like join up but without the stress on the horse .

He explained to one person how to get the horse to move forwards, slow down, stop, change direction. He got the mare working like a dream, working at liberty, reacting to his smallest cue. He then left to go and work with other folk , leaving her to practice.
This particular woman had not even picked up on the very, very basics and just chased her horse round and round and round and round until the poor mare was close to dropping. IN the end someone went and fetch the trainer to get her to stop the cruelty.

You can lead a horse owner to knowledge, but you cannot make them think.
 
Having said that, I have seen him and his Mrs. treat horses far, far more coarsely than I like to see. If they do this in public, what do they get up to when nobody is watching? I have also seen him bullshit shamelessly, displaying a level of knowledge he should not have been imparting. He did a Carriage Driving Video, harness set up dangerously, wrong bits causing the horses pain, and his advocating carriage driving practice that ought never have been approved of. If he don't know he should say so and acknowledge he is not the font of all knowledge
.
 
When I was at the Mark Rashid demo there were quite a few people there interested in NH. There were SOOOO many questions about why he WASN'T doing things (eg why aren't you bitless, why don't you use this or that piece of equipment etc). In the end he just said "I am here to talk about what I do, not why I don't do what I don't do! You are free to make your own choices.' He was very respectful of other viewpoints, but also said he was generally against fixed ideas about anything and the best way to learn was to be flexible and open minded.

So I would be happy to go to a PP demo and think it would be really interesting, but would not leave my brain at the door and would evaluate what I saw for myself.

But that open attitude contrasts with my (admittedly fairly limited) experience of PNH. I had a friend who was one of the first UK Parelli trained instructors. She left and set up on her own because 'his word was God' and there was no room for individuality or disagreement or adapting the models. She was a fantastic horsewoman and learnt a huge amount from PP but it was the attitude of him and his more loyal (fanatical!) adherents that puts me off.
 
:eek::eek: I am actually going to see a live demo from himself this Saturday. Anyone who knows me from over the years on here will understand I am not a huge fan of the new wave of various NH practitioners. Although, if I had to choose and follow just one, based purely on what I have seen and read second hand, Monty would be my 'go to' man.

Main reasons for going - the tickets are free, OH is going to buy me a nice lunch on the way down, there is a draw for lots of Horseware Ireland goodies and I am a huge fan of all their stuff........plus I have to admit a certain curiosity and wonder can he convert me to a follower. Quite happy to sit and soak up the demo and his words of wisdom with a reasonably open mind.

Will I come home clutching my new carrot stick and wippy woppy (or is that the other guy?) and chanting robotic-ally as I shake my lead rope at Dolly as she backs away from me in sheer terror and total bewilderment? What do have your money on? ;):p


Hahhaaaaaa, yes you will come away chanting for sure and wearing copies of those infamous suede chaps that they love....:p
It's always been that moustache that gets me - it's just so huge! Lol
Seriously though - I guess they can't be wrong in every aspect, they have a lot of followers and maybe you'll come away inspired? Look forward to hearing about it.
 
I do remember the video someone on here posted a long while ago - Linda was trying to get a horse to do something and it didn't understand. She resorted to keep flicking it around the head which I personally did not like. But that is only one bad thing I have seen. I know there are lots of books and videos they've made - I keep saying I'll have a look at a cd I got that was free.
 
There may or may not be some sound horsemanship in there but I'm afraid all the negative publicity surrounding the Parellis and the video footage we've seen showing them essentially abusing the horses they're handling will prevent me from ever being open to listening to what they have to say :rolleyes: If a normal, non-abusiveg horse owner could show me how they put Parelli stuff into practise with their own horses then maybe I would be able to listen to them.

You're more than welcome to come & watch Pete & I at any time. I don't know where you are, but if you're close to West Sussex - feel free to pop in!

I cringe at how I see a lot of people doing NH games etc. as they totally miss the point of it, a lot of the "founders" (for want of a better word) are nice to watch and have good understanding. I wouldn't rule out watching a demo, I mean its just common sense horsemanship isn't it really, but I am generally very wary when looking at horses etc. if people say they have been doing NH with them as too many I have seen have been too softly, softly and the horses have no respect and take the P (not all, those who do it well are great)

Surely that's the same as anything? I see plenty of people who do dressage or showjumping or in fact, anything (both students and instructors!) who do it far from well :D I'm not sure why it would be different for NH?

Some people are naturally more in tune or instinctive with horses - some people have to learn it & some may always struggle. Surely that's the same with anything? I'll always find jumping hard - I'm not a natural at it, for a whole host of reasons! That's not a mark against people that have taught me, it's my my thing! Parelli was the first method, that addressed 'common sense' things for me. Literally, no other instructor I had, had done so. I probably could have got it from another NH or just very good instructor, but Parelli was the source I came across first.

I must admit, I've chosen to train with instructors - I use 3 different instructors, ranging from newly qualified to 3* - over home study, as I think it's FAR easier to learn better, with hands on instruction so to speak. I'm 99% confident, had I tried to learn from a DVD I'd have got myself in a right pickle & confused not only myself, but my poor horse too!

I've bought a few DVDs - but literally like 1 or 2 - and they are great, but for me, they support my learning as apposed to being how I learn.

When I was at the Mark Rashid demo there were quite a few people there interested in NH. There were SOOOO many questions about why he WASN'T doing things (eg why aren't you bitless, why don't you use this or that piece of equipment etc). In the end he just said "I am here to talk about what I do, not why I don't do what I don't do! You are free to make your own choices.' He was very respectful of other viewpoints, but also said he was generally against fixed ideas about anything and the best way to learn was to be flexible and open minded.

So I would be happy to go to a PP demo and think it would be really interesting, but would not leave my brain at the door and would evaluate what I saw for myself.

But that open attitude contrasts with my (admittedly fairly limited) experience of PNH. I had a friend who was one of the first UK Parelli trained instructors. She left and set up on her own because 'his word was God' and there was no room for individuality or disagreement or adapting the models. She was a fantastic horsewoman and learnt a huge amount from PP but it was the attitude of him and his more loyal (fanatical!) adherents that puts me off.

See, I think it's fascinating how people's opinions differ. All 3 of my Parelli instructors are open about the fact they have trained/studied or draw from different methods. People I've met, are friends with & spoken to from students and instructors alike are all similar. I'm going to see Mark Rashid this year with Parelli friends & I think a Parelli instructor is going to with our group.

One of my instructors is currently learning T-Touch & we've tried some with Pete, another uses Essential Oils routinely & another has spent lots of time with different trainers. It's quite common for the phrase 'This isn't strictly Parelli, but I think it'll help ...' to come up in my lessons.

I don't have all Parelli gear either - some things, I think are worth paying extra for. But for example, my carrot stick is a fake as Pete loves chewing on the handle - so for me, it's cheaper to buy a fake & replace it when it gets too manky! My instructors all know that & a agree, it's cheaper for my stick eating monkey :D

When I started Parelli, I was on a low-ish wage too - so I've done it on a normal salary too! As expense, is another thing I'm questioned on. My lessons range from £25 to £70 depending on whose teaching (I share a lesson with the 3* instructor with friends) - but the 2 I use most regularly are £25 for an hour/£30 for 90 minutes & £50 for 90 minutes, so they are comparable with other instructors.

All 3 of my instructors have encouraged me to check out different people & we often talk about various methods and stuff.

For me, finding PNH was the single best thing I've done. I've been involved for a couple of years, so I'm not sure how much it's changed since inception.

But, on the whole, I've only met normal people that care about horses & are want the best for them.

Of course, you get the people that do it badly or are fanatical about it or feel they have to rush off & buy everything with a Parelli logo on it. But, you get those people in all walks of life.

I'm not on a mission to convert or preach to anyone about it.

We are all on our own journey - but it's changed not only my horsey life, but me as a person, for the better. For that I will always be grateful :)
 
I totally agree, anything can be done badly, I just think NH attracts people who are avoiding a conflict with their horse/want a softly softly approach etc where jumping for eg. is less likely to. IMO NH isn't supposed to be softly, softly, its supposed to be minimal but effective communication, which occasionally involves telling a horse 'no, you got that wrong' which is the bit I see lots of people skipping but DO see the "founders" doing in their demos.
 
Learning to be more assertive, was one of the hardest things for me.

I'm not a natural leader & usually by the time I'd got to the stage of having to be assertive, it was difficult to do it without emotion. Not helped of course, by years of riding instructors going 'get cross/angry with them as they aren't doing it' - I didn't want to angry at my own horse, so of course it put me off being 'assertive'.

Having a very pushy, dominant horse - I had to learn to be a better leader, before I could get softness, connection & the communication I wanted. Well, actually - at first it was just about staying safe :D

It's only through learning & being shown how to be assertive, without emotional, that I learnt to become a better leader. But, for me - that was a very personal & emotional thing to have to come to grips with.

It's also been one of the most positive life lessons I've learnt - I've been promoted twice since learning it !
 
People who educated me on NR put Parelli (style) horsemanship on the list of those I should study. I watched everything with an open mind. And because Parelli centres on people who own horses and provides a step by step training programme for them, RS riders like myself cant really try it out.
However, when I read criticisms now of Parelli and his current wife, I cant take any particular stand Because there were things I gained, not from Parelli directly but from people who were influenced him.
My first sight of what I called horses behaving like dogs (I.e. free schooling, leading and following and jumping) belonged to Sue Gardener who brought them to the annual NH gathering. Thanks to her, my first horsemanship videos about how to handle horses on the ground and then ride them were from Australian Parelli riders, Rodney and Eisenhauer-Rodney, It All Starts from the Ground.
Similarly the NH groundwork teacher at our yard learned from Parelli influenced stockmen in Australia and gave me lessons, and my grand daughter too so she ended up riding bareback in a rope and halter.
It is hard for me to work out how I as a complete beginner gained so much pleasure and soft compliance from horses from a trainer with such a low reputation.

I would agree with what Wally says about showing someone how to do something doesnt always have the right result if they dont "get" it. I can ride out with someone who catches on to my Rashid ways - and can solve any problem following the slightest suggestion. Other people you can explain e.g. what Davidson (Dressage coach) advises, but they predict it wont work on their horse and then try it all wrong.
But where Parelli is concerned, it could be that if you remove his masculine force and the big whips and use instead the body language of old women and children, the horses react well to those much reduced cues? Tho most of his and other NH teaching is to help people with too little authority establish more secure boundaries.

And yes, Pete's Mum, if you are inviting people I would like one day to come and see you doing Parelli with your horse.
 
newrider.com